The Moral Quandary of Lulav Ha-Gazul

The Torah and Bavli vs. the Prophets and Yerushalmi

SBL Style

Click to copy

"The Moral Quandary of Lulav Ha-Gazul." TheTorah.com, October 7, 2014. https://www.thetorah.com/article/moral-quandary-of-lulav-hagazul.

APA Style

Click to copy

"The Moral Quandary of Lulav Ha-Gazul" (2014, October 7). TheTorah.com. https://www.thetorah.com/article/moral-quandary-of-lulav-hagazul

Published: October 7, 2014

|

Last Updated: September 7, 2026

  1. Does religion take moral considerations in account or is it oblivious to them? See the illuminating discussion by Avi Sagi and Daniel Statman, Religion and Morality, Amsterdam 1995.

  2. וְעַל־בְּגָדִ֤ים חֲבֻלִים֙ יַטּ֔וּ אֵ֖צֶל כָּל־מִזְבֵּ֑חַ וְיֵ֤ין עֲנוּשִׁים֙ יִשְׁתּ֔וּ בֵּ֖ית אֱלֹהֵיהֶֽם

  3. כִּ֣י אֲנִ֤י יְ-הֹוָה֙ אֹהֵ֣ב מִשְׁפָּ֔ט שֹׂנֵ֥א גָזֵ֖ל בְּעוֹלָ֑ה

    Alternatively “I hate the robbing of wages”, depending on the parsing of the ambiguous Hebrew שֹׂנֵא גָזֵל בְּעוֹלָה

  4. הֲבֵאתֶ֣ם גָּז֗וּל וְאֶת־הַפִּסֵּ֙חַ֙ וְאֶת־ הַ֣חוֹלֶ֔ה

    The meaning of the word גזול translated here ‘stolen’ is debated among modern commentators. While all traditional authorities understand it as ‘stolen’, modern scholars point out the dissimilarity of the moral blemish (stolen) from the physical blemishes mentioned later on in the verse. Thus the interpretation ‘beaten, unsuitable’ was suggested for גזול, based on such verses as Micah 3:2. This point is significant, given that the Book of Leviticus does not include moral blemishes on a par with physical ones (see immediately below).

  5. The Norwegian scholar Karl W. Weyde (Prophecy and Teaching, Berlin 2000, p. 153) sought the roots of Malachi’s rebuke in Leviticus 5:20-26, 19:13. Biblical scholars are in disagreement whether torat kohanim (the priestly teaching) was actively aware of moral considerations. Compare Jacob Milgrom, Leviticus: A Book of Ritual and Ethics, Minneapolis 2004, with Israel Knohl, The Sanctuary of Silence, Minneapolis 1995, pp. 137-147.

  6. See the lucid definition in: Shulchan Aruch, Choshen Mishpat, 359:7.

  7. לולב הגזול והיבש פסול

  8. נמצא סנגורו קטגורו

  9. מצווה הבאה בעבירה

  10. תני רבי חייה ולקחתם לכם משלכם ולא הגזול אמר רבי לוי זה שהוא נוטל לולב גזול למה הוא דומ' לאחד שכיבד את השלטון תמחוי אחד ונמצא משלו אמרו אי לו לזה שנעשה סניגורו קטיגורו

  11. It is possible that Shmuel had originally intended the force of his words not to be about the question of a mitzvah born of transgression, but rather about the status of the second day of Yom Tov, which Shmuel defines as not counting as “the first day” of which the Torah speaks. (See b. Beitzah 4b.) If this is correct, then Shmuel’s statement was taken out of context by the editor of the Babylonian sugya, or maybe even earlier by the tradent, R. Yitzhak b. Nahmani.

  12. On the redaction of this sugya see Rabin Shushtri, Textual Traditions of Bavli Sukkah(Ph.D. Dissertation, Bar Ilan University, 2000) [Hebrew].

  13. There is no room to list them all here. An extreme case is that of Ritva (Rabbi Yom Tov ben Abraham of Seville; c.1250-c.1330) who writes:

    “Because the mitzva of lakhem [=“belonging to you”] is not a blemish in the actual physical species themselves, and the Torah is strict about it only on the first day, […] therefore we need not apply an additional stringency by applying this prohibition to the other days of the festival. However, any blemish that makes the physical special look ugly is always a prohibition from the Torah, on any day when the Torah [commands to take the lulav].”

    לפי שמצות 'לכם' אינו חומר בגופן של ארבעת מינין, אלא שהחמיר הכתוב ביום הראשון… ולפיכך אין לנו להחמיר בענין זה שאמר לכם ביום הראשון שיהא נוהג בשאר ימים כמו ביום הראשון. אבל כל שפסולו מפני שאינו הדר נוהג בכולם מן התורה בימים של תורה.”

    That is to say, the dried-out lulav is always invalid, because the object itself is blemished, but the stolen lulav is invalid only on the first day, because the lulav itself isn’t blemished.

  14. (95 א”ר יוחנן מפני מה חרב’ ירושל’ מפני שדנו בה דין תור’ (כ”י מינכן

Related Topics:Morality & EthicsLulav