Jacob and Rachel at the well (adapted), Julius Schnorr von Carolsfeld, 19th c. Wikimedia
Why the Brothers Hate Joseph
A background fraught with favoritism
Published: December 1, 2015
|
Last Updated: September 7, 2026
In its punctuation, spacing and paragraphing NJPS takes great liberties at Gen. 37:1-2 with the Masoretic text.
תֹּלְדוֹת can be rendered several ways in English – including story, history, line or descendants.
In likening Jacob and Joseph, younger and favored sons, Rashi follows Midrash Genesis Rabbah 84:6. See also Peter Miscall, “Jacob and Joseph as Analogies” JSOT 6 (1978): 28-40.
Midrash Aggada, Lekach Tov, and Sechel Tov (ad loc.)
The dreams will be pointedly referred to when Joseph approaches the brothers at Dothan (37:20), and yet again in Genesis 42:9 when Joseph realizes that his brothers’ unexpected appearance in Egypt will allow him to fulfill these youthful dreams. Nachmanides emphasizes the role of dream-fulfillment in explaining Joseph’s motives in Gen 42-45 and with reason. I prefer the multi-faceted explanation of Meir Sternberg (The Poetics of Biblical Narrative) that teaching, testing punishing and dream fulfillment are all involved. As so often in human affairs, Joseph’s motives are overdetermined. Nachmanides, Commentary on the Torah, Genesis, (trans. Charles Chavel; NY: Shilo Press, 1971), 455-459.
This will prove critical later in the story when Joseph is proclaimed to be alive and very well in Egypt. In short, the hatred of Joseph is amply narrated, as is the violence perpetrated against him in vv. 23-24, which uses three verbs (“they stripped,” “they took,” “they threw”) to describe their actions. Thomas Mann, Joseph and his Brothers, John Woods translation. (NY: Alfred A. Knopf, 2005), 465-475. Mann deftly captures the animalistic rending of the hated katonet passim and highlights the coat’s role as a stand-in for Joseph.
The empty pit which had no water in it has been another exegetical crux, but even if one thinks Rashi’s view that the pit was populated with “snakes and scorpions” is over-reading, it certainly captures their fratricidal impulse. Gabriel Josipovici,The Book of God (New Haven: Yale, 1988): 19-20.
The sale of Joseph a sin for which later generations must atone – this is captured vividly in the “Testament of the Twelve Patriarchs,” in the midrashic collection Pirke de Rab Eliezer, perek 38, and also in the eleh azkarah service at Yom Kippur. In the interest of space, I leave Jacob’s role in this fraternal strife to the side: modern readers will tend to blame the parent for favoritism more than the favored child, but I am not sure that earlier readers would. In any event, the palpable tensions between Jacob and his other sons becomes more of a focus later in the Joseph narrative.
See the recent discussion of various adaptations of these methods in James Adam Redfield, “Behind Auerbach’s Background,” in AJS Review 39:1 (April 2015): 121-150.
Given the nature of mandrakes as aphrodisiacal-fertility plant one may infer that Reuben seeks to enhance his mother’s erotic powers. Reuben’s role as a vehicle of the sexual-sororal tensions between Jacob, Rachel, and Leah is continued in Gen 35 – Reuben’s attempts to supplant Jacob as patriarch by sleeping with Bilhah, concubine of the departed Rachel.
The midrashim speculate on the significance of many of the named characters in the Torah, and raise many of the question posed by modern readers: who named whom, what significance was the name, what was its etymology, what was its etiology, etc. Midrash also tends to note ironic names if Pharaoh’s daughter knew Hebrew why did she name the baby Moshe rather than Mashui), and incongruities (if Noah was meant to bring comfort, his name ought to have been Menachem).
Ilana Pardes, Countertraditions in the Bible (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1992), 60-66.
See also Yair Zakovitch, Jacob: The Unexpected Patriarch(New Haven: Yale University Press, Jewish Lives Series, 2012).
I do not always agree with Harold Bloom’s readings in The Book of J, but ‘agonistic’ is surely le mot juste with regard to Jacob, and, I would add, Rachel.
Solomon is also named Yedidyah; Jacob renames Benjamin birth, after the dying Rachel names him Benoni.
משנולד יוסף בטח יעקב בהקב”ה ורצה לשוב
Notably, Jacob does consult Rachel and Leah, sisters and co-wives, who agree that this departure from Paddan-Aram is necessary to save their children’s inheritance. (Gen. 31:4).
To speculate a little further, it seems only human to imagine that they resent being taken away from their friends, family, and childhood home. Even if Lavan is a terrible father-in-law, and a suspicious father, his performance as a grandfather may be quite different, as may that of his unnamed wife.
Gen. 27:45. NJPS sensibly places an exclamation point at the end of this verse. The subject “both” has been the subject of debate. The plain sense seems to imply Esau and Jacob, one lost to murder, and the other lost as a murderer, but others have read it as Esau and Isaac, since the death of the father opens the way for fratricide.
Jon D. Levenson notes, “Jacob graphically reaffirms his preference for Rachel, now extended to her son Joseph, which once caused so much ill will between his wives.” The Jewish Study Bible (Oxford, 2004) “Genesis,” 68.
In a comment on an earlier draft, Zev Farber noted that the separation-of-the-children-by-mother theme continues in Genesis 34 – the rape of Dinah, particularly with Jacob’s reference to the endangerment of “me and my house (אני וביתי)” and the response of Shimon and Levi that emphases the epithet “our sister,” not “your daughter,” as she was called earlier in the text. I agree with this observation. (Editor’s note: I originally heard it from Rabbi David Silber of the Drisha Institute. ZIF)
The text highlights the tension between Joseph and the sons of the midwives – a theme later commentaries expanded greatly.