Did Jacob Meet YHWH by the Stairway to Heaven in Beth-El?

On his way to Haran, Jacob stops at a place, later named Beth-El, and sees in a dream angels going up and down a staircase to the gateway of heaven. In the story, Jacob also notices YHWH standing beside him and YHWH speaks to him. Examined closely, this short story is beset with literary difficulties that suggest it is composed of two independent narratives.

SBL Style

Click to copy

"Did Jacob Meet YHWH by the Stairway to Heaven in Beth-El?." TheTorah.com, November 15, 2018. https://www.thetorah.com/article/did-jacob-meet-yhwh-by-the-stairway-to-heaven-in-beth-el.

APA Style

Click to copy

"Did Jacob Meet YHWH by the Stairway to Heaven in Beth-El?" (2018, November 15). TheTorah.com. https://www.thetorah.com/article/did-jacob-meet-yhwh-by-the-stairway-to-heaven-in-beth-el

Did Jacob Meet YHWH by the Stairway to Heaven in Beth-El?

Jacob’s Dream by Aert de Gelder 1710-1715 Dulwich Picture Gallery – Wikimedia

Categories:

Vayetzei

Published: November 15, 2018

|

Last Updated: September 7, 2026

  1. The definite article in the word בַּמָּקוֺם is correctly translated in JPS and elsewhere as “aplace”, i.e., a previously unknown one, and not “the place”; for this use of the definite article see GKC§126r.

  2. For the related promise to Abraham, see Gen 13:14–17 (discussed below); compare 12:2–3, 7; for its repetition to Isaac, see Gen 26:3­–4. The words וְנִבְרְכוּ בְךַָ in v. 14 and the similar phrases in the parallel passages mentioned means that other peoples, when blessing themselves or each other, will express the desire that the fate of the recipient of the blessing be like that of the Israelites; see Gen 48:20.

  3. וַיִּיקַץ in v. 16 describes waking up in the middle of the night, while וַיַּשְׁכֵּם in v. 18 indicates rising at the dawn of a new day; this does not constitute a doublet in the story, as will become clear below.

  4. This the meaning of נצב על elsewhere; see Gen 18:2; 24:13; Exod 18:14; Num 23:6; Ruth 2:5.

  5. See Joel S. Baden, The Promise to the Patriarchs (NY: Oxford University Press, 2013), 73–74, 85, for further discussion of this issue.

  6. On this verse, see below.

  7. Surprisingly, source critics seem not to have arrived at a consensus on how to resolve our text into two narrative strands; the following solution is my own, building on the work of previous scholars.

  8. See below for discussion of “the ground” vs. “the land” as the meaning of the word הָאָרֶץ here, as well as the reconstruction “that you see” in place of “on which you are lying.”

  9. A neder is not by definition an “if-then” undertaking. While it is true that several vows occurring in narrative contexts are preceded by conditional clauses (see Num 21:2; Jud 11:30–31; 1Sam 1:11; 2Sam 17:8) this is by no means a requirement; see Jer 44:25 as well as all of the references to nĕdārîm “vows” that appear in legal, cultic, poetic and other texts—none of which indicate that the person making the vow is expected to make it contingent on anything at all. It is equally clear that, contingent or not, no neder is fulfilled in some generalized manner as would be implied by our text if vss. 20a–21 were part of Jacob’s vow. It was the compiler of the Torah who (perhaps because he noticed the formal similarities between Jacob’s declaration in J and the vows reported in the narratives just mentioned) saw fit to combine Jacob’s words in J with his vow in E, with the canonical vv. 20–22 as the result.

  10. Editor’s note: For an attempt to make sense of the final form of this neder, see Zvi Grumet, “Jacob’s Deal with God,” TheTorah.com (2013).

  11. The conjunction “and” in the translations (“and this stone”) reflects the waw in the Hebrew (וְהָאֶבֶן), which was added by the compiler; see below.

  12. For a similar sequence in which dreaming at night is followed by awakening from the dream during the night, expressed by וַיִּיקַץ, after which the dreamer falls asleep again (and in this case, dreams again and awakes again), while only subsequently we are told of his actions in the morning, see E’s account of Pharaoh’s dreams in Gen 41:1–8.

  13. Critics have long noted E’s propensity for portraying encounters with Yhwh as taking place in dreams; Robert Karl Gnuse, The Elohist: A Seventh-Century Theological Tradition(Eugene, Oregon: Cascade Books: 2017), 63–66, and note E’s programmatic statement in Num 12:6. Of course this by no means implies that all of the dreams in the Pentateuch must be assigned to E or that E knows of no form of divine revelation other than dreams.

  14. Editor’s note: For more on how the revelation of the name YHWH functions in the Documentary Hypothesis, see, Zev Farber, “Documentary Hypothesis: The Revelation of YHWH’s Name Continues to Enlighten,” TheTorah.com (2014).

  15. As far as I can tell, the E thread leaves off after its account of the Akedah (Gen 22:1–14 +19); its sudden reappearance in Gen 28:11 implies that it included more than has been incorporated in the Torah.

  16. Notice also that ויאמר “He said” actually occurs at precisely the same place in both sources. J had this word between what are now v. 16b and v. 20b; in E it was the second word in what is now v. 17. It is not unusual for the sources to “share” such phrases.

  17. That is: I am (the messenger of) the God of Bethel—since it is the messenger who is speaking, on behalf of God.

  18. Sincere thanks to Justin Moses, David Ridge, David Harris, Hananel Shapira and Or Liber for their help in preparing this essay.