Song of Songs (detail), Enrico Salfi, ca. 1900-1930. Wikimedia
A Nitpicking Lover in Song of Songs 1:7
The woman in Song of Songs wishes to know where her lover will be, asking: “Why should I be like an ʿōṭǝyâ (כְּעֹטְיָה).” Translators struggle with this phrase, and suggest meanings as disparate as “be veiled like a prostitute,” “be as a wanderer,” or even “pick at my nits.” How do scholars use ancient translation, cognate words, and content to translate a word in the Bible whose meaning is so obscure?
Published: April 13, 2022
|
Last Updated: September 7, 2026
I would like to thank Matthew Arakaky for his assistance with this article. While this article primarily deals with the meaning of one word, my goal is to use the approach to this question to illustrate what a day (or several days) of a biblical scholar who sits in the library and deals with texts look like. It is thus a companion piece to Zev Farber’s “Digging Archaeology – A Report from the Trenches,” TheTorah (2014).
I heard this anecdote from my friend and colleague, Prof. Mark Smith of Princeton Theological Seminary.
When translating a contemporary language, we can ask native speakers (linguists call these “informants”) what a word or phrase means, but we have no native speakers of biblical Hebrew.
Michael Fishbane, Song of Songs, JPS Bible Commentary (Philadelphia: JPS, 2015), 38; so Yair Zakovitch, The Song of Songs: Introduction and Commentary, Miqra’ Liyisra’el (Tel-Aviv: Am Oved, 1992), 53 [Heb.] (קשׁה).
Duane Garrett and Paul R. House, Song of Songs and Lamentations, WBC (Nashville: Thomas Nelson, 2004), 135 n. 7.b.
Scott B. Noegel and Gary A. Rendsburg, Solomon's Vineyard: Literary and Linguistic Studies in the Song of Songs (Atlanta: SBL, 2009), 190 n. f. Some understate the problem; for example, Christian David Ginsburg (The Song of Songs and Coheleth [1857; repr. NY: Ktav, 1970], 135) says that it “has caused much perplexity to interpreters”; Marvin Pope, (Song of Songs, AB [Garden City, NY: Doubleday, 1977], 330) notes that it “has occasioned some difficulty”; and Roland E. Murphy (The Song of Songs, Hermeneia [Minneapolis: Fortress, 1990], 131) says “the meaning is not obvious in the context.”
The term comes for Greek ἅπαξ λεγόμενον, “being said once.” Biblical scholars often abbreviate this as “hapax.”
A participle is a form that is used verbally and nominally.
The Jewish medieval grammarians typically noted the root as עטה (ʿṭh), and the modern biblical lexica follow the convention of these grammarians, which base the root on the 3ms Qal form. From a historical perspective, however, these are third yod verbs; see e.g., JM §79a, and note forms such as בָּנוּי and בוֹכִיָּה, where the original yod is preserved—as it is in the word עֹטְיָה.
I am leaving aside its Aramaic use in Daniel 2:14.
Note the comment of one of the great scholars of biblical style, Arnold B. Ehrlich, Randglossen zur hebräischen Bibel (Leipzig: J. C. Hinrichs'sche Buchhandlung, 1914), 7.3–4, after explaining all the other words in the verse writes: “כעטיה aber ist undeutbar. Das fragliche Wort is verschrieben, and das Ursprüngliche lässt sich nicht mehr ermitteln.” “כעטיה, however, is undefinable. The word in question is an error, and the original can no longer be determined.”
The Torah was the first part of what became the Bible that was translated into Greek, in the third century BCE. Other books were translated later. For the likely date of the translation of the Song, see Bénédicte Lemmelijn, “Canticles,” in Textual History of the Bible, The Hebrew Bible Vol. 1C, ed. Amrin Lange and Emanuel Tov (Leiden: Brill, 2017), 323. The Septuagint (LXX) is by far the most important ancient version, both for understanding the textual history of the Bible, and its most ancient interpretations. Originally, this term referred specifically to the translation of the Torah only into Greek, but it became the term for the main Greek translation of the Old Testament. (I use this term on purpose, since it is used for the books in the OT that are not in the Hebrew Bible, the deutero-canonical or apocryphal books.)
Unlike English “wrap” where the object is preceded with the preposition “with,” in Hebrew this word typically takes a direct object. Other constructs are possible, however. See, e.g., Ps 109:19, תְּהִי־ל֭וֹ כְּבֶ֣גֶד יַעְטֶ֑ה, “Let it be like the cloak he wraps around him.” And note the Hiphil use in Isaiah 59:17.
The root is also used in the idiom וְעַל־שָׂפָ֖ם יַעְטֶ֑ה, he shall cover his upper lip (Lev 13:45 with variants at Ezek 24:17, 22 and Mic 3:7), where it takes an indirect object.
Cynthia L. Miller-Naudé, “Ellipsis: Biblical Hebrew,” EHLL 1.807.
Miller-Naudé, 807–812.
See, e.g., Elie Assis, Flashes of Fire: A Literary Analysis of the Song of Songs, HLB/OTS 503 (NY: T & T Clark, 1994), 44: “The meaning of עֹטְיָה is ‘veiled.’”
Adin Even-Yisrael (Steinsalz), The Tanakh Explained, The Five Scrolls (Jerusalem: Koren, 2017), 220 [Hebrew].
The most extensive discussion of this is Karel van der Toorn, “The Significance of the Veil in the Ancient Near East,” in Pomegranates and Golden Bells: Studies in Biblical, Jewish, and Near Eastern Ritual, Law, and Literature in Honor of Jacob Milgrom, ed. David P. Wright et al. (Winona Lake, IN; Eisenbrauns, 1995), 327–39; see esp. 328: “What is normally referred to by the ancients as a veil is a piece of cloth covering the head and partially concealing the face; the eyes and the cheeks were usually left exposed.” This is not a “veil” in our current use of the word.
Giszczak, “Song of Songs 1,7—What King of Wrapping?” 58–70 [p. 58].
So, e.g., Pope, Song of Songs, 330–331. Note Gianni Barbiero, Song of Songs: A Close Reading, trans. Michael Tait, SVT 144 (Leiden: Brill, 20110 66, “the veil was the distinctive mark of the prostitute.”
Murphy (The Song of Songs, 131) actually suggests “to disguise oneself” in keeping with this use of the veil. He is followed by Tremper Longman III, Song of Songs, NICOT (Grand Rapids, MI: Eerdmans, 2001), 100–101.
Fox, Song of Songs and the Ancient Egyptian Love Songs, 103.
See Esther Marie Menn, Judah and Tamar (Genesis 38) in Ancient Jewish Sources: Studies in Literary Form and Hermeneutics, SJSJ 51 (Leiden: Brill, 1997), 72–73 and Laura Quick, Dress, Adornment, and the Body in the Hebrew Bible (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2021), 98–99. See also Mark Giszczak, “Song of Songs 1,7—What King of Wrapping?” RB 122/1 (2015), 58: “Prostitution, with its many toxic associations, has no place in a love poem.” The prostitute suggestion was already trenchantly critiqued in Ginsburg, The Song of Songs and Coheleth, 135.
The exact date of this translation, and whether it was originally a Jewish work, are debated. See Ignacio Carbajosa, “Peshitta,” in Textual History of the Bible, The Hebrew Bible Vol. 1C, ed. Amrin Lange and Emanuel Tov (Leiden: Brill, 2016), 263–266.
It is also possible, even likely, that this Targum is understanding the word עֹ֣טְיָ֔ה from טעות, “error;” see the opinion of R. Berekhiah in Song of Songs Rabbah loc. cit., and the Targum’s למחב, “to sin.” This interpretation is also found in a Genizah fragment; see Zvi Meir Rabinovitz, Ginzé Midrash: The Oldest Forms of Rabbinic Midrashim According to Geniza Fragments (Tel-Aviv: The Chaim Rothberg School for Jewish Studies, 1976), 93, line 1, טעת. I would like to thank Dr. Tamar Kadari for taking the time to review this and other rabbinic material with me. The Targum of the Song is largely paraphrastic and extremely expansive relative to the Hebrew text of the Song, so it is more difficult to use in understanding how it understood specific words, though we can often surmise what meaning is being expanded upon. See the introductory sections of Philip S. Alexander, The Targum of Canticles (College, MN: Liturgical Press, 2003), and more briefly, Andrew W. Litke, Targum Song of Songs and Late Jewish Literary Aramaic: Language, Lexicon, Text, and Translation (Leiden: Brill, 2019), 226–228.
An alternative translation, also quoted in the name of Aquilas is or ἀπολελυμένη, “destroyed utterly.” See Fridericus Field, Origenis Hexaplorum quae supersunt (Oxford: Clarendon, 1875), 2.412, the apparatus to BHQ loc. cit., and p. 58*, and Mark Giszczak, “Song of Songs 1,7—What Kind of Wrapping?” RB 122/1 (2015), 59–60.
Jerome (4th cent. C.E.) consulted Jewish authorities while engaged in his translation; see Görge Hasselhoff, “Revising the Vulgate: Jerome and his Jewish Interlocutors,” Zeitschrift für Religions- und Geistesgeschichte 64/3 (2012), 209–221.
More precisely, “a linguistic process which involves changes in the position of consonants or vowels in a word”; see Avihai Shivtiel, “Metathesis” EHLL 2.634.
On metathesis in translation, without citing this case, see Emanuel Tov, The Text-Critical Use of the Septuagint in Biblical Research, Second Edition, Revised and Enlarged (Jerusalem: Simor, 1997), 142–43.
In Hebrew, this phenomenon is wonderfully called שׂיכול אותיות; see Gen 48:14.
HALOT; see also Fishbane, Song of Songs, 38.
Fox, Song of Songs and the Ancient Egyptian Love Songs, 186–190.
This list is from Shivtiel, 634.
James Barr, Comparative Philology and the Text of the Old Testament, With Additions and Corrections (Winona Lake, IN: Eisenbrauns, 1987), 96–101.
Torleif Elgvin, The Literary Growth of the Song of Songs During the Hasmonean and Early-Herodian Periods (Leuven: Peeters, 2018), 77–78; he notes that the broken part of the letter is not consistent with the word כטעיה.
It is important to remember, however, that translators in antiquity did not leave us with notes like those in the NJPS: “Meaning of Heb. uncertain.” In some cases, when they were stuck, they transliterated rather than translated a Hebrew word, but more often they guessed at a likely meaning based on context. See Emanuel Tov, “Loan-Words, Homophony, and Transliterations in the Septuagint,” in The Greek and Hebrew Bible: Collected Essays on the Septuagint, SVT 72 (Leiden: Brill, 1999), 180–181 and “Did the Septuagint Translators Always Understand their Hebrew Text?” in his The Greek and Hebrew Bible: Collected Essays on the Septuagint, 204–205; Patrick Pouchelle, “Septuagint Lexicography,” in T & T Clark Handbook of Septuagint Research, ed. William A. Ross and W. Edward Glenny (London: T & T Clark, 2021), 75–76. The authors of both the LXX and the Peshitta of the Song of Songs, just like those who completed the NJPS translation, seem to have had some trouble understanding the Hebrew in places, and sometimes guessed at a word’s meaning. See Lemelijn, 323 (on the LXX) and 324 (on the Peshitta).
I do not think that the image should be rejected as “perhaps too plain and prosaic,” with Garrett and House, Song of Songs and Lamentations, 137. See the similar critique in Michael V. Fox, The Song of Songs and the Ancient Egyptian Love Songs (Madison, WI: University of Wisconsin Press, 1985), 103.
The word is rendered “wanderer” in the excellent and sensible commentary of J. Cheryl Exum, Song of Songs, OTL (Louisville, KY: Westminster John Knox, 2005), 97 (and see 99 n. f). Among others, it is also endorsed by Robert Gordis, The Song of Songs and Lamentations: A Study, Modern Translation and Commentary, revised and augmented edition (NY: Ktav, 1974), 47, 80. See also Othmar Keel, The Song of Songs, Continental Commentary, trans. Frederick J. Gaiser (Minneapolis, MN: Fortress, 1994), 51–52, “wandering in confusion,” though the ancient Near Eastern parallels he adduces are not compelling. And note the NJPS translation.
In this essay, I have deliberately excluded how the medieval interpreters understand כעטיה. Their interpretations are completely based on context; namely, how the verb is used elsewhere, but without consideration of etymology or the versions.
I am thus distinguishing between homonymy and polysemy; see Tamar Sovran, “Homonymy,” EHLL, 2.211.
It is common for historical linguists to reconstruct such “proto” languages; scholars have attempted, e.g., to reconstruct Proto-Indo-European, a common ancestor of English, German, Spanish, Latin, Greek, Hittite, Sanskrit, and many other languages.
See Gotthelf Bergsträsser, Introduction to the Semitic Languages: Text Specimens and Grammatical Sketches, transl. Peter T. Daniels (Winona Lake, IN: Eisenbrauns, 1983), 2–4 and Sabatino Moscati et al., An Introduction to the Comparative Grammar of the Semitic Languages: Phonology and Morphology (Wiesbaden: Otto Harrasowitz, 1964), 43–45.
See, for example, in Isaiah:
ישעיה ד:ב בַּיּ֣וֹם הַה֗וּא יִֽהְיֶה֙ צֶ֣מַח יְ־הוָ֔ה לִצְבִ֖י וּלְכָב֑וֹד...
Isa 4:2 On that day, the radiance of YHWH will lend beauty and glory…
“Deer” makes little sense in this context, and צְבִי in the sense of “beauty” fits well next to כבוד, “glory.” This example is taken from Tamar Sovran, “Homonymy,” EHLL, 2.211:
Thus, צְבִי ṣəḇī ‘deer, gazelle’ developed from a form with original /ẓ/ (IPA [ð’]) as the first consonant (see Ugaritic ẓby ‘deer’), which through normal sound shifts became /ṣ/ in Hebrew and /ṭ/ in Aramaic (see Syriac ṭabya ‘deer’, Jewish Babylonian Aramaic טַבְיָא ṭaḇya ‘deer’). צְבִי ṣəḇī ‘beauty’, however, derives from a proto-Semitic root with original /ṣ/ as the first root letter (see the Syriac and Jewish Babylonian Aramaic verb צב״י ṣ-b-y ‘wish, desire’); semantic development yielded a variety of nouns, including צְבִי ṣəḇī ‘desired thing’, hence ‘beauty’ (see also Mishnaic Hebrew צביון ṣivyon ‘will, wish’, which in modern Hebrew has come to mean ‘unique style, character’). In short, the separate origins of these two phonetically and graphically identical lexemes explain the lack of a semantic relationship between them, while at the same time they serve to illustrate the accidental nature of homonymy.
https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/ear
The Oxford English Dictionary explains their etymologies: The first, referring to the organ of hearing: Cognate with Old Frisian āre, ār, Old Dutch ōra (Middle Dutch ōre, Dutch oor), Old Saxon ōra, ōre (Middle Low German ōre, ōr), Old High German ōra (Middle High German ōre, ōr, German Ohr), Old Icelandic eyra, Old Swedish öra (Swedish öra), Old Danish øre (Danish øre), Gothic ausō < the same Indo-European base as (with various different stem-formations) ancient Greek οὖς, classical Latin auris, Early Irish ó (rare and literary), Old Church Slavonic uxo, Lithuanian ausis, all in the sense ‘ear’.
The second, referring e.g. to an ear of corn: Cognate with Old Frisian ār , Middle Dutch aer (Dutch aar ), Old Saxon ehir (Middle Low German ār , āre ), Old High German ah (rare), ahir , ehir , eher (Middle High German ach (rare), eher , äher , German Ähre ), Old Icelandic ax , Old Swedish ax (Swedish ax ), Old Danish ax (Danish aks ), Gothic ahs (genitive ahsis ) < the same Indo-European base as classical Latin acus (genitive aceris ) husk of corn, chaff.
Ludwig Koehler and Walter Baumgartner, The Hebrew and Aramaic Lexicon of the Old Testament, 5 vols. (Leiden: Brill, 1994-2000), 813-814.
In this case, the hapax “pitch,” found only in Genesis 6:14, is likely a borrowing from Akkadian (see HALOT, ad loc.). Paul V. Mankowski, Akkadian Loanwords in Biblical Hebrew (Winona Lake, IN: Eisenbrauns, 2000), 72 is “less certain” that this is a borrowing, but given the use of the word specifically in the flood narrative and in Atra-hasis and in Gilgamesh XI, the borrowing is very likely, especially given the use of the word חֵמָר elsewhere in the Bible for “pitch.”
See, e.g., the phrase from Song 2:12, עֵ֥ת הַזָּמִ֖יר הִגִּ֑יעַ, where זָמִיר may refer to pruning or singing; see Exum, Song of Songs, 121 n. i.
Francis Brown, S.R. Driver, and Charles A. Briggs, A Hebrew and English Lexicon of the Old Testament (Oxford: Clarendon, 1907), 741-742. This lexicon is based on that of the great German scholar, Wilhelm Gesenius.
Etymology refers to “the history of a linguistic form (such as a word) shown by tracing its development since its earliest recorded occurrence in the language where it is found, by tracing its transmission from one language to another, by analyzing it into its component parts, by identifying its cognates in other languages, or by tracing it and its cognates to a common ancestral form in an ancestral language.” https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/etymology.
As Wilhelm Gesenius, Hebräisches und Aramäisches Handwörterbuch über das Alte Testament 18th edition (Heidelberg: Springer, 2013), 950 notes ‘TY < * ĠTY/W.
“Jer 43,12 und das Zeitwort עטה,” ZAW 24 (1904), 105–121. The criticism of van Gall in William McKane, Jeremiah, ICC (Edinburgh: T & T Clark, 1996), 2.1060, is not compelling.
See G. R. Driver, “Lice in the Old Testament,” PEQ 106:2 (1974), 159–160. G. R. Driver (son of S. R. Driver) was the convener of the NEB translation committee, and its revision, The Revised English Bible (1989). This translation is further defended by another member of the committee: J. A. Emerton, “Lice or a Veil in the Song of Songs 1.7?” in Understanding Poets and Prophets: Essays in Honour of George Wishart Anderson, ed. A. Graeme Auld, JSOTSup 152 (Sheffield: JSOT Press, 1993), 127–140.
See e.g., Giszczak, 68: “‘[L]ice-picking’ can be excluded as a fanciful, unlikely possibility….” But the Song is often fanciful in its imagery; the woman is twice described, e.g., as having “hair that is like a flock of goats streaming down (Mount) Gilead” (4:1; 6:5). Is passing away time while picking out lice any stranger than that?
Driver, “Lice in the Old Testament,” 160.
https://www.courant.com/news/connecticut/hc-xpm-2002-10-11-0210111158-story.html ; see also OED “wile” 3.
Emerton, “Lice or a Veil in the Song of Songs 1.7?” 138.
This is the thesis of the brilliant article, Edward Ullendorff, “Is Biblical Hebrew a Language?” in his Is Biblical Hebrew a Language? Studies in Semitic Languages and Civilizations (Wiesbaden: Otto Harassowitz, 1977), 3–17.
In this piece, it was impossible to cite all of the literature that I have read on the Song and on this verse; see Qoh 12:12, but I have done my best in this context to cite the most relevant opinions and works.
Also, they are not viewed with the same disgust as in the United States: here, they are seen more as a nuisance.