Each Man Does What Is Right in His Eyes: Deuteronomy 12:8—A Crux Interpretum

Was sacrifice centralized in the Tabernacle in the wilderness, or were the people permitted to sacrifice wherever they pleased? This straightforward question defies a simple answer.

SBL Style

Click to copy

"Each Man Does What Is Right in His Eyes: Deuteronomy 12:8—A Crux Interpretum." TheTorah.com, August 5, 2026. https://www.thetorah.com/article/each-man-does-what-is-right-in-his-eyes-deuteronomy-128-a-crux-interpretum.

APA Style

Click to copy

"Each Man Does What Is Right in His Eyes: Deuteronomy 12:8—A Crux Interpretum" (2026, August 5). TheTorah.com. https://www.thetorah.com/article/each-man-does-what-is-right-in-his-eyes-deuteronomy-128-a-crux-interpretum

Each Man Does What Is Right in His Eyes: Deuteronomy 12:8—A Crux Interpretum

The Tabernacle (adapted), The Bible and its story, 1908. Wikimedia

Categories:

Re’eh

Published: August 5, 2026

|

Last Updated: October 28, 2026

  1. This refers to an offering that is partially consumed by the person who brought it, as opposed to an offering burnt entirely upon the altar.

  2. This is a surprising assertion in view of a tannaitic dispute as to whether they sanctified firstlings in the wilderness (b. Bekhorot 4a). Also, Talmudic sources indicate that the Hagigah offering was brought in the wilderness (b. Hagigah 6a). As to festival offerings, here too, Nahmanides’ position is unique, holding that these only became obligatory when the Temple was built, once they arrived at the allotted haven, and not in the period when the Tabernacle was current. See Maimonides, Mishneh Torah, “Bet haBehirah” 1:1, and see R. Joseph Karo’s commentary, Kesef Mishneh, citing Semag.

  3. In rabbinic understanding, the dispensation to slaughter animals for food consumption outside of the centralized sanctuary became effective only after they built a Temple (12:15, 21–22) and not immediately after they entered the Promised Land. Netziv simply states ודבר זה נאסר בארץ ישראל שהותר בשר תאוה שחוטה, “and this thing was forbidden in the land of Israel, where meat slaughtered for personal use was permitted,” possibly implying that the slaughter of animals for food became permissible right after their entry to the Land.

  4. On nominal clauses, see Paul L. Joüon and Takamitsu Muraoka, A Grammar of Biblical Hebrew, 2nd ed., repr. with corr. of 2006 (Editrice Pontifico Instituto Biblico, 2009), §154.

  5. Rashi is building on the less explicit midrash in the Sifrei (3rd cent. C.E.):

    ספרי דברים פיסקא סה "לא תעשון ככל אשר אנחנו עושים פה היום"—היום אנו מטלטלים את המשכן היום אנו אסורים בבמה משנבוא לארץ אין אנו אסורים בבמה.
    Sifrei Deut §65 “You shall not do according to everything that we are doing here today”—today we are carrying around the Tabernacle and today we are forbidden to make offerings on high places; when we enter the land, we shall no longer be prohibited from offering on high places.
    "איש כל הישר בעיניו"—כל שנידר ונידב קרב בבמת יחיד, וכל שאין נידר ונידב אין קרב בבמת יחיד.
    “Every man what is right in his own eyes”—whoever made a vow or gift can offer it upon a local high place, but anything that is not a vow or a gift may not be offered on a local high place.
  6. Here he hedges a bit because of the rabbinic tradition:

    הופמן דברים יב:ח אמנם קבלו רבותינו שרק בגלגל הותרו הבמות, כמו ששנינו במשנתנו, אבל בכל זאת יתכן שגם לפני זה לא נזהרו באיסור הזה, כאשר בטל טעמו. אם כן הביטוי ״איש כל הישר בעיניו״ יש בו משום נזיפה, אבל בכל זאת אין זאת עבירה חמורה כל כך...
    Hoffmann Deut 12:8 Admittedly, the rabbinic tradition is that high places only became permitted at Gilgal, as was taught in our Mishnah (Zevachim ch. 14) but even so, it would see that even before this they were not careful about this prohibition, once the reason for it disappeared. If so, the expression, “every man according to all that was right in his eyes” had a bit of rebuke to it, but even so, it was not such a serious sin.

    Given Hoffmann’s rejection of ibn Ezra’s suggestion that the verse was a rebuke, this is a surprising concession.

  7. Perhaps modern scholars may want to characterize the phrase “every man doing what is right in his own eyes” as a late, midrashically inspired scribal interpolation, to hint to the future reader that such a tradition existed. If so, the addition created an awkward transition.

  8. Recognizing this fact has an important methodological consequence. It encourages caution before drawing broader historical or theological conclusions from the passage. Source-critical arguments, harmonizing readings, and rabbinic interpretations alike all rest upon literary decisions whose own adequacy remains open to question. Before the passage can be enlisted in larger debates concerning the development of Israelite worship or the relationship between Deuteronomy and Leviticus, its own internal difficulties must first be acknowledged.