Echoes of Maimonides’ View in Medieval Biblical Interpretation
Published: May 14, 2014
|
Last Updated: September 7, 2026
My general impression from reading his commentary is that Nachmanides recognizes the uniqueness and special significance of different parts of the Torah. I hope to write about this in the future.
He offers a similar explanation of Haazinu (Deut 32, ad loc.).
See Uriel Simon, “Two Grab Hold of R. Abraham ibn Ezra’s ‘Secret of the Twelve,’”Megadim 51 (Iyar 5770) [Hebrew]. See also Eran Viezel, “The Divine Content (te’amim) and the Words (milot) of Moses: R. Abraham Ibn Ezra on Moses’ Role in Writing the Torah,” Tarbiz 80.3 (5770): 387–407 [Hebrew]. For more on ibn Ezra’s secret see Zev Farber’s TABS essay, “Ibn Ezra’s Secret: Late Editorial Comments in the Opening Chapters of Deuteronomy.“ For a different take on the underlying assumptions of ibn Ezra and Bonfils, see Rabbi Yuval Cherlow’s TABS essay, “The Authorship of the Torah: The Position of Ibn Ezra and R. Yehuda Hachasid.“With respect to Rashbam’s view on this topic, Eran Viezel, “Rashbam’s Position on the Question of the Place of Moses in Writing the Torah,” Cheker haMikra Ve-Mizrach haKadum (5773): 167–88 [Hebrew].
See Gershon Berin, “Outlines of R. Judah the Pious’ Commentary on Torah,” Teudah 3, (5743) [Hebrew].
This is also the way R. Bonfils understands the passage in Sanhedrin. See TABS essay “The Significance of Ibn Ezra’s Position that Verses were Added to the Torah” and “Seven Torah Passages of Non-Mosaic Origin According to Ibn Ezra and R. Joseph Bonfils.”
Tzafenat Paneah Genesis 12:6. He basis his words on hints at various points in Ibn Ezra’s commentary.
Bonfils refers to the problem that is liable to arise as a result of evaluating the nature of prophecy. He writes at the beginning of the passage quoted above: “Because we have to believe in the words of the received tradition (kabbalah) and the words of prophecy, why should it matter whether Moses or another prophet wrote it, since all of them are true and prophetic?”