How Did Abraham Discover God? The Experiential Approach

The midrashic Parable of the Illuminated Palace concerns Abraham and the existence of God. In Part 1, we looked at Maimonides rationalistic, Aristotelian approach. Alternative interpretations focus on the idea of an experiential, living relationship with God.

SBL Style

Click to copy

"How Did Abraham Discover God? The Experiential Approach." TheTorah.com, October 6, 2013. https://www.thetorah.com/article/how-did-abraham-discover-god-the-experiential-approach.

APA Style

Click to copy

"How Did Abraham Discover God? The Experiential Approach" (2013, October 6). TheTorah.com. https://www.thetorah.com/article/how-did-abraham-discover-god-the-experiential-approach

How Did Abraham Discover God? The Experiential Approach

‘אור ה (“The Light of the Lord”) by Rabbi Hasdai Crescas

Categories:

Lech Lecha

Published: October 6, 2013

|

Last Updated: October 28, 2026

  1. Most famous as the author of Hiddushei ha-Ran and Derashot ha-Ran (1320-1376). Rabbenu Nissim Gerondi and Rabbi Hasdai Crescas were the rabbinic leaders and halakhic authorities of Spain during their respective lifetimes. However, probably because of the horrific circumstances under which he lived, Crescas never composed the great halakhic work that he planned. Or Hashem was meant to be part one of a two-part work called Ner Elohim: The first part (Or Hashem) is constructed as an alternative to Maimonides’ Guide, and the planned second part (Ner Mitzvah) was meant to replace Maimonides’ Mishneh Torah (!). The second part was never written. Crescas devoted his life not to writing, but to rebuilding Jewish communities in Spain that were shattered during the fierce persecutions of 1391. For some background on the school of the Ran, see the first chapter of my dissertation, The Book of Abraham: Rabbi Shimon ben Zemah Duran and the School of Rabbenu Nissim Gerondi(University of Haifa, 2006).

  2. For an in-depth analysis of ikkarim and “books of principles of the Torah” in the school of Rabbenu Nissim Gerondi, see the third chapter of my dissertation. For a full history of Jewish dogma from its beginnings through Abarbanel’s Rosh Amanah, see the book by my teacher and friend Menachem Kellner, Dogma in Medieval Jewish Thought (Oxford University Press, 1986).

  3. In parts one and two of the First Treatise, Crescas dealt extensively with a wide variety of matters from physics to metaphysics, and from mathematics to the careful use of scientific language, most of which would seem at first glance to be foreign to a book called “The Light of the Lord” about the principles of the Torah. But it is helpful to remember that in the middle ages the word “philosophy” incorporated the entire corpus of rational inquiry or systematic thinking, including all of what we call “science” today, and that “philosophy” as a whole was the primary intellectual challenge to traditional Judaism.

  4. My use of “non-dogmatic” here is an attempt to convey Crescas’ goal in Or Hashem of leaving open as many intellectual options as possible. In terms of the Torah, this means not to claim anything in the name of the Torah that the Torah does not clearly and absolutely claim for itself. In terms of rational inquiry or science, it means not to claim anything in the name of reason that reason itself does not firmly establish. For instance, can one ascribe positive attributes to God? According to Crescas, neither the Torah nor rational inquiry negate that possibility. Can there be an “actual infinity”? One can use try to use reason to negate the idea (as did Aristotle), but the arguments are not convincing. In our case, does the nature of universe “prove” that it has a First Cause in the Aristotelian sense? According to Crescas neither the Torah nor rational human inquiry insist that this is so.

  5. Or Hashem as a whole is characterized by extreme brevity, but its terse text contains the some of the most profound ideas in medieval Jewish philosophy. It is surpassed only by Maimonides’ Guide in its combination of originality and high quality argumentation.

  6. Natan Alterman homed in on this point in his light-hearted poem “The Little Cleric” (הקלריקל הקטן). The world naturally inspires wonder in children (and sometimes even in adults). The questions that it inspires, and the places they can lead, may sometimes be troubling for parents, as for the atheistic couple in Alterman’s poem who listen to their child in horror, as his questions make him sound like a primitive religious fanatic to their ears. At the same time, as the poem acknowledges, things can also move in the opposite direction. But honest struggling with questions is healthy regardless of where they may lead: “No Marxist ever grew up in an incubator… And besides, those concerned have forgotten, for they too were once Little Clerics! But it was no tragedy, because there is One who cares and takes pity: They grew up Epikorsim, thank God!” The poem is from The Seventh Column, vol. 1 (Tel Aviv: Hakibbutz Hameuhad, 1973), pp. 200-202 (Hebrew); the text can be found below in the comments section. There is no question that Alterman was influenced by the midrashic model of Abram as a youth.

  7. The most that can possibly be established about God through reason, according to Crescas, is limited and stunted. In Or Hashem I:3:3 he sums up his position by saying that the universe—the totality of nature and causality, whether it is finite or infinite—is in itself nothing more than a contingent possibility that can either exist or not. What can therefore be said is that there must be some sort of a “switch” that turns reality on. This is a far cry from both the isolated grandeur of the Aristotelian God who is an incorporeal intellect, and the powerfully involved God of the Torah who is a personality.

  8. Joshua Berman eloquently expressed this idea in a short video that used to be found in a personal website devoted to his book, Created Equal. The point was that coming from an Orthodox Jewish perspective can be an advantage for a serious scholar, even (and perhaps especially) in a field like biblical scholarship that often involves direct, acute tension at the very core of Jewish tradition.

  9. For more on Crescas as a scientist, and on dealing with the tensions between Torah and science, see my essay found here (a bit of which has been lifted into the current text).

  10. How this general attitude played out in various competing systems of ikkarim will be explored in future essays; this is the first installment of what I plan to be a series. I will continue with further installments, God willing, as time and opportunity permit. A highly tentative (and evolving) list of general topics and various specific points that I would like to address in the future may be found here (comments and suggestions are welcome). For those who would like to read more in the meantime about how and why the medieval critique of Maimonides’ ikkarim developed, see chapter 3 of my dissertation.