Breaking the Heifer’s Neck: A Bloodless Ritual for an Unsolved Murder

If a corpse is found in a field, and the killer is unknown, the enders of the closest city to break a heifer’s neck by a stream and declare that they did not spill “this blood” (Deuteronomy 21). How does this ritual of eglah arufah, “broken-necked heifer,” atone for Israel’s bloodguilt?

SBL Style

Click to copy

"Breaking the Heifer’s Neck: A Bloodless Ritual for an Unsolved Murder." TheTorah.com, August 14, 2018. https://www.thetorah.com/article/breaking-the-heifers-neck-a-bloodless-ritual-for-an-unsolved-murder.

APA Style

Click to copy

"Breaking the Heifer’s Neck: A Bloodless Ritual for an Unsolved Murder" (2018, August 14). TheTorah.com. https://www.thetorah.com/article/breaking-the-heifers-neck-a-bloodless-ritual-for-an-unsolved-murder

Categories:

Shoftim

Published: August 14, 2018

|

Last Updated: September 7, 2026

  1. Text edition: Harry A. Hoffner, The Laws of the Hittites: A Critical Edition (Leiden: Brill, 1997), 20. The translation is mine. For further discussion, see my Blood Expiation in Hittite and Biblical Ritual: Origins, Context and Meaning (Atlanta: Society of Biblical Literature, 2011), 236–40.

  2. A later expansion (IV) sets forth differential payments based on the status of the victim:

    If a person is killed on another’s property, if (the victim) is a free person, (the owner) shall give the property, the house and 1 mina and 20 shekels of silver. If it is a woman, he shall give 3 minas of silver.

  3. The Hittite laws were first written down in the Old Hittite period, 1650–1500 B.C.E. The late revision discussed here appears in a copy from the New Hittite period (14th–early 12th cent. B.C.E.). Although these versions were recorded on separate “manuscripts” (cuneiform tablets), several modern editions and translations place the parallel versions side by side for comparison.

  4. For an early discussion of this parallel, see Alexander Roifer (Rofé), “עגלה ערופה,” Tarbiz 31 (1961–1962): 119–143 [Hebrew]. This parallel brings to mind the possibility of literary dependence, though this question cannot be adequately addressed here. In brief, it should be noted that other examples may be cited (especially the rape law of Deut 22: 23 – 27 and HL 197), they are not as pervasive and systematic as those found in comparing the Covenant Collection (Exod 21–23) and the Laws of Hammurabi. While it is possible that these Deuteronomic laws are based on a body of ancient legal traditions that also informed the Hittite laws, it is also possible that these similar laws merely reflect a shared set of values and beliefs regarding the transgressions in question.

  5. Between verses 4 and 6 comes a verse saying that the Levitical priests appear:

    כא:ה וְנִגְּשׁוּ הַכֹּהֲנִים בְּנֵי לֵוִי כִּי בָם בָּחַר יְ-הוָה אֱלֹהֶיךָ לְשָׁרְתוֹ וּלְבָרֵךְ בְּשֵׁם יְ-הוָה וְעַל פִּיהֶם יִהְיֶה כָּל רִיב וְכָל נָגַע.
    21:5 The priests, the sons of Levi shall approach, for YHWH, your God, has chosen them to serve him and bless in the name of YHWH, and according to their command shall be every dispute and injury.

    Nevertheless, the Levitical priests do not seem to do anything, and the ritual is done entirely by the elders. Moreover, the verse interrupts between the elders bringing the heifer to the stream and their washing their hands. These observations lead some scholars to suggest that an editor added this verse to make this ancient ritual fit with Deuteronomy’s overall view that priests need to officiate at any ritual act. For a discussion of the likelihood that the elders represent an older layer of law upon which Deuteronomy built, see, Yigal Levin and Parry Moshe, “Deuteronomy’s Justice System: Real and Ideal,” TheTorah.com (2015).

  6. For a helpful summary and analysis, see David P. Wright, “Deuteronomy 21:1–9 as a Rite of Elimination,” CBQ 49 (1987): 387–403. See also, Martin Lockshin, “Eglah Arufah: A Ritual Response to an Unsolved Murder,” TheTorah.com (2017).

  7. A slightly different usage of the root ע.ר.פ appears in Hosea 10:2 which refers to God (?) destroying Israel’s altars:

    הוּא יַעֲרֹף מִזְבְּחוֹתָם יְשֹׁדֵד מַצֵּבוֹתָם
    He will break (the tops) of their altars, destroy their standing stones.

    This usage may anticipate the modern Hebrew use of this verb in the sense “decapitate” (as opposed to “neck-breaking”), here referring to the breaking the tops off Israel’s illicit altars. More importantly, however, this source reinforces the anti-sacrificial connotations of the verb.

  8. As noted by Henry McKeating, “The Development of the Law of Homicide in Ancient Israel,” VT 25 (1975): 46-68 [63, n. 22]; Calum M. Carmichael, “A Common Element in Five Supposedly Disparate Laws,” VT 29 (1979): 129-142 [133].

  9. The rabbis see this ritual as a parallel to the execution of murderers, who are also decapitated (b. Sanhedrin 52b; Soncino trans. with adjustments):

    …תניא: ואתה תבער הדם הנקי מקרבך – הוקשו כל שופכי דמים לעגלה ערופה, מה להלן – בסייף ומן הצואר אף כאן בסייף ומן הצואר. – אי מה להלן בקופיץ וממול עורף, אף כאן בקופיץ וממול עורף? – אמר רב נחמן אמר רבה בר אבוה: אמר קרא ואהבת לרעך כמוך – ברור לו מיתה יפה.
    It has been taught: “So shall you put away the guilt of the innocent blood from among you” serves to denote that all that shed blood are likened [in treatment] to the atoning heifer: just as there, it is done with a sword and at the neck, so too here, execution is with the sword and at the neck [i.e., the throat]. If so, just as there it was done with an axe, and on the nape of the neck, so too here? — R. Nahman answered in the name of Rabbah b. Abbuha: “Scripture says: ‘You shalt love thy neighbor as yourself’ – choose an easy death for him.”
  10. This is in contrast to the killing of birds in sacrificial rituals:

    ויקרא ה:ח וְהֵבִיא אֹתָם אֶל הַכֹּהֵן וְהִקְרִיב אֶת אֲשֶׁר לַחַטָּאת רִאשׁוֹנָה וּמָלַק אֶת רֹאשׁוֹ מִמּוּל עָרְפּוֹ וְלֹא יַבְדִּיל.
    Lev 5:8 He shall bring them to the priest, who shall offer first the one for the sin offering, pinching its head at the nape without severing it.

    This cannot have been bloodless since the next verse deals with what one does with the blood (see also Lev 1:15).

  11. M. Soṭah 9:5. This is the simple meaning of the Mishnah, though Maimonides (ad loc.) interprets קשה (hard) not to mean dry but to mean חזקה, with a strong water flow.

  12. The use of the root k-p-r in the context of bloodguilt refers to making compensation for the spilt blood. According to the traditional requirement of blood retribution, the blood of the murderer was demanded to pay off (expiate, from Latin ex-pio) the blood-debt. For further discussion, see my, “Expiating with Blood,” TheTorah.com (2015).

  13. The confusion raised by this verse is best captured by the suggestion of Raphael Patai, who suggests that since “this blood” must refer to that of the heifer, the elders’ denial of guilt is in effect placing the blame on the murderer for bringing about the death of the heifer (“The ‘Egla ‘Arufa or the Expiation of Polluted Land,” JQR 30 [1939–1940], 67).

  14. This understanding was already noted by the rabbinic commentators Rashbam and Ramban (ad loc.).

  15. Through the narrator’s remark “in order (לְמַעַן)…,” we learn that Reuben’s real intention is to return later to free Joseph from the pit (cf. v. 29). For our purposes, however, it is the nature of Reuben’s argument, which successfully convinces his brothers, that is informative.

  16. See Moshe Greenberg, “Some Postulates of Biblical Criminal Law,” in Yehezkel Kaufmann Jubilee Volume (ed. Menahem Haran; Jerusalem: Magnes, 1960), 5–29; cf. Pamela Barmash, Homicide in the Biblical World (Cambridge: Cambridge University, 2005), 142–147.

  17. In contrast, the standard ancient Near Eastern practice seems to have involved monetary compensation (Hoffner, Laws, 165–167). To my knowledge, the closest parallel to the biblical notion of asylum and the restrictions governing them are represented in ancient Greek sources; see Robert Parker, Miasma: Pollution and Purification in Early Greek Religion (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1983), 104–143.

  18. See Klaus Seybold, “חנף”, TDOT 5: 42–43; Jacob Licht, A Commentary on the Book of Numbers (vol. 3; Jerusalem, 1995), ad loc. (Heb.).

  19. While this attitude may possibly be traced back to a folk belief in the need to placate the spirit of the dead (Gen 4:10), the more conventional view represented in the biblical sources is that blood retribution is a necessary principle of divine justice.

  20. Bruce Kapferer, “Ritual Dynamics and Virtual Practice. Beyond Representation and Meaning,” in Ritual in its own Right (eds. Don Handelman and Galina Lindquist; New York: Berghahn, 2005), 35–52 [47–48].