Rabbi Louis Jacobs on obtaining his doctorate in 1953. OCHJS Muller Library
The Ilui Who Couldn’t Reject Biblical Criticism: Louis Jacobs
He was British Jewry’s outstanding homegrown rabbinic scholar, a protégé of Rabbi Eliyahu Munk, and described as an ilui (genius in Torah study) by R. Eliyahu Dessler. Yet R. Louis Jacobs’ desire to reconcile Judaism with academic studies led to his exclusion from Britain's orthodox rabbinate.
Published: May 12, 2021
|
Last Updated: September 7, 2026
This essay is based upon my, Reason to Believe: The Controversial Life of Rabbi Louis Jacobs (London: Bloomsbury Continuum, 2020).
He says this in a lecture titled “The Doctrine of ‘Bread of Shame,’” available here (paywall).
Eliyahu Dessler, מכתב מאליהו [Strive for Truth] (Jerusalem, 1963), 166, translated and quoted in Elliot Cosgrove, Teyku: The Insoluble Contradictions in the Life and Thought of Louis Jacobs, Ph.D. dissertation (University of Chicago, 2008), 1.26.
In their “Louis Jacobs: We Have Reason to Believe” (TheTorah 2020), Marc Brettler and Eddie Breuer document the events which led to Jacobs’s rift with the orthodox rabbinate in Britain.
Louis Jacobs, Helping with Inquiries: An Autobiography (London: Vallentine Mitchell & Co, 1989), 63.
Founded by R. Esriel Hildesheimer in 1873, this was a strictly Orthodox institution, but one which strongly respected academic Jewish studies (though not Pentateuchal criticism), and many of whose instructors had doctorates (including Hildesheimer himself).
Jacobs, Helping with Inquiries, p. 109.
R. Eliyahu Munk to Louis Jacobs, 1954, quoted in Cosgrove, Teyku, 1.134.
Louis Jacobs, We Have Reason to Believe: Some Aspects of Jewish Theology Examined in the Light of Modern Thought (London: Vallentine Mitchell, 1957).
Ibid p.9
Editor’s note: For some discussions of different theories of revelation in Judaism, see the symposium titled “The Revelation and Authority of a Participatory Torah,” TheTorah (2017). See also, Kenneth Seeskin, “What Did the People Hear at Mount Sinai?” TheTorah (2021); Haim Kreisel, “Were Maimonides and Some of His Followers Orthoprax?” TheTorah (2017); Sam Fleischacker, “Making Sense of the Revelation at Sinai - Revisiting Maimonides' Eighth Principle of Faith,” TheTorah (2014).
Jacobs, We Have Reason to Believe, 59, quoting Hertz, Commentary to the Prayer Book, (London: National Council for Jewish Religious Education, 1942) p.252.
The lecture is titled “Two Concepts of Learning” and can be found here (paywall).
Editor’s note: For other discussions of the difference between academic and yeshivah learning, see Samuel Heilman, “Lernen, Davenen, and Identifying Orthodox,” TheTorah (2018); Zev Farber, “Traditional Torah Study Versus Scientific Analysis,” TheTorah (2018); Oren Fass, “My Encounter with the Firmament,” TheTorah (2019).