Does the Torah Really Want Us to Appoint a King?

Throughout the Torah, Israel is warned not to imitate the surrounding nations. Yet Deuteronomy speaks of the people appointing a king if they want to be “like all the nations” around them. Is YHWH commanding Israel to appoint a king or just reluctantly permitting it?

SBL Style

Click to copy

"Does the Torah Really Want Us to Appoint a King?." TheTorah.com, September 2, 2016. https://www.thetorah.com/article/does-the-torah-really-want-us-to-appoint-a-king.

APA Style

Click to copy

"Does the Torah Really Want Us to Appoint a King?" (2016, September 2). TheTorah.com. https://www.thetorah.com/article/does-the-torah-really-want-us-to-appoint-a-king

Does the Torah Really Want Us to Appoint a King?

King Josiah Hears the Book of the Law. Julius Schnorr von Carolsfeld 1858

Categories:

Shoftim

Published: September 2, 2016

|

Last Updated: October 28, 2026

  1. See also:

    Eating matzah and removing chametz

    שמות יג:ה וְהָיָה כִי יְבִיאֲךָ יְ־הוָה אֶל אֶרֶץ הַכְּנַעֲנִי… וְעָבַדְתָּ אֶת הָעֲבֹדָה הַזֹּאת בַּחֹדֶשׁ הַזֶּה.
    Exod 13:5 When YHWH has brought you into the land of the Canaanites… you shall observe in this month the following practice:

    The Sabbatical Year

    ויקרא כה:ב כִּי תָבֹאוּ אֶל הָאָרֶץ אֲשֶׁר אֲנִי נֹתֵן לָכֶם וְשָׁבְתָה הָאָרֶץ שַׁבָּת לַי־הוָה.
    Lev 25:2 When you enter the land that I assign to you, the land shall observe a sabbath of YHWH.

    Inheriting the Land

    דברים ו:י וְהָיָה כִּי יְבִיאֲךָ יְ־הוָה אֱלֹהֶיךָ אֶל הָאָרֶץ אֲשֶׁר נִשְׁבַּע לַאֲבֹתֶיךָ… ו:יב הִשָּׁמֶר לְךָ פֶּן תִּשְׁכַּח אֶת יְ־הוָה אֲשֶׁר הוֹצִיאֲךָ מֵאֶרֶץ מִצְרַיִם מִבֵּית עֲבָדִים.
    Deut 6:10 When YHWH your God brings you into the land that He swore to your fathers… 6:12 take heed that you do not forget YHWH who freed you from the land of Egypt, the house of bondage.

    The blessing and curse ceremony

    דברים יא:כט וְהָיָה כִּי יְבִיאֲךָ יְ־הוָה אֱלֹהֶיךָ אֶל הָאָרֶץ אֲשֶׁר אַתָּה בָא שָׁמָּה לְרִשְׁתָּהּ וְנָתַתָּה אֶת הַבְּרָכָה עַל הַר גְּרִזִים וְאֶת הַקְּלָלָה עַל הַר עֵיבָל.
    Deut 11:29 When YHWH your God brings you into the land that you are about to enter and possess, you shall pronounce the blessing at Mount Gerizim and the curse at Mount Ebal.

    No idolatrous practices

    דברים יח:ט כִּי אַתָּה בָּא אֶל הָאָרֶץ אֲשֶׁר יְ־הוָה אֱלֹהֶיךָ נֹתֵן לָךְ לֹא תִלְמַד לַעֲשׂוֹת כְּתוֹעֲבֹת הַגּוֹיִם הָהֵם.
    Deut 18:9 When you enter the land that YHWH your God is giving you, you shall not learn to imitate the abhorrent practices of those nations.

    In fact, even when the Torah includes a conditional clause in the opening of the law, this is never an expression of an option; the opening condition is always something that will happen inevitably.

    Orlah, i.e., not eating fruit for three years

    ויקרא יט:כג וְכִי תָבֹאוּ אֶל הָאָרֶץ וּנְטַעְתֶּם כָּל עֵץ מַאֲכָל וַעֲרַלְתֶּם עָרְלָתוֹ אֶת פִּרְיוֹ שָׁלֹשׁ שָׁנִים יִהְיֶה לָכֶם עֲרֵלִים לֹא יֵאָכֵל.
    Lev 19:23 When you enter the land and plant any tree for food, you shall regard its fruit as forbidden. Three years it shall be forbidden for you, not to be eaten.

    Omer, bringing first gleanings to the priests

    ויקרא כג:י כִּי תָבֹאוּ אֶל הָאָרֶץ אֲשֶׁר אֲנִי נֹתֵן לָכֶם וּקְצַרְתֶּם אֶת קְצִירָהּ וַהֲבֵאתֶם אֶת עֹמֶר רֵאשִׁית קְצִירְכֶם אֶל הַכֹּהֵן.
    Lev 23:10 When you enter the land that I am giving to you and you reap its harvest, you shall bring the first sheaf of your harvest to the priest.

    Although “planting” and “reaping” are conditions—without any fruit or grains these mitzvot cannot be accomplished, nevertheless, they aren’t really options. Of course, the Israelites will plant and harvest.

  2. The NJPS translation elides this with its, “you shall be free to set a king” as opposed to the usual approach with cognate/tautological infinitives, “you shall surely set.”

  3. שום תשים עליך מלך. ע”ד הפשט זו מצות עשה שיהיה בישראל מלך.
    “You shall surely appoint for yourselves a king”—by way of peshat, this is a positive commandment that Israel have a king.
  4. והמצוה הקע”ג היא שצונו למנות עלינו מלך מישראל יקבץ כל אומתינו וינהיגנו. והוא אמרו ית’ (דברים יז:טו) שום תשים עליך מלך. וכבר קדם לנו לשונם בספרי [ע"ז] שלש מצות נצטוו ישראל בכניסתן לארץ למנות להם מלך ולבנות להם בית הבחירה ולהכריע זרעו שלעמלק. ולשון ספרי ג”כ שום תשים עליך מלך מצות עשה.
    The 173rd commandment is that we are commanded to appoint upon ourselves a king of Israel who will gather all of our nation and rule it. This is what He, the blessed one, said (Deut 17:15) “You shall surely appoint for yourselves a king.” Already the Sages stated in the Sifrei (67): “Israel was commanded with three commandments when they entered the land: To appoint a king, to build the Temple, and to deal definitively with the seed of Amalek.” The language of the Sifrei also implies that “appoint for yourselves a king” is a commandment.

    Rambam’s position appears to have shifted over time. Thus, later in life, when he wrote the Mishneh Torah, Rambam was of the opinion that the obligation was to appoint a Jewish king only if the Israelites wanted to appoint one. He even “corrected” the title in his updated edition of the Sefer HaMitzvot to reflect his new position (see Hayim Heller’s edition of the Sefer HaMitzvot for the differences), though he kept the body of the comment in the Sefer haMitzvot as it was. For a detailed discussion of this, see Albert Dov Friedberg, Crafting the 613 Commandments: Maimonides on the Enumeration, Classification, and Formulation of the Scriptural Commandments (Academic Studies Press, 2013), 307-313.

  5. See also,

    דברים יג:ז כִּי יְסִיתְךָ אָחִיךָ… בַּסֵּתֶר לֵאמֹר נֵלְכָה וְנַעַבְדָה אֱלֹהִים אֲחֵרִים אֲשֶׁר לֹא יָדַעְתָּ אַתָּה וַאֲבֹתֶיךָ. יג:ח מֵאֱלֹהֵי הָעַמִּים אֲשֶׁר סְבִיבֹתֵיכֶם הַקְּרֹבִים אֵלֶיךָ אוֹ הָרְחֹקִים מִמֶּךָּ מִקְצֵה הָאָרֶץ וְעַד קְצֵה הָאָרֶץ. יג:ט לֹא תֹאבֶה לוֹ וְלֹא תִשְׁמַע אֵלָיו וְלֹא תָחוֹס עֵינְךָ עָלָיו וְלֹא תַחְמֹל וְלֹא תְכַסֶּה עָלָיו.יג:י כִּי הָרֹג תַּהַרְגֶנּוּ…
    Deut 13:7 If your brother… entices you in secret, saying, “Come let us worship other gods”—whom neither you nor your fathers have experienced — 13:8 from among the gods of the peoples around you, either near to you or distant, anywhere from one end of the earth to the other: 13:9 do not assent or give heed to him. Show him no pity or compassion, and do not shield him; 13:10 but take his life…
  6. For more on Deuteronomy as the Torah, both in Deuteronomy itself and in the Deuteronomistic History, see David Glatt-Gilad, “Deuteronomy: The First Torah” TheTorah (2015). For more on the theory of the Deuteronomistic History, see Martin Noth, The Deuteronomistic History, JSOTsupp 15 (Sheffield: Sheffield University Press, 1981 [German ed., 1943]). For a critique of Noth’s DtrH model, see, Thomas Römer, The So-Called Deuteronomistic History: A Sociological, Historical, and Literary Introduction (T&T Clark, 2007), 79-80.

  7. For a detailed discussion of this double editing, see Richard Nelson, The Double Redaction of the Deuteronomistic History, JSOTsupp 18 (Sheffield: Sheffield Academic Press, 1981); and Richard Elliott Friedman, The Exile and Biblical Narrative: The Formation of the Deuteronomic and Priestly Works, Harvard Semitic Monographs 22 (Scholars Press, 1981).

  8. One of the clearest pieces of evidence for this comes from 30:1-10, which discusses return from exile, something that the pre-exilic ch. 28 never envisioned. For more on this, see Marc Zvi Brettler, “Comparing Curses,” TheTorah (2016); idem, “Is Israel’s Repentance a Foregone Conclusion?” TheTorah (2016).

  9. Most source critical scholars, when discussing this text, assume that the entire law is of a piece, and that it was either composed during the Josianic period or the exilic/post-exilic period. Since the law is decidedly negative about kings, many current scholars are choosing the latter. Thomas Römer, for example, writes:

    …[T]he presence of such a law in the Josianic edition of Deuteronomy would be astonishing… even if the ‘Josianic reform’ was strongly supported by the Deuteronomists, they would not so openly restrict the king’s power in an ‘official’ publication (Römer, The So-Called Deuteronomistic History, 79-80).

    Römer is undoubtedly correct, but what he does not address is the problematic conditional opening, either literarily: it reads awkwardly (as discussed above), or conceptually: why not forbid kings entirely, or say that they can only be appointed by one of YHWH’s prophets and not at the people’s request? Insofar as Römer’s point that limiting the amount of the king’s horses and wives seems impossible in this context, I would respond by suggesting that these two verses are also part of the redaction, but the division of the passage will have to wait for another piece.

  10. Cyprus and Phoenecia, for example, still had kings. See Pierre Briant, From Cyrus to Alexander: A History of the Persian Empire, trans. Peter T. Daniels (Eisenbrauns, 2002), 411.

  11. Joseph Blenkinsopp, Judaism: The First Phase (Eerdmans, 2009), 155-156.

  12. The rest of ch. 10 (vv. 17-27) contains more of the negative layer, plus further redactions to connect to both the positive account and the originally independent story of Saul’s battle against Nahash king of Ammon in ch. 11.