To the Lord be glory, (detail) Stanisław Grocholski circa 1895
Mitzvah Piety and the Need for Individual Atonement
In the Priestly texts, observing the divine commandments became an end in itself while the unique meaning or purpose of the particular mitzvah took on less significance. Concomitantly, Priestly authors asserted the need for personal atonement through a chatat (sin offering) for even unintentionally violating God’s commandments.
Published: March 29, 2017
|
Last Updated: September 7, 2026
In theory, a third option, prayer, could be added to the mix. Nevertheless, prayer seems to be secondary in the Bible from a number of vantage points. First, prayer of the individual, as in many of the Psalms, takes place at the Temple, and is presumably accompanied by sacrifice. Those individuals who can’t afford a sacrifice often express anxiety about that and remind God that what he really wants is an honest heart (cf. Ps 40:7 in light of verse 18; Ps 69:30-32). So prayer is to a great extent a part of cult. Second, songs of praise are often sung by individuals upon the fulfillment of a neder (oath) and should be understood as a part of this process. See, for example, Hannah’s prayer (1 Sam 2:1-10; cf. Ps 50:14-15). Third, prayer outside of the Temple is generally practiced when the temple or altar is not accessible (cf. 1 Kgs 8:46—48 in contrast with most of the other passages in the chapter, where יתפללו אל המקום הזה means “they will pray at this place.” See v. 33.). Fourth, prayer is not standardized in any way, contrary to sacrificial law which is very standardized, including rules about when an individual must visit the Temple and bring a sacrifice (holidays, sins, births, etc.). In contrast, one need not pray at all. Prayer is the initiative of the individual and expresses the needs of the individual.
Of course, many of the commandments in the Torah, particularly in Leviticus, relate in great detail to the proper forms of cultic worship, and may be said to belong mostly to the previous category. Furthermore, many of the commandments are directed to Israel as a group rather than to the individual qua individual, such as the command to set up cities of refuge for the inadvertent killer (Deut 19; Num 35). Many other positive commandments, however, are directed toward the individual and are not related to Temple worship.
A clearer example of the coexistence of law and sacrifice is provided by Psalm 50. Here we find a condemnation of the “wicked one” (the priest?) who hypocritically relates God’s laws to the “pious ones” who are involved in a sacrificial feast at the Temple. See especially verses 5, 16ff. and 23. One may wonder, however, if the laws that the wicked one relates are not essentially those related to cultic worship and the endowments owed to the priests.
In all likelihood, the material in Numbers 15 constitutes a later expansion in relation to Leviticus 4. In the present context, however, the texts may be treated as reflecting the same basic trend.
This is not the traditional reading of the text, which instead argues midrashically that the law applies only to idolatry, claiming that violating “all these laws” means “violating a law that equals all laws.” See Rashi ad loc. (based on b. Shabbat 69a and b. Horayot 8a).
According to Jacob Milgrom in his JPS commentary on Numbers (ad loc., p. 125), the statement of Numbers 15:30-31, that he who acts ביד רמה, “defiantly,” is subject to karet and cannot offer a sacrifice of atonement, refers only to the one who publicly flaunts his defiant behavior. The person who knowingly and intentionally transgresses the law but does not flaunt it in public does have the option of offering the sacrifice. This interpretation is doubtful. First, if ביד רמה refers to defiant acts done in public why is this punished by karet alone? Why shouldn’t the community punish him? The person who curses the name of God in public, for example, is executed by the community (Lev 24:10-23). The warning of the karet punishment fits much better for a sin that is hidden from the people. This is why punishment must be meted out by God. Second, the fact that ביד רמה is placed in contrast with בשגגה implies that it refers to sins done knowingly and intentionally. This in itself constitutes defiance. If the sacrifice of atonement was indeed available to the person who knowingly sinned but was not seeking to make a public display of his sin why is there no clear statement to this effect? It seems to me that Milgrom found the simple position of the text too severe—it leaves the intentional sinner with no option for remorse and forgiveness—and therefore, sought to present a more palatable understanding of it.
Presumably, if the one who forgot to eat matzot intentionally refrained from bringing an atoning sacrifice, the karet punishment would pertain to him as well. Theoretically, the yearly rituals of יום הכיפורים (Lev. 16) should atone for intentional sinners who were not caught in the act and remained alive. After all, Leviticus 16 makes no distinction between intentional and unintentional sins. It thus would seem that the rituals of the day atone for the intentional sinner as well. However, neither Leviticus 4 nor Numbers 15 makes any reference to this day of atonement and they do not seem to fathom the possibility that God would leave the intentional sinner unpunished for very long. If these authors were aware of Yom Kippur as presented in Lev 16, one may suggest that their texts came to reinvigorate the fear of punishment that Yom Kippur largely mitigated with its guarantee of yearly atonement for all sins, even intentional ones.
This festival is believed to be a late development even in the Priestly tradition. Leviticus 16 seems to have been reworked; originally, it dealt only with the purging of the temple from impurities and the priestly removal of the sins of Israel as a whole. It was not a fixed to the yearly calendar and the individual Israelite played no active role in achieving atonement. See my, “Recasting a Temple Purification Ritual as the Yom Kippur Service,” TheTorah.com (2014). I suspect that the final form of Lev 16 did include atonement for intentional sins but Lev 4 and Num 15 came to warn that the intentional sinner cannot bring a sacrifice and probably won’t live long enough to reach Yom Kippur.
In general, the rewards and punishments in Exodus and Deuteronomy (and, admittedly, parts of P as well; cf. Lev. 26) are mostly national rather than individual (excepting criminal law). In Deuteronomy 29:17-20, Moses assures the people that God will not allow the individual sinner to benefit from the religious loyalty of the general population. God will single out this individual for punishment. This refers, however, specifically to the idolater and not to the one who violates any of the other commandments.
One non-Priestly text, Deuteronomy 27:26, at first glance seems to be about divine punishment for violating all mitzvot without distinction:
דברים כז:כו אָרוּר אֲשֶׁר לֹא יָקִים אֶת דִּבְרֵי הַתּוֹרָה הַזֹּאת לַעֲשׂוֹת אוֹתָם וְאָמַר כָּל הָעָם אָמֵן.
Deut 27:26 Cursed be he who will not uphold the terms of this torah (teaching) and observe them. — And all the people shall say, Amen.
However, “this torah” does not refer to the commandments as a whole, but to the immediately preceding specific list of offences committed in secret: idolatry, bribery, incest, demeaning parents, etc. (verses 15-25). Aside from this list, Deut. 29:17-20 (see previous note), and Deut. 18:19 (see next note) Deuteronomy places responsibility for punishment squarely on the people rather than on God. (The phrase ומת הנביא ההוא in Deut. 18:20—with reference to the prophet who speaks in the name of other gods or says something in the name of God that wasn’t told to him—refers to the death penalty as shown by the parallel of 17:12 and 24:7.) Failure of the community to carry out its responsibility to punish results in communal guilt (cf. Deut. 19:10).
In Deut. 18:19 we find the divine threat of אנכי אדרש מעמו (“I will hold him accountable”) with reference to the individual who refuses to obey the words of the prophet. This, however, belongs to the realm of institutional authority (cf. also Deut. 17:12) and can hardly be considered a “ritual” law. Nonetheless, I believe that we may discern an intriguing affinity between the assertion of Deut. 18:19 that God will personally punish disobedience by the individual Israelite of any single command given through God’s future prophet(s) and the Priestly assertions that God will “cut off” those individuals who disobey any command given through Moses. Indeed, in light of the tension between the authority of the living prophet and that of Mosaic law—on which see my, “Judaism without Sinai?” TheTorah.com (2015)—these two texts should probably be seen as “competitive.” It is worth noting in this context that the Priestly legislation makes no mention at all of the future institution of prophecy. Quite possibly, the Deuteronomic verse is part of a secondary expansion that starts in v. 16. Note that this legal material refers back to and freely expands upon (and even contradicts) the earlier narrative of Deut 5:20 ff.
See Exod 20:25-26; 22:28-30; 23:15, 18, 19. The prohibition against eating carrion (Exod 20:30) is the only one that is not related to the temple cult.
Deuteronomy makes no mention of either circumcision or the dwelling in booths. It does briefly mention the command to wear “tassels” on one’s garment (Deut 22:12). However, it is only in the Priestly material (Numbers 15:37-41) that we find an elucidation of this practice and a heightening of its importance in terms of individual mitzvah piety. Deuteronomy does include some ritual laws for the individual that are non-cultic. Other than “tassels”, all of them are negative. Note: the prohibition against blood consumption (Deut 12:16); illicit mourning rites (Deut 14:1); eating prohibitions (Deut 14:3-21); illicit divinatory practices (Deut 18:9-12); illicit dress ware (Deut 22:5, 10).
For more on the Priestly aim to infuse holiness into the lives of individual Israelites, a concern characterized the Priestly school known as H (Holiness), see Israel Knohl, “The Concept of Kedusha (Sanctity),” TheTorah.com (2014).
An important example of the Priestly heightening of ritual law for the individual is found in Leviticus 23. The chapter emphasizes a prohibition that applies specifically to the individual “in all your dwelling places,” independent of the Temple – the prohibition of work on a day that is a מקרא קדש, a holy convocation. This includes every weekly Sabbath, the first and seventh day of Chag HaMatzot, the fiftieth day from the omer offering, and the first, tenth, fifteenth and twenty third days of the seventh month. Thus, this legislation fills the year with many sacred days on which work is forbidden. Neither Mishpatim nor Deuteronomy mentions any prohibition of work on the festivals. Another example: Exodus 23:15 and 34:18 mention the command to eat matzot on this seven day festival. But there is no mention of a prohibition against eating chammetz or having it in one’s house. And the reference to this prohibition in Deuteronomy 16:3-4 has been shown to constitute a late addition to the text. See Alexander Rofé, Introduction to Deuteronomy: Part 1 and Further Chapters (Jerusalem: Akademon, 1988), 39 [Hebrew].