Moses, by Lorenzo Monaco, ca. 1370–1425 (adapted). Wikimedia
Moses the Lawgiver? Not For the Rabbis
Writers in the Second Temple period portray Moses as the Torah’s author and master lawgiver, attributing commandments directly to him. The rabbis, by contrast, repeatedly depict Moses as forgetful, confused, and sometimes mistaken—downplaying his authority to emphasize the Torah’s divine authorship and elevate the rabbis’ own role as its interpreters.
Published: May 19, 2026
|
Last Updated: October 28, 2026
Editor’s note: For more on this, see Christopher A. Rollston, “Who Wrote the Torah According to the Torah?” TheTorah (2017).
Bible translations from NJPS with modifications.
Josh 8:31-32, 23:6; 1 Kgs 2:3; 2 Kgs 14:6, 23:25. Editor’s note: See David A. Glatt-Gilad, “Deuteronomy: The First Torah,” TheTorah (2015).
These later references, all from the post-exilic period, include Mal 3:22; Dan 9:11, 13; Ezra 3:2; 7:6; Neh 8:1; 2 Chr 23:18 and 30:16. David Lambert, “How the ‘Torah of Moses’ Became Revelation: An Early, Apocalyptic Theory of Pentateuchal Origins,” Journal for the Study of Judaism 47.1 (2016): 22-54, observes that references to the “Torah of Moses” only refer to collections of laws, the content of which is unclear, until Jubilees. As he notes, up to that point, “There remains uncertainty around whether ‘Torah of Moses,’ in its various contexts, references a delineated composition or a mode of authorization, whether it refers to the Pentateuch or some other related composition, and how widely it was known and accepted as authoritative.” (p. 26, n. 12). Marc Z. Brettler, “YHWH’s Laws in Psalms,” in Ritual and Law in the Hebrew Bible and the Ancient Near East, ed. Jeffrey Stackert, Tzvi Abusch and Alan Lenzi, Forschungen zum Alten Testament 184 (Tübingen: Mohr Siebeck, 2024), 109-126 (110-115), illustrates how difficult it is to determine what the term Torah refers to in biblical texts through a study of references in Psalms. See also Lisbeth S. Fried, “Sukkot in Ezra-Nehemiah and the Date of the Torah,” TheTorah (2015); Hindy Najman, “The Ancient Practice of Attributing Texts and Ideas to Moses,” TheTorah (2016); Yishai Kiel, “How the Concept of Mosaic Authorship Developed,” TheTorah (2018); and Molly M. Zahn, “What is ‘Torah’ in Second Temple Texts?” TheTorah (2021).
Non-Jewish sources from the same time period also view him as a lawgiver (e.g. Justinus, Epitome of Pompeius Trogus' Philippic Histories 36.2; Tacitus, Histories 5:1-13).
Philo’s explicit explanation of the authorship of Torah law is as follows: “I am not unaware then that all the things which are written in the sacred books are oracles delivered by him [Moses]; and I will set forth what more peculiarly concerns him, when I have first mentioned this one point, namely, that of the sacred oracles some are represented as delivered in the person of God by his interpreter, the divine prophet, while others are put in the form of question and answer, and others are delivered by Moses in his own character as a divinely-prompted lawgiver possessed by divine inspiration.” (On the Life of Moses II.188). Here Philo seems to distinguish between those oracles which are represented as “delivered in the person of God by his interpreter, the divine prophet” (i.e. probably those represented as direct speech by God), those “put in the form of question and answer” (i.e. probably those represented as dialogue between God and Moses), and those “delivered by Moses” (i.e. probably those represented as direct speech by Moses). It is not clear how consistent he is in this distinction, however; later in the same book, he (like Josephus, quoted below) attributes the decision to begin the year with Nissan to Moses: “Moses puts down the beginning of the vernal equinox as the first month of the year” (On the Life of Moses II.222), despite that law being represented as the direct speech of God in the relevant verse in Exodus. Translations of Philo are from Charles D. Yonge, trans., The Works of Philo: Complete and Unabridged (Peabody, MA: Hendrickson Press, 1993).
Josephus is not entirely consistent in his attribution of the Torah to Moses. In his preface to his summary of Torah law in Book 4 of Antiquities, he explains regarding the laws he digests that “they were by him left in writing as they were accidentally scattered in their delivery, and as he upon inquiry had learned them of God.” (4.196) Translations of Josephus are from William Whiston, trans. The Works of Josephus (Peabody, MA: Hendrickson, 1987).
The exact date is unclear and the text is not a literary unity. Parts may date to the second century B.C.E. See Steven D. Fraade, The Damascus Document (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2021), 4-5.
Text and translation from Fraade, The Damascus Document (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2021), 45-46. Editor’s note: For more on references to the Torah in the Damascus Document and other materials from the Dead Sea community, see Zahn, “What is ‘Torah’ in Second Temple Texts.”
I will take a broad approach to rabbinic literature in this paper without distinguishing between times or places of composition or between individual collections. My goal is to illuminate one line of rabbinic thought, a highly influential one whose influence was not limited to any particular collection or time period. The nuances of the particular interpretations of different individuals, communities, or collections are beyond the scope of this article.
Yair Furstenberg, “The Agon with Moses and Homer: Rabbinic Midrash and the Second Sophistic,” in Homer and the Bible in the Eyes of Ancient Interpreters, ed. Maren Niehoff (Leiden: Brill, 2012), 305, makes a related argument regarding the depiction of Moses as an “ignorant text receiver” in rabbinic literature: “At the same time, I would argue that the figure of Moses in this story [that of Moses and R’ Akiva] is representative of a more general attitude in rabbinic literature. Although this story, as it stands in the Talmud, is a Babylonian creation, the depiction of Moses follows earlier traditions and is strongly rooted in earlier tannaitic sources. It may even underlie the very character of tannaitic midrash. There too Moses is depicted as an ignorant text receiver who is disqualified from participating in any interpretive activity.”
Sifrei Devarim, ed. Louis Finkelstein (Berlin: Der Jüdischer Kulturbund for the Gesellschaft zur Forderung der Wissenschaft des Judentums, 1939), 1. Punctuation and translation mine.
Translations of Midrash Tanhuma are my own. (This midrash aims to explain the enigmatic Exod. 34:29-35.) Another example describes Moses writing other biblical texts in addition to the Torah:
ירושלמי סוטה ה:ח, כ ד משה כתב חמשה סיפרי תורה, וחזר וכתב פרשת בלק ובלעם, וכתב ספרו שלאיוב.
j. Sotah 5:8, 20d Moses wrote the five books of the Torah, and went back and wrote the portion of Balak and Balaam, and wrote the book of Job.
The text is my own transcription of Ms. Leiden (viewable in the Leiden University Libraries Digital Collections). Punctuation and translation mine.
I exclude here all verses which are explicitly contained within dialogue attributed to Moses in the Torah, such as much of Deuteronomy.
Bereshit Rabba, ed. Julius Theodor and Hanoch Albeck (Jerusalem: Wahrmann Books, 1965), 61. Punctuation and translation mine. Some non-rabbinic Biblical interpreters at the time did read this verse in ways the rabbis would have deemed heretical, most notably early Christians (Justin Martyr, Dialogue with Trypho 62; Irenaeus, Against Heresies 4.20.1; Tertullian, Against Praxeas 12; Origen, Against Celsus 5.37).
One could argue that these are simply two different rabbinic perspectives on Moses, if not for the fact that some texts, like Bereishit Rabbah 8:8 (see above) both describe Moses writing the Torah and undermine his authorship of it.
This phenomenon is ubiquitous and nearly universal throughout rabbinic literature. Here is the first clear example in each of the main rabbinic corpora: Mishnah, Tosefta, and Talmuds: m. Berakhot 1:3, t. Berakhot 1:3, b. Berakhot 2a, y. Berakhot 1:1 (ironically the verses cited in each of these are direct speech attributed to Moses in Deuteronomy, an inverse of what we saw above in Philo, Josephus, and the Damascus Document); Halakhic Midrashim: Mekhilta dR’ Yishmael Pisha 1:1, Sifra Vayikra 2:4, Sifrei Bamidbar 1:1, Sifrei Devarim 1:1; Aggadic Midrashim: Bereishit Rabbah 1:1, Vayikra Rabbah 1:1, Tanhuma Bereishit 1:1. It is also present for other biblical books, but somewhat less consistently (e.g. note the contrast here between “it is said” introducing the verse from Deuteronomy and “David says” for the verse from Psalms 116, which is not explicitly attributed, in Sifrei Devarim 32:7).
As Richard Kalmin, The Sage in Jewish Society of Late Antiquity (London: Routledge, 1999), 94-95, has noted, the rabbis “seldom refer to the Torah as belonging to Moses” and with only a handful of exceptions across the two Talmuds, “phrases such as ‘the Torah of Moses’ are found only in statements attributed to non-rabbis or non-Jews.”
Arguably the earliest version is the concise mention of “three things with which Moses struggled, and which the Omnipresent showed him with a finger” (new moon, forbidden species, menorah; some add slaughter) in Mekhilta dR. Yishmael Pisha 2 (paralleled, other than the addition by the second opinion, in Sifrei Bamidbar 61; quoted with some variations in b. Menahot 29a, seen below).
Text from the Friedberg Project for Talmud Bavli Variants (Hachi Garsinan), transcription of Ms. Munich 95. There are no significant variants. Punctuation and translation mine.
The species which the Israelites are forbidden to eat, the appearance of the new moon which indicates the start of a new month, and the process of ritual slaughter are grouped together in b. Menahot 29a, but versions of this midrash appear across a wide variety of different works of rabbinic literature with variations on the list (e.g. Tanhuma Shemini 8: menorah, new moon, forbidden species). Each is derived from the use of the word "זה", “this” – the rabbis generally interpret this word as implying that the speaker is pointing to an object.
E.g. Tanhuma Shemini 8, Tanhuma Behaalotekha 3, Tanhuma Buber Shemini 11, Tanhuma Buber Behaalotekha 4.
See also Tanhuma Buber Behaalotekha 11.
Vayikra Rabbah, ed. Mordecai Margulies (New York: Jewish Theological Seminary of America, 1993), 269. Punctuation and translation mine.
The midrash is playing on the fact that the Hebrew words "give" (נתן, natan) and "gift" (מתנה, matanah) are related etymologically, much like the English words "give" and "gift."
Vayikra Rabbah, ed. Mordecai Margulies (New York: Jewish Theological Seminary of America, 1993), 272. Punctuation and translations mine.
Moses himself, in this depiction, openly admits his inferior knowledge and endorses his brother’s superior powers of inference. In creating this portrait of Moses as enthusiastic about sharing his role, the rabbis of course draw on many biblical precedents, such as his response to the prophesying elders Eldad and Medad:
במדבר יא:כט וַיֹּאמֶר לוֹ מֹשֶׁה הַמְקַנֵּא אַתָּה לִי וּמִי יִתֵּן כׇּל־עַם יְ־הֹוָה נְבִיאִים כִּי־יִתֵּן יְ־הֹוָה אֶת־רוּחוֹ עֲלֵיהֶם.
Num 11:29 But Moses said to him [Joshua], “Are you wrought up on my account? Would that all YHWH’s people were prophets, that YHWH put His spirit upon them!”
This is not a biblical quote. Rather, the rabbis based it on their observation of the difference in the order of these items in the instructions (Exodus 25-26: ark, vessels, tabernacle), and in the description of their construction (Exodus 35-39: tabernacle, ark, vessels).
Rabbeinu, meaning “our rabbi” or “our teacher,” is the epithet the rabbis gave Moses. Editor’s note: For more on this, see Malka Z. Simkovich, “Why The Sages Add Titles to Biblical Personalities,” TheTorah (2013).
Text from the Vilna Edition; all of the manuscripts contain errors or difficult readings which would impede easy reading but do not affect the basic sense of the text. Punctuation and translation are mine.
Sifrei Devarim, ed. Louis Finkelstein (Berlin, 1939), 30. Punctuation and translation mine. Parallels, with substantial variation in the wording but similar substance: Tanhuma Pinhas 8:1, Tanhuma Buber Miketz 6, Pinhas 9:1, b. Sanhedrin 8a. This interpretation is in sharp contrast to that of Philo, who explains that Moses could see both sides of the case and was therefore conflicted: “Moses was very naturally in a state of indecision, and was dragged different ways, so that Moses laid his perplexities before God, whom he knew to be the only being who could with true and unerring judgment decide such delicate differences with a complete display of truth and justice” (Philo, On the Life of Moses II.237).
Josephus’s version of the story completely omits any mention of uncertainty: “At this time the chief men of the tribe of Manasseh came to Moses, and informed him that there was an eminent man of their tribe dead, whose name was Zelophehad, who left no male children, but left daughters; and asked him whether these daughters might inherit his land or not. He made this answer, That if they shall marry into their own tribe, they shall carry their estate along with them; but if they dispose of themselves in marriage to men of another tribe, they shall leave their inheritance in their father’s tribe. And then it was that Moses ordained, that every one’s inheritance should continue in his own tribe” (Josephus, Antiquities 4.174-175).