My Abandoned Quest to Integrate Orthodoxy and Biblical Criticism

When I encountered TheTorah.com, I experienced a moment of déjà vu. In the early 1970s, I majored in Bible at Yeshiva University and spent my junior year abroad in Jerusalem studying with Hebrew University Bible professors. My goal was to grapple with questions of Pentateuchal criticism in a way that would be meaningful and beneficial for an Orthodox Jew. But then I dropped it. Here is my story.

SBL Style

Click to copy

"My Abandoned Quest to Integrate Orthodoxy and Biblical Criticism." TheTorah.com, November 11, 2021. https://www.thetorah.com/article/my-abandoned-quest-to-integrate-orthodoxy-and-biblical-criticism.

APA Style

Click to copy

"My Abandoned Quest to Integrate Orthodoxy and Biblical Criticism" (2021, November 11). TheTorah.com. https://www.thetorah.com/article/my-abandoned-quest-to-integrate-orthodoxy-and-biblical-criticism

My Abandoned Quest to Integrate Orthodoxy and Biblical Criticism

Yeshiva University's Mendel Gottesman Library, built in 1967. Wikimedia

Published: November 11, 2021

|

Last Updated: September 7, 2026

  1. The expression “Torah u-Madda” is first found in a letter in June 1915 from Bernard Revel to Rabbi Avraham Eliezer Alperstein. It eventually became the motto of Yeshiva University. “Madda” was used by Revel as a generic term for knowledge and wisdom and not just natural sciences. See Norman Lamm, Torah Umadda: The Encounter of Religious Learning and Worldly Knowledge in the Jewish Tradition (Northvale, New Jersey, 1990), 11-12. See also Jacob J. Schachter, “Torah U-Madda Revisited: The Editor’s Introduction,” The Torah U-Madda Journal 1 (1989): 1-22.

  2. Chemists and physicians who had survived the Holocaust contributed substantially to the initial growth of AOJS. BJA members in the AOJS 1962 directory included chemists Dr. S.B. Bamberger, Dr. Jonas Bondi, and Dr. Karl Schoen, and physicians Ernest Freeman, Willy Hoffman, Adolf Loewenthal, Menny Rapp, Godschaux (Chaim Gershon) Schnerb, and Kurt Stern. Among the BJA members who helped in the initial formation of the Israeli branch of AOJS in 1962 were chemists Dr. Felix Munk and Dr. Wolf Bodenheimer. For my father, their behavior and Weltanschauung “served as role models.” For more on this, see my father’s autobiography, recorded by Estie Ben David, which I edited and published in 2019 under the title, My Life: Reflections At Ninety-Five: Prof. Elmer (Eliezer) Offenbacher An Autobiography.

  3. See Elmer L. Offenbacher, “The Association of Orthodox Jewish Scientists (AOJS) The First Two Decades (1947–1967),” Bekhol Derakhekha Daehu: Journal of Torah and Scholarship 15 (Sept. 2004), 5–36.

  4. Greenberg, at the time a Professor of Bible at Penn University, had been ordained like his father, as a Conservative Rabbi at the Jewish Theological Seminary JTS, but he was a member of our Orthodox Lower Merion Synagogue (“LMS”) in suburban Philadelphia.

  5. Robert Koret, “Letter to the Editor,” The Commentator 62.3 (Dec. 2, 1965), 6.

  6. Irving Jabitsky, “Biblical Criticism,” The Commentator 62.4 (Dec. 2, 1965), 5-6.

  7. Mayer Herskovics (1912-2003) completed his Ph.D. in 1950 about Halakah and Agadah in Onkelos at YU’s Bernard Revel Graduate School of Jewish Studies.

  8. “Dr. Herskovics Criticizes Allegations of Bible Critics,” The Commentator, 62.5 (Dec. 16, 1965), 7.

  9. Larry Grossman, “Does Yeshiva Have Room for Bible Criticism,” The Commentator 62.5 (Dec. 16, 1965), 3-4. It might be noted that Lawrence Grossman is still actively engaged in analyzing Orthodox responses to Biblical criticism. See Lawrence Grossman, "Seven Defenses Against Biblical Criticism" TheTorah.com (2017). Grossman optimistically predicts: “Ways will undoubtedly be worked out to justify sincere adherence to the Torah way of life together with an openness to critical study of that Torah. That is what happened when Judaism faced the challenges of an incorporeal God, a heliocentric universe, and evolution. And it will happen again.”

  10. For a synopsis of the Lichtenstein - Greenberg Exchange and the later scholarly analysis see Adam S. Ferziger, “Fluidity and Bifurcation: Critical Biblical Scholarship and Orthodox Judaism in Israel and North America,” Modern Judaism 39.3 (October 2019): 233–270.

  11. Rabbi Dr. Lawrence Grossman informed me that Greenberg actually left the YU faculty in 1972 but this episode “fractured the relationship between the two men”. Grossman added that “Rav Aharon Soloveichik, who then taught at YU, devoted an entire shiur (class) to blasting Greenberg and asserting that biblical criticism was cooked up by anti-Semites.” (Personal correspondence Nov. 8, 2021)

  12. Editor’s note: For Greenberg’s later reflections on Bible criticism, see Irving (Yitz) Greenberg, “Meeting the Challenge of Critical Scholarship with Leviticus,” TheTorah (2016).

  13. The first Bible instructor at YU was Dr. Moshe (Moses) Seidel. He was appointed on Oct. 1917 and taught three Bible courses “with classical Jewish commentaries”: Psalms, Joshua-Judges, Samuel-Kings. See Gilbert Klaperman, The Story of Yeshiva University (London, 1969), pg. 260.

  14. Few Bible instructors at YU had academic degrees in Biblical Studies - “Most had semikhah and a doctorate in history or some other field” - See B. Barry Levy, “My Experience at Yeshiva,” in, My Yeshiva College: 75 Years of Memories, ed. Menachem Butler and Zev Nagel (New York: Yashar, 2006), 226–230.

  15. Levy’s 1974 doctorate at New York University was titled The Language of Neofyti 1: A Descriptive and Comparative Grammar of the Palestinian Targum. Later it was published in two volumes as Targum Neophyti: A Textual Study (Lanham, Maryland, 1986-1987).

  16. Levy was later to publish Fixing God's Torah: The Accuracy of the Hebrew Bible text in Jewish Law (Oxford University Press, 2001).

  17. In the fall of 1973 Levy left YU, first to Brown University and then to McGill in Montreal. For Levy’s own reflections on the importance of critical study of the Bible, see his, “Text and Context: Torah and Historical Truth,” TheTorah (2013). On Levy’s influence on a generation of Bible teachers see Jaqueline S. Du Toit, Jason Kalman, Vanessa R. Sasson, Hartley Lachter, eds., To Fix Torah in Their Heart: Essays on Biblical Interpretation and Jewish Studies in Honor of B. Barry Levy (Hebrew Union College Press, 2018).

  18. I wrote a term paper analyzing “Angelology and Demonology in Jubilees” in Levy’s course “Introduction to the Apocrypha and Pseudepigrapha” and researched “The Dating of Biblical Accentuation and Cantillation” for his course Hagiographa.

  19. This paper on Fallen Angels was submitted April 13, 1972 for a history course by Dr. Aaron Lichtenstein—not to be confused with Rav Aharon Lichtenstein—titled “The Ancient Near East.” Editor’s note: For discussions of this topic, see Miryam Brand, “The Benei Elohim, the Watchers, and the Origins of Evil,” TheTorah (2016); Samuel Z. Glaser, “Demigods and the Birth of Noah,” TheTorah (2020); Rachel Adelman, “Reintroducing the Myth of the Fallen Angels into Judaism,” TheTorah (2015).

  20. We were such a small group of students in Greek that we studied on Sundays in Prof. Feldman’s private home in Manhattan rather than at YU. After we had studied Plato’s Apology and Crito in the first semester, I conditioned my continuing in the second semester on selecting the Septuagint as the semester’s reading. At the end of the course, I presented 17 riddles in Greek Septuagint studies as part of the induction ceremony into YU’s classics student honor society Eta Sigma Phi (ΗΣΦ).

  21. Chaim Potak’s 1969 novel, The Promise, centers around YU using a thinly veiled pseudonym as the Samson Rafael Hirsch College and JTS disguised as the Zechariah Frankel Seminary. The protagonist, Reuven Malter, who studies at “YU” while his father teaches Talmud at “JTS,” chooses to use his father's critical methodology method on the Talmud and Bible but excludes the Pentateuch. For Potok’s personal understanding of Divine Revelation at Sinai see his response in Milton Himmelfarb (ed.), The Condition of Jewish Belief: A Symposium Compiled by the Editors of Commentary Magazine (1966), 173–175. The first of the five questions posed to the 38 Rabbis who agreed to respond was “In what sense do you believe the Torah to be divine revelation?” Sixteen responses are available online here. Editor’s note: For more on this issue of Commentary, see Lawrence Grossman, “In What Sense Did Orthodoxy Believe the Torah to be Divine?” TheTorah (2015).

  22. In the early 1970s it was common for Yeshiva College and Stern College students to spend their junior year in Israel at Hebrew University. As a group, we bonded with our Israeli counterparts who were organized as Yavneh, the religious students’ organization (Dovid Asulin was chosen to head the HU Student Council). We had our own religious dorms at Givat Ram (row 3 buildings 2 and 9) and organized joint activities, tiyulim (trips), and shabbatonim.

  23. Similarly, Marc Angel who studied Tenach with Aryeh Toeg at Pardes Institute, wrote about Toeg in his book, Choosing to be Jewish: the Orthodox Road to Conversion (Jersey City, NJ: Ktav, 2005), 80:

    Aryeh would discuss Wellhausen’s theories of biblical source criticism with as much facility as he presented Ibn Ezra’s comments on comparative Semitics. His openness to any honest inquiry that could enhance our understanding and appreciation of the Biblical text was inspiring. I was impressed by his ability to live a committed halakhic life without compromising intellectual integrity…..

    Toeg’s book was published posthumously as מתן תורה בסיני [Lawgiving at Sinai] (Jerusalem: Magnes, 1977).

  24. Moses Zvi (Hirsch) Segal served as professor teaching Bible at HU from 1926–1949 and his magnum opus in English is The Pentateuch, Its Composition and Its Authorship and Other Biblical Studies (Jerusalem, 1967). Segal critiqued the “crass scepticism” (sic) of the Documentary Hypothesis and defended Mosaic authorship of the Torah.

  25. For a discussion of the term “Orthodox Jewish Bible scholar” as an oxymoron and an in-depth discussion of his dilemmas see Moshe Bernstein. “The Orthodox Jewish Scholar and Jewish Scholarship: Duties and Dilemmas,” The Torah U-Madda Journal 3 (1991-1992), 8-36.

  26. See Marc Zvi Brettler and Edward Breuer, “Louis Jacobs: We Have Reason to Believe,” TheTorah (2020); Harry Freedman, “The Ilui Who Couldn’t Reject Biblical Criticism: Louis Jacobs,” TheTorah (2021).

  27. For example, Charles Liebman, “Orthodoxy in American Jewish Life,” American Jewish Year Book 66 (1965), 21–97 [p. 46] states:

    The entire belief structure of American Orthodoxy still finds verbal expression within the bounds of a rather narrow fundamentalism… making no serious effort… to engage in biblical criticism, and thereby ruling out the development of any outstanding Orthodox biblical scholars in the United States… no one is prepared to undertake or even encourage the work.

  28. Adele Berlin makes a similar observation in her, “Between Heart and Mind: On Being an Observant Academic Bible Scholar,” TheTorah (2021).

  29. This 1973 letter was later published in my article “Approaching Judaica Objectively,” YU Israel News 11.18 (May 1982).

  30. R. J. Zvi Werblowsky, “Madda haMikdra Kebayah Datit,” Molad 18.141–142 (May 1960), 162–168.

  31. Mordechai Breuer, “Emunah u-Madda be-Parshanut ha-Mikra,” Deot 11 (fall 1959), pp. 18-25, Deot 12 (winter 1960), pp. 12-27.

  32. The course description of the Joseph Shapiro Academy of Jewish Studies, Spring 1974 catalogue stated: “Analysis includes Rabbinic interpretation, archeological findings, and illustrations of critical methodologies”. Rabbi Steven (later Shlomo) Riskin, who was Rabbi of LSS, was listed as teaching a course titled “Readings in Biblical Literature.”

  33. There already was a Jewish Studies Society at YU, and we organized JSHS as an honors society similar to existing honors societies at YU such as Pi Sigma Alpha, the National Political Science Honor Society.

  34. AJS was established in 1969 and Band became president in 1972.

  35. My impassioned appeal to set up a national JSHS was published in the Kol Yavneh Newsletter of Sept./Oct. 1974, pp. 3,7.

  36. On the rise and fall of Yavneh in America see Benny Kraut, The Greening of American Orthodox Judaism: Yavneh in the Nineteen Sixties, Cincinnati: Hebrew Union College Press, 2011. Founded in 1960 by Orthodox students on college campuses in Israel and the US, Yavneh activists were idealistic and optimistic about solving such challenges as Biblical criticism.

  37. Dr. Felman was an assistant professor of Bible who had a medical degree. I was so enamored by his approach to Bible that I took three of his courses.

  38. Rabbi Soloveitchik’s essay, “The Lonely Man of Faith,” was first published in the summer 1965 issue of Tradition. He reads the first two chapters of Book of Genesis as offering two images of Adam.

  39. In support of this analysis, I quoted Lawrence Kaplan, “The Religious Philosophy of Rabbi Joseph Soloveitchik,” Tradition 14.2 (Fall 1973), 43-64.

  40. My thanks to Prof. Edward Breuer for directing me to R. Lichtenstein’s essay initially delivered as a public lecture at Stern College in 1962 and only published 50 years later in 2012 as “Criticism and Kitvei ha-Kodesh”, in Rav Shalom Banayikh, Essays Presented to Rabbi Shalom Carmy by Friends and Students in Celebration of Forty Years of Teaching, ed. Hayyim Angel and Yitzchak Blau (Jersey City, NJ, 2012), 15–32.

  41. For example, see Rabbi Aharon Lichtenstein, “General Studies from a Torah Point of View, Commentator, April 27, 1961.

  42. See R. Lichtenstein’s answers in Milton Himmelfarb (ed.), The Condition of Jewish Belief: A Symposium Compiled by the Editors of Commentary Magazine (1966), 132-134.

  43. B. Barry Levy wrote a laudatory letter praising me as an outstanding future Bible scholar, and Prof. Shemaryah Talmon portrayed my contributions in his courses as “outstanding.”

  44. The paper can be found posted in a few pieces on my Academia page.

  45. Ben Levi, Revelation (Manchester: Torah Publications, 1964). I later discovered that Ben Levi was a pseudonym for Rabbi Baruch Horowitz (later the Rosh Yeshiva of Devar Yerushalayim) who at the time was rebutting Louis Jacobs but didn’t want to offend him personally.

  46. Joshua Abelson, “Bible Problems and Modern Knowledge,” The Jewish Review (March 1913), 483.

  47. Later, I was told that one of the judges was Rabbi Shlomo Riskin.

  48. Leiman’s letter was dated Sept. 1, 1974. He was one of the outstanding scholars, many who were Orthodox, who were mentored by Prof. Moshe Greenberg at the University of Pennsylvania. The letter said: “Congratulations on your interesting paper which gathers together for the first time (since Shaw) and categorizes various Orthodox responses to Biblical criticism.” Leiman was referring to the article by Steven Shaw, “Orthodox Reactions to the Challenge of Biblical Criticism,” Tradition 10.3 (1969): 61–85.

  49. One time I enthusiastically/naively spoke about Prof. Moshe Zvi Segal’s writings as the solution to the challenge of Biblical criticism. The second time, on March 2, 1974, I brashly declared how aliyah to Israel is a Torah requirement. When I looked behind me on the podium at Rabbi Jung and Rabbi Lamm, I realized that I might have exaggerated in my enthusiasm.

  50. Compare Rabbi Lamm’s characterization of Biblical “Higher Criticism” as “a relatively minor and manageable problem that is chiefly a nuisance but not a threat to the enlightened believer” in Milton Himmelfarb (ed.), The Condition of Jewish Belief: A Symposium Compiled by the Editors of Commentary Magazine (1966), 123-126.

  51. The EMC Dean, Rabbi Jacob Rabinowitz, wrote a congratulatory letter: “It is our hope that this well-earned recognition will inspire you to even greater achievements for the greater glory of our Torah and people” (June 11, 1974).

  52. Rav Zvi Yehudah himself had asked his father Rav Avraham Yitzchak Hacohen Kook about studying in university. The answer is recorded in a letter dated June 1, 1916, Iggrot Raayah, no. 771, 39-40 that,הלוא אמרתי כמה פעמים שתעשה כנטיית רוחך הטהור “have I not told you many times that you should do as your pure spirit directs you.” He further said that secular studies serve a purpose towards revealing the ideals of Holiness.

  53. The attitude of Rav Kook’s father to Judaic studies at HU in its early days had been much more conciliatory and optimistic.

  54. I cited Einstein’s declaration on March 27, 1925 in The New Palestine (the weekly publication of the Zionist Organization of America) celebrating the opening of Hebrew University on Mt. Scopus. One of Einstein’s statements was “Science and investigation recognize as their aim the truth only”. Einstein asked that “our University will develop speedily into a great spiritual center which will evoke the respect of cultured mankind the world over”.

  55. About the visionary dream of Rav Abraham Isaac Kook to unite with Rabbi Dr. Bernard Revel in creating a joint academic institution/yeshiva for YU and Mercaz Harav see my article “Rav Kook and Dr. Revel: A Shared Vision for a Central Universal Yeshiva?” The Torah u-Madda Journal 15 (2008-2009), 188­–208. This article examines several exchanges between R. Kook and R. Revel beginning in 1918, continuing when R. Kook visited New York in 1924, and culminating in a written proposal by Revel on May 17, 1927. The proposal would have meant uniting what we now call the Torah u-Madda ideology developed in New York with Torat Erez Yisrael of Jerusalem.

  56. Never before had an Orthodox Rabbi been employed by the administration on a secular Israeli campus and my job was defined as two years. But the University President, Abraham Harman, and the Vice President, Bernard Cherick, were very supportive. Successive Deans of Students renewed my contract for a total of 16 years.

  57. Editor’s note: For more on Crescas’ approach to belief see Seth Kadish, “How Did Abraham Discover God? The Experiential Approach,” TheTorah (2013).

  58. See Marc B. Shapiro, “Is Modern Orthodoxy Moving Towards an Acceptance of Biblical Criticism?” Modern Judaism - A Journal of Jewish Ideas and Experience, vol. 37, issue 2, May 2017, pp. 165–193, https://doi.org/10.1093/mj/kjx021

  59. Bernstein (“The Orthodox Jewish Scholar and Jewish Scholarship,” 21) states that Orthodox scholars interested in Bible have chosen to study Semitic languages or Jewish biblical interpretation thus sidestepping the challenge of Biblical criticism. He further cites (33 [n26]) B. Barry Levy that Orthodox biblical scholars “are an endangered species” and there are very few “Orthodox North American scholars who regularly write about… the primary concerns of the academic field of Biblical studies.”

  60. These questions are raised by Eric Grossman, “Bible Scholarship in Orthdoxy,” TheTorah (2013).

  61. For an analysis of how and why TheTorah.com came into existence only now in the beginning of the 21st century see Chaim I. Waxman, “Why Now? Toward a Sociology of Knowledge Analysis of TheTorah.com,” TheTorah (2014).

  62. My thanks to Lawrence Grossman for suggesting emphasizing this distinction. Perhaps the answer can be clarified by exploring how the 21st century Internet age is becoming a revolutionary facilitator of new Global Communities. But that is a different discussion.