Edomite Kings List: Is It Post-Mosaic?

Genesis 36:31 introduces a list of kings who ruled “before a king ruled in Israel,” ostensibly a reference to Saul. Traditional commentators, committed to the Mosaic authorship of the Torah, have long struggled to reinterpret this phrase against its plain meaning, though some accepted its implications.

SBL Style

Click to copy

"Edomite Kings List: Is It Post-Mosaic?." TheTorah.com, December 12, 2019. https://www.thetorah.com/article/edomite-kings-list-is-it-post-mosaic.

APA Style

Click to copy

"Edomite Kings List: Is It Post-Mosaic?" (2019, December 12). TheTorah.com. https://www.thetorah.com/article/edomite-kings-list-is-it-post-mosaic

Edomite Kings List: Is It Post-Mosaic?

Edomite kings list, in the Almanzi Pentateuch (1450-1474), MS 27167, f.62v and f.63r. British Library

Published: December 12, 2019

|

Last Updated: September 7, 2026

  1. The passage here is generally considered to be part of P’s narrative:

    בראשית לו:ו וַיִּקַּח עֵשָׂו אֶת נָשָׁיו וְאֶת בָּנָיו וְאֶת בְּנֹתָיו וְאֶת כָּל נַפְשׁוֹת בֵּיתוֹ וְאֶת מִקְנֵהוּ וְאֶת כָּל בְּהֶמְתּוֹ וְאֵת כָּל קִנְיָנוֹ אֲשֶׁר רָכַשׁ בְּאֶרֶץ כְּנָעַן וַיֵּלֶךְ אֶל אֶרֶץ מִפְּנֵי יַעֲקֹב אָחִיו. לו:ז כִּי הָיָה רְכוּשָׁם רָב מִשֶּׁבֶת יַחְדָּו וְלֹא יָכְלָה אֶרֶץ מְגוּרֵיהֶם לָשֵׂאת אֹתָם מִפְּנֵי מִקְנֵיהֶם. לו:ח וַיֵּשֶׁב עֵשָׂו בְּהַר שֵׂעִיר עֵשָׂו הוּא אֱדוֹם.
    Gen 36:6 Esau took his wives, his sons and daughters, and all the members of his household, his cattle and all his livestock, and all the property that he had acquired in the land of Canaan, and went to another land because of his brother Jacob. 36:7 For their possessions were too many for them to dwell together, and the land where they sojourned could not support them because of their livestock. 36:8 So Esau settled in the hill country of Seir—Esau being Edom.
  2. This list does not connect to the promise to Abraham, of course, but it does lead to Rebekah and Laban (father of Rachel and Leah), who will be important later in Genesis as providing marriage partners for Abraham’s son and grandson.

  3. The inclusion of Seir’s sons and clans is unusual, as Seir is described as a Hurrian and not part of Abraham’s family. The ostensible reason for its inclusion is because Seir is an integral part of Edom, which is the theme of this unit.

  4. See Christopher Rollston, "Who Wrote the Torah according to the Torah," TheTorah.com (2017).

  5. Rashbam continues his gloss by saying:

    {ואין לומר לפני מלך שאול,} כי עד דוד מצאתי ביוסיפון אחרי אילו המלכים קרוב לארבעים מלכים נקובי שמות זה אחר זה.
    {And do not say that [it means] before king Saul} since I found in the book of Josippon that until the time of David there were almost forty kings, all named, ruled one after the other.

    The line in brackets does not appear in our Rashbam texts but is included in quotes of Rashbam in Hizquni and Hadar Zekeinim, and was reintroduced into the text in the Al-Hatorah website.

  6. This reading is also adopted by Ralbag (R. Levi Gersonides, 1288–1344) and R. Obadiah Sforno (1475–1550). Although he suggests a different explanation, Shadal (ad loc.) also defends this reading:

    ורשב״ם וראב״ע ואחרים פירשו כי משה עצמו נקרא מלך, ככתוב "ויהי בישורון מלך" וזה עולה יפה לפי דעתי ששם מלך נגזר מן מוליך (dux), ומשה היה מוליך ומנהל את ישראל, אע״פ שפסוק ויהי בישורון מלך איננו לדעתי על משה.
    Rashbam and ibn Ezra and others explain that Moses was himself called king, as it says (Deut 33:5): “And there was a king in Jeshurun.” This works well, in my view, for the word king comes from the verb rule (dux), and Moses did rule over and direct the Israelites, even though in my view, the verse “and there was a king in Israel” is not about Moses.
  7. This same midrash appears in Leviticus Rabbah (Parshat Emor 31) and Ecclesiastes Rabbah (10), and is taken for granted in a number of rabbinic passages.

  8. See discussion of this verse in the context of verses about God’s kingship in, Israel Knohl, “Rosh Hashanah: Why the Torah Suppresses God's Kingship,” TheTorah (2018). Even if one were to read it as a reference to a human king, Moses referring to himself should be understood as an accident of redaction. In other words, the text was likely composed in a later period and would have been speaking about the monarch in the author’s time, but the (even later) editors, by attributing the song to Moses, created an anachronism. The same phenomenon occurs in the song of Channah (1 Sam 2:10), who refers to a king even though her story is set in the time before the monarchy.

  9. Shadal also suggests a second interpretation:

    ויתכן ג״כ לפרש לפני מלוך מלך לבני ישראל קודם שיהיו ישראל לעם אחד בארץ וראויים להמליך עליהם מלך, ומיד אחרי משה היו יכולים להמליך עליהם מלך.
    And it even seems possible to interpret “before a king ruled the children of Israel” to mean before the Israelites became one people on the land and were fit to be ruled by a king, and immediately after Moses they were fit to have a king rule over them.
  10. Christian Benedict Michaelis (1680–1764) was a professor of theology and oriental languages at the University of Halle. He was a student (and successor) of his uncle, Johann Heinrich Michaelis (1668–1738), who is best known for publishing the Hallische Bibel (Biblical Hebraica, pub. 1720), the first critical edition of the Hebrew Bible, based upon 5 manuscripts and 9 editions. Like his mentor, Christian Benedict Michaelis was also a philologist, as was his son (the great nephew of Johann Heinrich), Johann David Michaelis (1717–1791), who did text-critical work on the Syriac Peshitta. Johann David Michaelis’ 6-volume Gründliche Erklärung des mosaischen Rechts (A Thorough Explanation of Mosaic Law) interprets the Pentateuchal law collections as the human achievement of a great thinker and was considered forward thinking for his day. Ernst Friedrich Karl Rosenmüller (1768–1835) was a professor of Arabic and Oriental Languages in the University of Leipzig. He was an early advocate for the historical-critical method and was known for pushing the idea that Isaiah was the product of multiple authors.

  11. For a full translation of ibn Ezra’s comment here and Bonfils glosses, see Section G in "Seven Torah Passages of Non-Mosaic Origin According to Ibn Ezra and R. Joseph Bonfils," TheTorah (2014).

  12. Isaac (Abū Ibrāhīm) Ibn Qasṭār ibn Yashūsh of Toledo (982–1056) was a prominent grammarian, whom Moses ibn Ezra refers to as one of two experts (the other being ibn Janach), and whose philological work was even praised by Abraham ibn Ezra. Some suggest that the Kitāb al-Taṣārif (Book of Conjugations), which exists in manuscript form in the Oxford and Saint Petersburg Library collections, should be attributed to ibn Yashush. See discussion in, José Martínez Delgado, “Ibn Yashūsh, Isaac (Abū Ibrāhīm) Ibn Qasṭār,” in Encyclopedia of Jews in the Islamic World, vol. 2, ed., Norman A. Stillman (Leiden: Brill, 2010).

  13. Israeli is the author of multiple medical treatises, many of which have been translated into English. See Alexander Altmann and Samuel M. Stern, Isaac Israeli, a Neoplatonic Philosopher of the Early Tenth Century: His Works Translated with Comments and an Outline of his Philosophy, Scripta Judaica 1 (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1958); reprinted with new forward by Alfred Ivry (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2009).

  14. The text says “Taḥpanḥes” but this appears to be a mistake for Taḥpenes, since Taḥpanḥes is a city not a person. The same is true of the text in Bonfils, which is merely quoting ibn Ezra here.

  15. For more on this king, see Tzvi Novick, "The Depiction of Jeroboam and Hadad as Moses-like Saviors," TheTorah (2019).

  16. Bonfils makes this point explicitly:

    "כי בימי יהושפט נכתבה"—פירוש: כי דעתו היתה שהראשון היה שאול, כאשר אמר, וסובר כרש"י שאלו המלכים היו שמנה וכנגדם העמיד יעקב ונטל מלכות מעשו כל ימיהם. ואלו הם: שאול, ואיש בושת, דוד, ושלמה, רחבעם, אביה, אסא, יהושפט. ובימי[ו] (שאול) כתיב: "אין מלך באדום נצב מלך" (מ"א כב:מח). "ובימי יורם פשע אדום מתחת יד יהודה וימליכו עליהם מלך" (מ"ב ח:כ). וכן נדרש בבראשית רבה (פרש' פג, אות ב).
    “This section was written during the time of Jehoshaphat”—the meaning: His opinion is that the first king was Saul, as explained, and he agrees with Rashi, that there were eight [Edomite] kings, and as a counter to them, Jacob (=Israel) appointed eight kings, during whose time Esau (=Edom) had no king of its own. These were: Saul, Ish Boshet, David, Solomon, Rehoboam, Abiyah, Asa, and Jehoshaphat. In [his] days, it says (1 Kings 22:48): “There was no king in Edom; a viceroy acted as king.” It was in the days of Joram that Edom rebelled against Judah and appointed a king over themselves (2 Kings 8:20). This also appears as a derashah in Genesis Rabbah (83:2).

    The fact that Rashi also cites this midrash, and that Rashi’s name was Solomon Yitzḥaqi, led some to suggest that ibn Ezra was referring to him as Yitzḥaqi, though this is almost certainly not the case: Rashi does not say some of the things ibn Ezra quotes Yitzḥaqi as saying and, anyway, ibn Ezra generally refers to him as Rabbi Solomon.

  17. ולפי זה צריך לפרש שהיתה מלכותו קודם שאול והוסר ממלכותו כל ימי שאול ואיש בושת ודוד ושלמה עד זקנתו של שלמה, והנה חיה שנים רבות! וכל צריך כל האחרים לפרש.
    According to this, [Yitzḥaqi] would have to explain that [Hadad] ruled before Saul, lost his thrown for the entire time Saul, David and Solomon ruled until Solomon’s old age. This would have been very many years. He would need to offer this interpretation about the others as well.

    Bonfils’ reading assumes that Yitzḥaqi believes this to be a list of kings from before Saul but written in Jehoshaphat’s time, but this is a hard interpretation to accept. Bonfils’ himself is aware of what a stretch such an interpretation is, but Bonfils sides with ibn Ezra and is not attempting to read Yitzḥaqi generously.

  18. For a discussion of ibn Ezra’s position here, see my "Editorial Comments in the Opening Chapters of Deuteronomy," TheTorah (2013); idem, "The Significance of Ibn Ezra's Position that Verses Were Added to the Torah," TheTorah (2014).

  19. The word for passage here is parashah; he means this in the technical sense of a paragraph between two spaces (probably a reference here to petuchot, though perhaps also setumot).

  20. This answer seems forced, and also technically incorrect, since the parashah continues into vv. 40–43, the second list of Edomite clans, which is not described as being added. Moreover, even Bonfils must admit that ibn Ezra’s comment that all of Deuteronomy 34 was written after Moses violates the “parashah law.” Perhaps, in this case, Bonfils could claim that ibn Ezra was merely extending a suggestion already made in rabbinic literature (though this extension literally creates the parashah problem that the rabbis otherwise avoid).

  21. See David Glatt-Gilad, "Reimagining the Israelite-Edomite Encounter," TheTorah (2016).

  22. I do not know what city פנדייא is or even how to transliterate it properly.

  23. This is not the only case in which R. Yehudah HeChasid suggests post-Mosaic changes to the Torah for counter-intuitive reasons. See Baruch J. Schwartz, “When Moses Place Ephraim before Manasseh,” TheTorah (2016), where he again suggests that the Men of the Great Assembly added a passage. See also my, “The Song of the Well, Psalm 136, Was Removed from the Torah,” TheTorah (2016), which discusses a passage that R. Yehudah HeChasid argues was removed from the Torah by King David.