My Encounter with the Firmament

The Torah describes God’s fashioning the firmament (רקיע) on the second day of creation. This piece of the universe, however, doesn’t actually exist—a problem obfuscated in my yeshiva education.

SBL Style

Click to copy

"My Encounter with the Firmament." TheTorah.com, October 11, 2017. https://www.thetorah.com/article/my-encounter-with-the-firmament.

APA Style

Click to copy

"My Encounter with the Firmament" (2017, October 11). TheTorah.com. https://www.thetorah.com/article/my-encounter-with-the-firmament

My Encounter with the Firmament

A fish-eye view of the Red sea in Israel, early spring.

Published: October 11, 2017

|

Last Updated: September 7, 2026

  1. This seems to be the idea in Gen 1, though Exod 24:10 may imply a different explanation, namely that the sky is blue because it is made of lapis lazuli.

  2. Alternatively, it could be blue because it is made of the same substance as the water, only solid. See discussion of Rashi later on.

  3. Gudmund Hatt, Asiatic Influences in American Folklore (Copenhagen, 1949), 50, quoted in, Paul H. Seely: “The Firmament and the Water above Part I: The Meaning of Raqiaʿ in Gen 1:6-8,” Westminster Theological Journal 53 (Fall 1991), 227-240 [p. 231].

  4. Seely, “The Firmament 1,” 231.

  5. Seely: “The Firmament 1,” 228-231.

  6. Alternatively “Lord of Storm.”

  7. Translation from, Stephanie Dalley, Myths from Mesopotamia, rev. ed. (Oxford World’s Classics; Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2000 [1989]), 257. For a discussion of where the conception of the world in Gen 1 fits with other ANE conceptions, see Othmar Keel and Silvia Schroer, Creation: Biblical Theologies in the Context of the Ancient Near East (Winona Lake: Eisenbrauns, 2015), 78-84.

  8. Natan Slifkin, “The Sun’s Path at Night,” Rationalist Judaism (2010).

  9. See discussion in, Moshe Simon-Shoshan, “The Heavens Proclaim the Glory of God – A Study in Rabbinic Cosmology,” Bechol Derakhekha De’ehu 20 (2008): 67-96 [82-83].

  10. And it is still causing traffic jams in Israel to get the water the day before matzah is baked. For other modern manifestations of this law, see the Youtube video, Dorog Rebbe at mayim she-lanu 5776, and Yochanan Donn, “Is New York Targeting Mayim Shelanu?”HaModia (March 20, 2013).

  11. By the time we reach Rambam’s era (13th cent), the firmament is imagined as more complex. In his Guide of the Perplexed (2:30), Rambam rejects the idea of a dome holding up heavenly waters (he says the water isn’t really water) and reimagines the dome to better fit to Aristotelian musings, namely as a huge solid dome containing a complex set of spherical orbits in which the planets move. In fact, Rambam uses the firmament and its spheres for planetary orbits as one of his rational proofs of divine existence. See discussion in, Micah Goodman, Maimonides and the Book That Changed Judaism: Secrets of “The Guide for the Perplexed” (Philadelphia: JPS, 2015), 8. Thus, even Rambam, Judaism’s philosophically literate rationalist, accepts that the rakia is a physical dome in the sky, which returns us to our difficulties, for there is no such dome.

  12. Slifkin, Natan. “The Making of Haredim,” Rationalist Judaism (2012): 9-10

  13. j. Berachot 1:1:

    רב אמר לחים היו שמים ביום הראשון ובשני קרשו רב אמר יהי רקיע יחזק הרקיע יקרש הרקיע יגלד הרקיע ימתח הרקיע
    Rav said: “The heavens were liquid on the first day and on the second day they congealed.” Rav said: “‘Let the firmament be’ – let the firmament congeal, let the firmament coagulate, let the firmament be spread thin.”

    See also R. Isaac’s position about the meaning of shamayim in Genesis Rabbah (Bereishit 4) which I discuss below.

  14. This claim has long been made about Rashi in particular. See discussion in, Yonatan Kolatch, Masters of the Word: Traditional Jewish Bible Commentary from the First Through Tenth Centuries, vol. 2 (Jersey City: Ktav, 2007) 57.

  15. I consider it odd that the fact that I knew about the problem with the firmament made me a person of note. I don’t know if I was supposed to be a hero or villain, but in 2015 that knowledge was not expected, at least by this particular speaker, to be common knowledge, nor did it appear to be common knowledge to a group of Orthodox people gathered out of scientific interest in Berieshis.

  16. J. Calvin, Genesis (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1948) 78-79. This approach continued in some circles from then until modern times. From the eighteenth century, e.g., A. Clarke, The Old Testament (New York: Hunt & Eaton, n.d.) 1.31. From the nineteenth century, e.g., G. Bush, Notes on the Book of Genesis, (New York: Ivison, Phinney, 1860) 33; R. S. Candlish,Commentary on Genesis (1868; repr. Grand Rapids: Zondervan) 25. From this century, e.g., C. E Keil and E Delitzsch, Biblical Commentary on the Old Testament, The Pentateuch(Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1949) 1.52; A. R. Fausset and D. Brown, A Commentary on the Old and New Testaments (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1948) 5; H. L. Ellison and D. E Payne, “Genesis,” in The International Bible Commentary (ed. E E Bruce; Grand Rapids: Zondervan, 1979), 115.

  17. Commentary to Genesis 1:6; cf. Rabbi Akiva Eiger, in his note to the phrase u’vokeya chalonei rakia in Siddur Otzar HaTefillos p. 672, and Maharzav to Midrash Bereishis Rabbah 6:8. For discussion of these and other sources, see Natan Slifkin, “What Firmament Really Is,” Rationalist Judaism (2011).

  18. See, e.g., R. Yudah ben Pazi’s comment in j. Berachot 1:1.

  19. See discussion in, E. J. Young, Studies in Genesis One (Philadelphia: Presbyterian & Reformed, 1964), 90 n. 94.

  20. Albeck’s emendation as per the earlier iteration of Rav’s position in Genesis Rabbah (vol. 1, p. 26).

  21. The text continues by midrashically reinterpreting the verse entirely:

    רַבִּי אֱלִיעֶזֶר אוֹמֵר רָקִיעַ שֶׁעַל רָאשֵׁי אַרְבַּע הַחַיּוֹת, שֶׁנֶּאֱמַר [יחזקאל א, כב] וּדְמוּת עַל רָאשֵׁי הַחַיָּה רָקִיעַ כְּעֵין הַקֶּרַח הַנּוֹרָא.
    Rabbi Eliezer says: “It was the firmament that sits atop the four creatures [Ezekiel saw in his vision of the chariot], as it says (Ezek 1:22): ‘Above the heads of the creatures was a form: an expanse, with an awe-inspiring gleam as of crystal.’”