Relegating Redemption of the Firstborn to a One-time Event in the Wilderness

The Priestly Torah has two different conceptions of why/how the firstborn Israelites are exempt from serving as priests. Is a questionable firstborn census an effort to weigh in on this dispute?

SBL Style

Click to copy

"Relegating Redemption of the Firstborn to a One-time Event in the Wilderness." TheTorah.com, May 19, 2015. https://www.thetorah.com/article/relegating-redemption-of-the-firstborn-to-a-one-time-event-in-the-wilderness.

APA Style

Click to copy

"Relegating Redemption of the Firstborn to a One-time Event in the Wilderness" (2015, May 19). TheTorah.com. https://www.thetorah.com/article/relegating-redemption-of-the-firstborn-to-a-one-time-event-in-the-wilderness

Categories:

Bamidbar

Published: May 19, 2015

|

Last Updated: September 7, 2026

  1. He continues:

    והוא אומר לבכור כשהיית במעי אמך הייתה ברשותך, ועכשיו אתה ברשותנו וקידש אותך כמו שאמרה תורה קדש לי כל בכור, והמעות או החפיצין הללו חולין הן ואתה קודש וקבלו אבותיך עליהן לפדותך בהם מן הכהן כמו שאמרה תורה ופדוייו מבן חדש תפדה בערכך כסף חמשת שקלים, ועכשיו יצאת מרשותנו בחפיצים הללו, ונכנסת לחולין ברשות אבותיך, ואלו החפיצים יכנסו תחתיך לפדיונך לרשותנו.
    The Kohen says to the firstborn [= a month-old child]: “When you were in your mother’s womb, you were independent. Now you are in our possession and you have become consecrated, as the Torah says (Exod 13:2), ‘consecrate each first born to me.’ Now, these coins or objects are mundane while you are consecrated, but your forefathers accepted upon themselves to redeem you with them from the Kohen, just as the Torah said (Num 18:16), ‘Take as their redemption price, from the age of one month up, the money equivalent of five shekels by the sanctuary weight.’ You are leaving our possession in exchange for these coins and you are now mundane and in the possession of your fathers, while these objects enter our possession in your stead to redeem you.”
  2. Yet again, we find no legal or narrative precedent that would demonstrate that such a thing occurred or was even seen as a possibility in Israelite society. Although Samuel is a non-Levite firstborn dedicated to God (1 Sam 1), the fact that his mother specifically made the oath and did not take his consecration as a default demonstrates that the author of this story did not think that a firstborn male was somehow consecrated at birth.

  3. This is certainly true of modern-day pidyon haben; see Shulchan Arukh, YD 305:15, which merely states that if a father does not redeem his firstborn son, the son must redeem himself when he becomes an adult.

  4. But this command comes only after God repeats the content of v. 41 verbatim in v. 45, to take the Levites in place of the firstborn. This Wiederaufnahme or resumptive repetition implies a complex redaction history for this section, most likely that the intervening verses are secondary, something that will have to be explored another time.

  5. The line about cattle here seems to come out of nowhere and is difficult to understand. Moreover, there is no ritual at the end of the chapter for exchanging cows as there is for people.

  6. Several non-Priestly texts that discuss what to do with a firstborn (Exodus 22:28-29 and Exodus 34:19-20—the latter discusses redemption) will not be dealt with here.

  7. There is nothing stopping God from having both firstborns and Levites serve but there would be no need for the exchange.

  8. For more on these problems and an alternative solution, see Ben Zion Katz, “Recounting the Census: A Military Force of 5,500 (not 603,550) Men,” TheTorah (2015).

  9. [9] This would answer a further problem with the text: If the author of the census account had originally envisioned Moses counting the firstborn as well, would it not make more sense—from the perspective of verisimilitude at least—to have told this to Moses from the beginning? If Moses was already going to count all the Israelite males—hundreds of thousands of them—would it not have been more convenient to have done both of these censuses at the same time? If, as we suggest, the census of the firstborn was added later, this problem falls off, since the original author did not envision a second census of the same families.