Israel’s Army: What Is the Basis for the Draft in Jewish Law?

When the State of Israel was established, the leading figures in religious Zionism had to justify Israel’s right to conscript soldiers using Jewish legal sources.

SBL Style

Click to copy

"Israel’s Army: What Is the Basis for the Draft in Jewish Law?." TheTorah.com, August 19, 2020. https://www.thetorah.com/article/israels-army-what-is-the-basis-for-the-draft-in-jewish-law.

APA Style

Click to copy

"Israel’s Army: What Is the Basis for the Draft in Jewish Law?" (2020, August 19). TheTorah.com. https://www.thetorah.com/article/israels-army-what-is-the-basis-for-the-draft-in-jewish-law

Israel’s Army: What Is the Basis for the Draft in Jewish Law?

IDF swearing-in ceremony for new recruits, 2013. Flickr/Israel Defense Forces

Categories:

Shoftim

Published: August 19, 2020

|

Last Updated: September 7, 2026

  1. Excluding 21:1–9, which is about the ritual performed when the body of a murdered person is found outside one’s city.

  2. Their important efforts in meeting this challenge have attracted little attention from academics.

  3. My analysis here draws from my book, Religious Zionism, Jewish Law, and the Morality of War: How Five Rabbis Confronted One of Modern Judaism’s Greatest Challenges (New York: Oxford University Press, 2017). The issue of conscription is discussed throughout this study.

  4. See also b. Berakhot 58a; b. Yoma 58b, and for a slightly different phrasing, see b. Sanhedrin 72a.

  5. In general, in Jewish law one is not required to obey any of commandments if obedience means endangering one’s life; see Tosefta Shabbat 16:14; b. Sanhedrin 74a.

  6. Those familiar with religious Zionism may wonder why this problem arose at all, given that religious Zionists are known for the belief that the State of Israel represents the beginning of the messianic era—and of course hastening the messiah would justify risking lives to defend Israel. It is important to remember, however, that the messianic agenda of religious Zionism only became central only after the Six-Day War in 1967. But even religious Zionists who believed in this agenda earlier had to solve the difficulty regarding conscription. See discussion in, Aviezer Ravitzky, Messianism, Zionism, and Jewish Religious Radicalism, trans. Michael Swirsky, Jonathan Chipman (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1996), chapter 3.

  7. There were two nineteenth-century rabbis who were aware of this problem, R. Naftali Tsevi Yehudah Berlin, the Netsiv, and R. Joseph Babad, usually referred to by the title of his major work, Minhat Hinukh. However, their comments on the matter are very brief. See Eisen, pp. 53-55, 64-65. In the early twentieth century, R. Abraham Isaac Kook deals more extensively with this issue, but his treatment is also limited because it is part of a larger debate with a rabbinic colleague about risking one’s life for others. See Eisen, chapter 3.

  8. This explains why the rabbis never mention the obvious way around the problem, namely, to rule that the State of Israel could not draft soldiers but rather should rely on an all-volunteer army. Because of the dire nature of Israel’s predicament in being surrounded by enemies, if military service were merely voluntary, Israel’s existence would again be at risk.

  9. Eisen, p. 242.

  10. The Talmud mentions that there are 613 commandments in the Torah but never enumerates them. This led to raging debates in the medieval period about what counts as a mitzvah and what does not, and this debate is the overriding theme of Nahmanides’ commentary. For more on the 613 concept, see Marc Herman, “The Origins and Use of the 613 Commandments,” TheTorah (2017).

  11. All translations in this essay are my own.

  12. Eisen, pp. 87, 183. Nahmanides also provided radical religious Zionists with an argument for wars of conquest beyond Israel’s borders, but that matter is one that we cannot take up here.

  13. פסקים וכתבים: שאלות ותשובות בדיני אורח חיים [Rulings and Writings: Responsa Regarding the Laws of Daily Life], ed. Shlomo Shapira (Jerusalem: Mosad ha-Rav Kuk, 1989), 1, 217.

  14. Ibid. R. Herzog also cites an aggadah in the Jerusalem Talmud in which R. Simeon ben Lakish risked his life to rescue R. Immi when the latter was captured and put in jail by non-Jews and would have likely died had R. Simeon not intervened. This source would seem to suggest that Jews must risk their lives even to save even a single Jew whose life is in danger, thereby contradicting most rabbinic views on this matter. R. Herzog admitted that this aggadic passage was not normally considered authoritative by later halakhic authorities, but he argued that in combination with the other arguments just mentioned, it should be brought into consideration.