Solomon reading from the Torah of Moses (detail), “North French Hebrew Miscellany,” illuminated manuscript, late 13th C., The British Library.
A King Who Reads Torah
Deuteronomy envisions a king constantly reading torah and limiting his wealth and resources. Is this how kings are described in the rest of the Bible? What was kingship like in the ancient Near East?
Published: August 24, 2017
|
Last Updated: October 28, 2026
Although in Gen 17:6, 16 God promises Abraham that his offspring will be kings, it is not clear whom they will rule. Exod 19:6 advances a vision that is both democratic and sacral, in which the people themselves will become a kingdom of priests.
Scholars agree that the “Royal Psalms” include Ps 2, 18, 20, 21, 45, 72, 89, 101, 110, 132, 144, although some augment this list with many more psalms.
In stark contrast with the instructions the Lord gives Samuel in 1 Sam 16:7, regarding the choosing of Saul’s successor.
These texts can be understood as a type of propaganda. Although kingship can function even when the governed are unwilling, assuming the king has amassed enough power to bend the people to his will, the system of kingship is more effective and efficient if subjects are willing to cede their rights without coercion. Towards these ends ideology operates to persuade the subjects that royal authority works to the benefit of the public as a whole.
Martha T. Roth, Law Collections from Mesopotamia and Asia Minor(2nd edition; Atlanta: Scholars Press, 1997), 76-81.
Roth, Law Collections, 134-35.
K. Lawson Younger, Jr., “The Azatiwada Inscription,” in The Context of Scripture, Vol. 2 (W. Hallo and K. L. Younger, eds; Leiden: Brill, 2000), 149.
The meaning of the term is uncertain, although it might be related to מסכן “poor” in Qoh 4:13, 9:15-16.
K. Lawson Younger, Jr., “The Kulamuwa Inscription,” in The Context of Scripture, vol. 2, 147-48.
K. A. D. Smelik, “The Inscription of King Mesha,” in The Context of Scripture, vol. 2, 138.
See also 2 Sam 14:4-12. The beginning of Parashat Shoftim in Deut 16:18 – 17:13 relegates the administration of justice to the local leadership, or in difficult cases, to a high court comprised of Levitical priests. This might indicate that the section derives from kingless period, or reflects an anti-monarchic tendency. Editor’s note: See discussion in Yigal Levin and Parry Moshe, “Deuteronomy’s Justice System: Real and Ideal,”TheTorah.com (2015).
See, for example, 1 Kings 9:4, 11:6, 33, 38, 15:3, 11, 2 Kings 14:3, 16:2, 18:3, 22:2.
This is in marked contrast with actions attributed to Saul, and see 1 Sam 14:35, 28:4.
“The House of David” and see 1 Kings 12:19-20, 26, 13:2, 14:8, 2 Kings 17:21, and particularly the mention of ביתדוד in the Aramaic Tel Dan inscription. For the text and translation of the Tel Dan Stele, see, Christopher Rollston, “The Tel-Dan Inscription,” Bible Odyssey.
This despite the many sins and fatal flaws detailed in Samuel his adultery with Bathsheba, his engineering the death of Uriah, his reluctance to censure his son Amnon for the incestuous rape of his half-sister Tamar, as well as his blatant lie to Ahimelek, the priest of Nob (1 Sam 21:2-3), which placed the entire town of Nob at risk of punishment for succoring a renegade from King Saul’s service. The author of Samuel accomplishes this overall positive evaluation of David through a series of artful comparisons with Saul. Whereas Saul fails in every endeavor, all that David attempts is capped by success. The reader is further led to overlook David’s shortcomings by default, in light of the negative portrayal of Saul in 1 Sam 13:7-14 and 15:1-35 since, according to the narrator of the Book of Samuel, Saul loses his kingship because he does not obey the Lord’s commandments, unlike David, who receives the Lord’s promise of an everlasting dynasty (2 Sam 7:5-17) as a replacement for Saul’s failed dynasty.
In addition to its juridical and legal sense, term משפט also carries the meanings of “practice,” “manner” and “measure.” In this case, “custom” provides the best sense for the practices common to kings as represented in 1 Sam 8:11-17.
Despite the rabbinic debate whether Deut 17:14-15 is a commandment (מצוה) or merely a permitted option (Sanhedrin 20b; Ibn Ezra vs. Gersonides, Nachmanides and Bechor Shor on Deut 17:14-16), the conditional nature of the sentence becomes clear when comparing the Hebrew wording with other casuistic laws in Deuteronomy, such as Deut 15:12, 17:2-5, 19:16-19, where [כי [יקטל] ו- [קטל expresses the “if … then” formula. Editor’s note: For a different interpretation of this text, see Zev Farber, “Does the Torah Really Want Us to Appoint a King?”TheTorah.com (2016).
Note, for example, lines 1 and 40 of the Sumerian King List, which state that kingship originally descended from heaven; see Jeremy A. Black, et al., The Electronic Text Corpus of Sumerian Literature, Oxford, 1998-2001 (http://etcsl.orinst.ox.ac.uk/section2/tr211.htm).
On the face of things, the notion of divine designation also seems at odds with the dynastic principle, which was basic to kingship throughout the entire Ancient Near East and seems to have been in effect in Israel for long swaths of its history and Judah throughout its entire history. However, according to the dynastic principle, the entire dynasty is divinely chosen, and thus the reference to appointing a king is only relevant for the first appointment in history or when a dynasty collapses; see Tomoo Ishida, The Royal Dynasties in Ancient Israel: a Study on the Formation and Development of Royal-Dynastic Ideology (Berlin: de Gruyter, 1977).
Logically, the first condition, of divine designation, already precludes the possibility that the people would choose foreign rule. Most likely this latter condition already foresees a future in which the people of Israel and Judah lose their autonomy and become foreign subjects and is thus particularly worried about the possibility of a foreign “king.” Some scholars view this duality as evidence that the Law of the King underwent one or more stages of revision. While this may be so, there is no significant textual or literary evidence in the text that supports redactional analysis.
The referent of the term Torah here is not entirely clear. “This Torah” could mean “this instruction”, referring to the “Law of the King.” However, the expression “this Torah” occurs several times in Deuteronomy in a self-referential fashion to indicate the Book of Deuteronomy itself, and see Deut 1:5, 4:8, 44, 28:58, 61, 29:20, 30:10. Editor’s note: See discussion in David Glatt-Gilad, “Deuteronomy: The First Torah,” TheTorah.com (2015).
See, e.g., Susan Niditch, Oral World and Written Word: Ancient Israelite Literature (Louisville, Ky.: Westminster John Knox, 1996), 39-58; David M. Carr, Writing on the Tablet of the Heart: Origins of Scripture and Literature (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2005), 115-28; Christopher A. Rollston, Writing and Literacy in the World of Ancient Israel: Epigraphic Evidence from the Iron Age (Atlanta: Society of Biblical Literature, 2010), 127-35. Editor’s note: For a somewhat different take, see, Aaron Demsky, Literacy in Ancient Israel (The Biblical Encyclopaedia Library XXVIII; Jerusalem: The Bialik Institute, 2012) [Hebrew].
So too, the unparalleled detailed description of the reign of Solomon may likely derive from archival records or a chronicle of his reign, although this matter is greatly debated.