Yeshiva student / image by TheTorah.com with AI
My Personal Struggle with Unreasonable Belief
Torah Mi-Sinai and other dogmas compelled me to reconsider my place within the Orthodox world.
Published: December 9, 2014
|
Last Updated: September 7, 2026
This essay is an updated and adapted excerpt from, Solomon Schimmel, The Tenacity of Unreasonable Beliefs: Fundamentalism and the Fear of Truth (Oxford University Press, 2008). Two more book excerpts will be posted shortly.
Whether at Mount Sinai or during the wilderness sojourn is immaterial.
Luckily, this aggressive and demeaning approach was not shared by my parents, such that my resentment never extended to them. Although admittedly pained by my non-Orthodox beliefs as an adult—and in the case of my mother, frequently critical of me for them—they did not “reject” me. But I was lucky in this regard. Many “rebels” against Orthodoxy are also rebelling against parents who were punitive and unloving in their transmission of Orthodox tradition, especially its rules and regulations. I once had a lengthy conversation with an activist in an anti-Haredi organization. He spoke of his deep resentment toward his right-wing, domineering, Orthodox father, with whom his childhood relationship was troubled and unhappy. I pointed out to him that his polemic and crusade against the Haredi world is really a way of ‘‘getting even’’ with, or continuing his long-standing battle with, his deceased father. He acknowledged that there was a psychological truth in what I had noted.
I did later encounter fear of divine punishment and (greater) obsessiveness with halakhic performance in some of the “right wing” yeshivot that I attended.
I am aware that these are merely fragments of memories. They leave out much of what ‘‘really happened’’ and most of what was unconscious, but it is the best that I can do.
College was something I attended to satisfy my parents (although I did enjoy my studies very much).
To be clear, although I bear resentment toward some teachers who did not respond to my doubts with the empathy and honesty I hoped for, for the most part I have positive feelings about my religious home environment and the yeshivot in which I had spent many months and years studying Torah. I had, and still have, affection for some of my teachers, who were to me positive models of mussar (a high level of ethical sensitivity and behavior) and of genuine concern for the spiritual and Talmudic development of their students, me no less than many others.
I also was not aware that there were thoughtful non-Orthodox models for Jewish living and commitment, whether religious or secular. I did not know that serious and knowledgeable Jewish thinkers had tried to respond to the questions that gnawed at me while they remained strongly identifying, though not Orthodox, Jews.
During the past 250 years, hundreds of thousands of Jews who were socialized in traditional or Orthodox homes and cultures experienced challenges to their religious beliefs and practices. Some resisted and warded off these challenges; others reformulated their beliefs so as to feel that they were compatible with modernity—especially the neo- or modern Orthodox, Conservative, and Reform Jews, as well as other non-Orthodox Jews, who defined themselves as religious. Some Jews ‘‘succumbed’’ to the challenges of modernity, professing agnosticism, atheism, or secular humanistic Judaism. My story is for the most part but a variation on a recurring theme experienced by myriad others.
For example, I have worked on a reassessment of the concept of man’s uniqueness as a creature in the image of God, in light of evolutionary theory and genetics. Such a reassessment may require radical revisions of long-held principles that are foundations of our moral and social order.