Torah from Heaven: Redefining the Question

Many Orthodox Jews believe that God composed the Torah, and feel no need to inquire further. Nevertheless, it does occurs to me to inquire further, and find a respectful answer to the question of how people, including myself, come to this belief. An honest question beats a dishonest answer, even if the dishonest answer produces much more comfort.

SBL Style

Click to copy

"Torah from Heaven: Redefining the Question." TheTorah.com, October 30, 2013. https://www.thetorah.com/article/torah-from-heaven-redefining-the-question.

APA Style

Click to copy

"Torah from Heaven: Redefining the Question" (2013, October 30). TheTorah.com. https://www.thetorah.com/article/torah-from-heaven-redefining-the-question

Torah from Heaven: Redefining the Question

Wooden shelves with Jewish prayer books at the entrance to Western Wall. 123rf

Categories:

Modern Faith

Published: October 30, 2013

|

Last Updated: September 7, 2026

  1. I wonder if we could read, or even imagine, a book, which takes part in no literary tradition. Perhaps a book in a language that no human could decipher might qualify, for whatever value it would have.

  2. [2] In the idiom of the Bible, whatever the proximate cause of an event or product, its ultimate cause is God.  “Why has God done this to us?” the prophet can complain, thinking about what our human enemies have done to us.  So maybe every book produced on earth qualifies as God’s book, produced, ultimately, by God.  A true religious genius could discern God as the source of any book, or could “see the world in a grain of sand,/ and to see heaven in a wild flower,/ hold infinity in the palm of your hand,/and eternity in an hour.” In some sense, though, we want the Torah to show the presence of God more directly, even to the rest of us. But what characteristics do we want the book of God to have?

    [3] In the first line of the Torah: “In the beginning, God created . . .” who does the speaking?  That may be as slippery a literary technique as any.

    [4] In case Shakespeare’s point is not clear, in effect, he says, “I love you so foolishly that, even though you do bad things, I cannot think you do bad things.”

    [5] The advisor then predated his letter of acceptance, lying and taking who knows what risk, to ensure that Rabbi Kapustin would earn his degree.  This student of Wellhausen, even in Nazi Germany, took an action that escaped the stain of anti-Semitism.

    [6] I am looking through Daube’s collected works –no small task — to find the reference again. Thus far, I have found two other references to this idea. He refers to “the possibility of gradual growth before the revelation” in a footnote in “Codes and Codas,” noting that this would be consistent with Orthodox belief, but that Orthodox Jews usually are “averse to any detailed inquiry.” In a footnote in “Law and the Narratives,” Daube asserts that the co-existence of two versions of the death of Moses, provided they both existed ‘from the outset,” “is not, as far as I can see, in conflict with axioms of Orthodox Judaism.”

    [7] He does explain how he understands the two versions of Adam: in the first story, Adam and his wife fit right into the world.  They are majestic creatures, able to function and accomplish what they set out to do.  In the second, Adam worries about his relationship with God, with his wife, and later with his children.  He is lonely and troubled as he tries to find community.  Rabbi Soloveitchik argues that human beings, all of us, have the characteristics of both Adam 1 and Adam 2, and we oscillate between the two poles, the untroubled, self-sufficient doer, and the lonely seeker of community.