Joseph Dreams that the Sun, Moon and Stars Bow to Him – Does It Come True?

Jacob berates Joseph when he hears his second dream: “Are we to come, I and your mother and your brothers, and bow to you?” (Genesis 37:10) Rachel, his mother, was dead. What then did the dream mean?

SBL Style

Click to copy

"Joseph Dreams that the Sun, Moon and Stars Bow to Him – Does It Come True?." TheTorah.com, December 9, 2020. https://www.thetorah.com/article/joseph-dreams-that-the-sun-moon-and-stars-bow-to-him-does-it-come-true.

APA Style

Click to copy

"Joseph Dreams that the Sun, Moon and Stars Bow to Him – Does It Come True?" (2020, December 9). TheTorah.com. https://www.thetorah.com/article/joseph-dreams-that-the-sun-moon-and-stars-bow-to-him-does-it-come-true

Joseph Dreams that the Sun, Moon and Stars Bow to Him – Does It Come True?

Joseph Explaining His Dream to His Brothers, Antonio Tempesta, ca. 1600. Wikimedia

Categories:

Vayeshev

Published: December 9, 2020

|

Last Updated: September 7, 2026

  1. The midrash explains that the reason Jacob actually did think this was possible, since היה יעקב סבור שתחיית המתים מגעת בימיו “Jacob believed that the resurrection of the dead would occur in his day,” but he did not want to share this with his sons.

  2. ולפי דעתי: כי בעת שירד יעקב למצרים כבר מתה בלהה גם זלפה, כי הכתוב אמר בספור שבעים נפש מלבד נשי בני יעקב (בראשית מ"ו:כ"ו), ולא הזכיר 'מלבד נשיו ונשי בניו'. ורחוק הוא שיהיה הירח רמז לפילגשו...
    In my view, when Jacob went down to Egypt, Bilhah and Zilpah had already died, for the when counting the seventy people accompanying him, the verse says (Gen 46:26) “other than the wives of his sons” and not “other than his wives and the wives of his sons.” And it is farfetched to assume that the moon refers to some concubine of Jacob’s…
  3. Nahmanides refers here to the second time the brothers appear before Joseph, which features all eleven brothers bowing before him, including Benjamin:

    בראשית מג:כו וַיָּבֹא יוֹסֵף הַבַּיְתָה וַיָּבִיאּוּ לוֹ אֶת הַמִּנְחָה אֲשֶׁר בְּיָדָם הַבָּיְתָה וַיִּשְׁתַּחֲווּ לוֹ אָרְצָה.
    Gen 43:26 When Joseph came home, they presented to him the gifts that they had brought with them into the house, bowing low before him to the ground.

    The brothers actually bow to Joseph a third time, after their father’s funeral:

    בראשית נ:יח וַיֵּלְכוּ גַּם אֶחָיו וַיִּפְּלוּ לְפָנָיו וַיֹּאמְרוּ הִנֶּנּוּ לְךָ לַעֲבָדִים.
    Gen 50:18 His brothers went to him themselves, flung themselves before him, and said, “We are prepared to be your slaves.”
  4. In fact, whereas Benjamin does eventually bow to Joseph when the brothers return to Egypt with him in Genesis 43:26, Jacob, the supposed “sun” in the dream, never does. Instead, in the scene in which Jacob comes to Egypt, we read only about how Joseph embraces his father:

    בראשית מו:כט וַיֶּאְסֹר יוֹסֵף מֶרְכַּבְתּוֹ וַיַּעַל לִקְרַאת יִשְׂרָאֵל אָבִיו גֹּשְׁנָה וַיֵּרָא אֵלָיו וַיִּפֹּל עַל צַוָּארָיו וַיֵּבְךְּ עַל צַוָּארָיו עוֹד.
    Gen 46:29 Joseph ordered his chariot and went to Goshen to meet his father Israel; he presented himself to him and, falling upon his neck, he wept on his neck a good while.
  5. See his gloss on v. 11:

    ואביו שמר את הדבר – כי אמר בלבו שזה אינו נמנע. ואין קושיא ממה שאמ' "הבא נבא", כי זה אמ' בפרסום לפני האחים.
    “His father kept the matter in mind”—For he said to himself that it isn’t impossible. And the fact that he said (in v. 10) “will [I and your mother and brothers] really come [to bow before you]?” is not a problem, since this is what he said publicly, in front of the brothers.
  6. The great British mystery writer, Ruth Rendel, has, on multiple occasions, had her entire plot pivot on her characters’ (and we the readers’) misreading of a common phrase, early in the narrative, only to find out later that there is/was a second way to read that phrase, and that re-reading is the key to solving the mystery. In a similar, though not quite exactly the same, way, I refer our readers to an excellent 1991 film, based on the Bentley case, a real life 1953 UK capital punishment case, all of which hinges on the reading of the title phrase of the movie, Let Him Have It.

  7. See Ron Pirson, “The Sun, the Moon, and Eleven Stars: An Interpretation of Joseph’s Second Dream,” in Studies in the Book of Genesis: Literature, Redaction and History, ed. André Wénin, BETL 155 (Leuven: Leuven University Press, 2001), 561–568; and idem, Lord of the Dreams: A Semantic and Literary Analysis of Genisis 37-50, JSOTsupp 355 (London: Sheffield Academic Press, 2002), 55–59.

  8. The sun and moon, Pirson argues, are often used in telling time. Their appearance here, therefore, does double duty: They represent two years as well as highlighting that these two years are different than the first eleven.

  9. Jonathan Grossman offers this view as one example of an interpretation that goes against the way the character’s themselves understand the dream:

    A good example is Pirson’s suggestion that in the second dream the celestial bodies do not symbolize family members, but, like the symbols in the ministers’ and Pharaoh’s dreams, they show when the dream will come to pass: thirteen years (eleven stars + sun + moon). Indeed, after thirteen years, the first dream begins to be fulfilled: Joseph rises to power in Egypt, and all bow and submit to his “sheaf.”

    Jonathan Grossman, “Different Dreams: Two Models of Interpretation for Three Pairs of Dreams (Genesis 37–50)” JBL 135.4 (2016): 717–732 [720, n. 13].

  10. One response to this criticism might be that the number 11 was necessary to fool the main characters—and the reader—into thinking it was a reference to the brothers, but this feels like overreach.

  11. Joseph meets the wine-steward in his 11th year in Egypt, and this reflects the mid-point between his fall into slavery and prison and his rise to become the vizier and master of his own brothers. This two-step process is hinted at in each of the dreams. In the first, Joseph’s sheaf first rises and then stands erect, while in the second, the sun and moon stand in for each of the two stages.

  12. When I first submitted this article with my own argument for interpreting eleven as the number of years, I was unfamiliar with Pirson’s work; thankfully, R. David Steinberg called my attention to it. I would have loved to dialog with Dr. Pirson on this subject further, but tragically, though he was a non-smoker, he died of lung cancer in 2006, at the young age of 42. In this spirit, I would like to dedicate this essay to the memory of a brilliant young colleague of mine, Dr. Ricky Ratowski, who, like Dr. Pirson, was a non-smoker, yet tragically died of lung cancer, in 2008, at the young age of 49.

  13. This is the text as it read in Nahmanides original commentary. Later in his life, when Nahmanides had moved to Israel and revised his commentary, he cut most of this and argued that, in fact, no dream at all had come true at this point, but that seeing his brothers bow gave Joseph the idea to manipulate them into bringing Benjamin, to make the first dream come true, after which he would reveal himself and have his father and entourage brought in to make the second one come true:

    ולפי דעתי שהדבר בהפך כי יאמר הכתוב כי בראות יוסף את אחיו משתחוים לו, זכר כל החלומות אשר חלם להם. וידע שלא נתקיים אחד מהם בפעם הזאת, כי יודע בפתרונם כי כל אחיו ישתחוו לו בתחילה, מן החלום הראשון: והנה אנחנו מאלמים אלומים (בראשית ל"ז:ז'), כי "אנחנו" ירמוז לכל אחיו אחד עשר, ופעם שנית ישתחוו לו השמש והירח ואחד עשר כוכבים, מן החלום השני,
    In my opening, the matter is the opposite (of what Rashi said), for when scripture describes how, when Joseph saw his brothers bowing to him, he remembered all of the dreams he had about them, he understood that neither of them had come true in this event, for he realized that their meaning was that all of the brothers would bow to him first, according to the first dream (Gen 37:7) “and behold we were binding sheaves,” for “us” implies all of his eleven brothers. And then, they would bow a second time [as part of] the sun, moon, and eleven stars from the second dream.
    וכיון שלא ראה בנימן עמהם חשב זאת התחבולה שיעליל עליהם כדי שיביאו גם בנימין אחיו אליו, לקיים החלום הראשון תחילה
    And since he did not see Benjamin with them, he thought up the specious accusation he would lob against them, so that they would bring their brother Benjamin to him, so that they could fulfill the first dream first.
    ועל כן לא רצה להגיד להם אני יוסף אחיכם, ולאמר מהרו ועלו אל אבי וישלח העגלות, כאשר עשה עמהם בפעם השניה, כי היה אביו בא מיד בלא ספק. ואחרי שנתקיים החלום הראשון. הגיד להם לקיים החלום השני...
    And this is why he did not want to say to them “I am your brother Joseph” and to say “hurry and bring up my father” and to send chariots, as he did with them the second time, for his father would have doubtless come immediately [thus making the first dream, of only brothers, impossible to ever come to fruition]. But after the first dream was fulfilled, he told them, so as to fulfill the second dream…

    As Yosef Ofer and Jonathan Jacobs note, Nahmanides likely changed his mind here, since the need to fulfill each dream separately better explains why Joseph would play the trick he did on them. See Yosef Ofer and Jonathan Jacobs, תוספות רמב"ן לפירושו לתורה שנכתבו בארץ ישראל [Naḥmanides Torah Commentary Addenda Written in the Land of Israel], אשכולות: סדרת מחקרים במדעי היהדות [Eshkolot: Jewish Studies Series] (Jerusalem: Herzog Academic College and World Union of Jewish Studies, 2013), 261–266 [§103]. Nevertheless, as I argue above, it is difficult to accept Nahmanides’ overall idea that the Benjamin trick was merely to facilitate the dream fulfillment.

Related Topics:JosephDreamsPharaoh