“Mother” Joaquín Sorolla Date: 1895; Spain
The Parturient’s Days of Purity: From Torah to Halacha
In reference to the parturient, the Torah speaks of a 33 or 66 day period of דמי טהרה “blood of her purity” as distinguished from a 7 or 14 day period “like menstruation.” What is the difference between these two periods according to Leviticus and how did later groups such as rabbinic Jews, Karaites, Samaritans, and Beta Israel understand it?
Published: April 26, 2017
|
Last Updated: September 7, 2026
[1] As she also transmits 7-day impurity to any man she is intimate with, who then transmits her impurity as if he were a menstruant, sex would also be avoided by her husband if he wished to remain pure or to have free access to the rest of the house, but this is much easier to avoid than touching pottery or sitting on chairs.
[2] See Avraham Faust and Hayah Katz, “The Archaeology of Purity and Impurity: A Case-Study from Tel ʿEton, Israel,” Cambridge Archaeological Journal 27.1 (2017): 1-27.
ויקרא כ:יח וְאִישׁ אֲשֶׁר־יִשְׁכַּב אֶת־אִשָּׁה דָּוָה וְגִלָּה אֶת־עֶרְוָתָהּ אֶת־מְקֹרָהּ הֶעֱרָה וְהִיא גִּלְּתָה אֶת־מְקוֹר דָּמֶיהָ וְנִכְרְתוּ שְׁנֵיהֶם מִקֶּרֶב עַמָּם׃
Lev 20:18 If a man lies with a woman in her infirmity and uncovers her nakedness, he has laid bare her flow and she has exposed her blood flow; both of them shall be cut off from among their people.
[4] Presumably, were the man to have sex with his wife during the tahara period, he would not contract impurity. For a detailed analysis of the distinction between P and H here and how this was dealt with by traditional commentators, see Eve Levavi Feinstein, “Sex during Menstruation: From Impurity to Prohibition,” TheTorah (2016).
For the purposes of this article, I include not only Karaite Jews and Falasha Jews, but also Samaritans. The latter group does not self-identify as Jews but as Israelites, but to constantly use “Torah observers” would be cumbersome.
Rashi’s paraphrase of this comment makes the point clearer:
בדמי טהרה – אף על פי שרואה [דם] טהורה.
With blood of tahara – even though she sees [blood] – she remains pure.
[7] See also Targum Pseudo-Jonathan (דמהא דכיין) and Neofiti (דם דדכי/דם דכי).
[8] The text appears in ch. 6 of part 2. This section has been translated from the Arabic in: Iain Ruairidh mac Mhanain Bóid, Principles of Samaritan Halachah (Studies in Judaism in Late Antiquity 38; Leiden: Brill, 1989), 168. See also Bóid’s discussion on pp. 297-298.
The Gan Eden passage continues with scriptural proofs of the Karaite interpretation:
וממאמר הכתוב שאמר על המטהר וישב מחוץ לאהלו שבעת ימים למדנו אסור ביאת האשה ר”ל שלא ישכב טמא עם טהורה ונאסר ביולדת תשב בדמי טהרה ומורה זה המאמר מניעתה מביאת איש
From the passage that states that a person in the process of becoming pure must dwell outside his tent for seven days, we learn that he is forbidden to his wife, i.e., that an impure man may not lie with a pure woman. The same is forbidden to a parturient woman [when it says] “she shall dwell in the blood of her purity.” This statement demonstrates that she is forbidden to be intimate with a man.
ונאמר עליה וטהרה ממקור דמיה ונאמר על הנדה והיא גלתה את מקור דמיה ומן שווי המלות למדנו אסור הביאה
It further states about her “she shall become pure from the source of her blood” and it says about a menstruant [who has relations] “and she reveals the source of her blood”. From the fact that these verses use the same phrase we learn that intimacy is forbidden.
Similarly, in his Seder Adderet Eliyahu (Seder Tumah ve-Tahara ch. 12), the 16th Century Karaite Sage, Eliyahu Bashyatchi attacks the rabbinic position, even making use of the same hyperbole used positively in the Lekach Tov:
מב[עלי] ה[קבלה] אמרו בשלשים ושלשה בזכר ובס”ו לנקבה היא טהורה לבעלה אפילו שופכת דם כנהר… ולפי הנראה שהם טהרוה לבעלה מן ההעתקה לא מפשטי הכתיב – וחכמי הקראים כלם טמאוה לבעלה והיא כמשפט הנדה בכל דבר לבד שהיא נכנסת במחנה באלה הל”ג ימים.
Some Rabbinic sages have said that a woman is pure [and thus permitted] to her husband during the 33 days for a male child and 66 days for a female, even if blood is flowing from her as a river… But it would seem that they declared her pure from “tradition” and not from the simple meaning of the verses. The Karaite sages have all declared her impure [and thus forbidden] to her husband, and she has the rules of a menstruant in all ways except for the fact that she may enter the camp during the 33 [or 66] day period.
[10] Sharon Shalom, From Sinai to Ethiopia (Tel Aviv: Miskal – Yedioth Ahronoth Books and Chemed Books, 2012), 256.
I am not referring to the custom of treating every woman who gave birth as a yoledet be-zov (a woman who gave birth while in the state of zavah impurity). Even though this often has the effect of forcing the couple to wait almost the entire period of tahara, this custom has its source in the general strictures on menstrual purity that developed during the Rabbinic period. Nevertheless, even this custom received some negative evaluation since it goes against the spirit of the days of tahara as the rabbis understand it. See, e.g., the argument of Rabbi Zerachiah ha-Levi (ca. 1125-1186) that applying this stricture to the birthing period is illegitimate (at least theoretically) in his glosses on Ba’alei ha-Nefesh (of Rabad), “Gate of Separation” (end of comment 2).
Technically, the bleeding would make the woman both a menstruant as well as a zavah.
The impurity of irregular vaginal bleeding described in Lev 15:25-30.
A white cloth the woman uses for internal checks to make sure there is no more vaginal blood.
Rabbi Ezekiel Landau, Noda bi-Yehuda 2nd ed., YD 113.
Rabbi Moses Maimonides, Mishneh Torah, Book of Holiness, Laws of Forbidden Sex, 11:14/15
The rabbinic interpretation found an advocate in the Leviticus scholar, Jacob Milgrom. In his Anchor Bible commentary (ad loc.), Milgrom brings up the position of the Samaritans and Karaites that intercourse is forbidden during this period, but argues against it:
The absence of any mention of ablution at the end of her purificatory period would then imply that none was necessary: the ablution after initial seven (or fourteen) days would allow her contact with the common, including intercourse with her husband, but not with the sacred… (ibid, 748-749).
Milgrom’s reading, however, superimposes two assumptions on the text that are not there. First, as noted above, as P and not an H text, Leviticus 12 never assumed that the woman was forbidden to her husband in the first place, making the debate between the rabbis and the Samaritans/Karaites artificial. Second, the text says nothing about ablutions after the 7/14 day period either. Milgrom believes that such a requirement is implied by the comparison of this first period of time to menstruation, but no ablution is mentioned in Lev 15 as necessary for menstruants either. Milgrom takes this requirement as a given, but as I argue in, “The Purification of a Niddah: The Torah Requirement” TheTorah (2014), and as Isaac Sassoon has argued in a number of places, including his, “The Purification of a Niddah: When Silence Matters” TheTorah (2014), it seems likely that the Priestly authors did not require ablution for female genital discharges. For a rejoinder, defending Milgrom’s position, see Yitzhaq Feder, “The Purification of a Niddah: The Legal Responsibility of the Reader,” TheTorah (2014). In any event, as Lev 12 makes no mention of ablution at all, it seems unwarranted to use the lack of mention after the period of 40 or 80 days of tahara as evidence that it should be distinguished from the 7 or 14 day period in this way.
b. San. 87b; b. Nid. 11b, 35b-36a.
הילכתא כוותיה דרב לחומרא, והלכתא כוותיה דלוי לחומרא. רב אשי אמר: הלכתא כוותיה דרב, בין לקולא בין לחומרא. דריש מרימר: הלכתא כוותיה דרב, בין לקולא בין לחומרא. והלכתא כוותיה דרב בין לקולא בין לחומרא.
[20] Jacob Milgrom (p. 749) argues that the attempt to distinguish between these two bloods based on physical properties derives from empirical observation and forms the basis for the biblical distinction:
The parturient’s blood discharge (lochia) is mentioned here three times (vv 4, 5, 7), emphasizing its long duration beyond the initial seven/fourteen day impurity. The first discharge is bright red, then turns brown and increasingly paler. The total discharge lasts from two to six weeks. Hence, the round figure of forty days is quite accurate. Moreover, the bright red of the initial discharge resembles the menstrual flow and is therefore treated as such…
(The final comment is based on Gordon Wenham’s gloss on this verse. See Gordon J. Wenham, The Book of Leviticus [The New International Commentary on the Old Testament (NICOT); Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1979.]) While Milgrom’s point is overall accurate, two problems arise with his analysis. First, it only applies to the bleeding period after male children; the 80 day period for female children is merely an artificial doubling of that of the males. Second, what he describes is just the phenomenon of blood flow diminishing. The same two stages could theoretically apply to any menstrual cycle.
Bekhor Shor continues:
ואז היא טמאה אפילו בלידה יבישתה, ולפי כי הדם מטהר, טהורה כל שלשים ושלשה לבעלה, שאין באותו דם זיהום שכבר יצא ונטהר הגוף, והבת יוצא עמה זיהום כפלים וטמאה כפלים ומטהרת הגוף כפליים, ואין דמה מזוהם עד ששים וששה… כל זה לא אמרתי אלא למסבר קראי ולתת לב למה זה טהור וזה טמא לבעלה, ומיהו לענין קודש ומקדש – לאו אורח ארעא, ואסר רחמנא אפילו דם טוהר.
This is why she is impure even in a dry birth (i.e., without bleeding), but since the bleeding cleanses, she is pure all thirty three days for her husband, since this blood does not contain any filth, since it exited [her body] already, and her body was cleansed. A daughter goes out with double the filth, and [the mother] is impure for double the time, and her blood does not include filth again for 66 days… All this I said in order to explain the scripture and to point out why one is pure and one impure to her husband. However, insofar as the holy and the temple – it would be improper conduct [for her to touch or enter while bleeding], and God forbade her [to do so], even if the blood was pure.
[22] Ramban (1194 – 1270) offers the same overall interpretation (ad loc.) as Bekhor Shor, explaining that the term ṭahara in the verse refers to cleansing.
והענין כי צוה ביולדת זכר שתטמא שבעה כנדתה, כי המנהג שתהיה שופעת דם מן המקור, וצוה שתוחיל עוד שלשים ושלשה ימים תשב בביתה לנקות גופה, כי בכל אלה תוציא תמצית הדמים והלחות העכורות המעופשות הבאות מתמצית הדם ואז תנקה מלידה ומבטן ומהריון ותבא בית ה’…
The reason that a woman who gave birth to a male was commanded to be impure seven days like her menstrual period is since it is usual for her to pour blood from the uterus [during this period]. And it was commanded that she sit another thirty three days in her house to cleanse her body, since during this period she will pass the blood essences and dark rotted liquids which come from blood essence, and then she will be clean from her birthing, from her womb and from her pregnancy and can come to the house of the Lord…
Yet another variation of the cleansing theory is mentioned by, among others, the Daat Zekenim mi-Baalei HaTosafot and Hezekiah ben Manoach (13th cent.), and is based on a medieval theory of conception called the seven-chambered uterus. See discussion in Edward Reichman, “Anatomy and the Doctrine of the Seven-Chamber Uterus in Rabbinic Literature,”Ḥakirah 9 (2010): 245-265.
Don Isaac Abarbanel (1437-1508) has a similar understanding:
והנה שבעת ימים האלה האשה על הרוב שופעת דם מן המקור מהמותרות שנשארו מהיצירה, אבל מפני שהאשה בהיותה מעוברת יפסק ממנה דם הנדות מדי חדש בחדשו, תשעה חדשים, עד שילדה, לכן צותה תורה שמלבד אלה שבעת הימים שתטמא כשתלד כימי נדת דותה עוד שלשים יום ושלשת ימים תשב בדמי טהרה כדי שבאותם הימים תנקה ויצא ממנה כל דם הנעצר ברחמה מן החדשים שלא עשתה נקיון בהיותה מעוברת.
In general, during these seven days, the woman’s blood pouring from the uterus is from the leftovers of the [blood utilized in] the formation [of the fetus]. However, since when a woman is pregnant her menstruation is forestalled every month, for nine months, until she gives birth, therefore the Torah commands that besides the seven days that she is impure like the days of her menstrual illness, she should wait for another thirty three days with the blood of her ṭahara, so that during those days she can be cleaned out of all the blood which has been stopped up in her uterus from the months where she did not have an [internal] cleansing due to her pregnancy.
[24] Since R. David ha-Adani’s Midrash ha-Gadol is mostly a compendium of earlier midrashic works, the assumption has been that he is quoting someone here. However, both the editor of the critical edition (Adin Steinsaltz) as well as Menahem Kasher (Torah Shleimaad loc. 60) are unable to locate an earlier source.
Ha-Adani continues:
וכן הוא אומר: ”בין דם לדם“ – בין דם טמא לדם טהור. הא אין הדבר תלוי בדמים אלא בימים; יש עת רואה והוא טמא ויש עת רואה והוא טהור.
For thus it is stated (Deut 17:8): “between blood and blood”– between impure blood and pure blood. The matter is not dependent upon blood but upon days; there is a time when she bleeds and [the blood] is impure, and there is a time when she bleeds and [the blood] is pure.
This last sentence is playing off of Ecclesiastes 3:1-8.