The Champagne Theater and the Rashi Memorial (Jewish Rabbi), in Troyes, Champagne, France. 123rf
On the Origins of Peshat Commentary
The shift in biblical exegesis from homiletic readings to literary, contextual commentaries has its roots in Charlemagne’s 9th century Carolingian Revolution. It comes to the fore only in the 11th century with Rashi’s quasi-peshat commentary, soon followed by the peshat approach of R. Joseph Kara and Rashbam.
Published: June 11, 2021
|
Last Updated: September 7, 2026
This essay is rooted in my current research: a book titled The Reinvention of Reading During the 12th Century Renaissance and an already published article, “From ‘Religious Truth-Seeking’ to Reading: The Twelfth Century Renaissance and the Emergence of Peshat and Ad Litteram as Methods of Accessing the Bible,” in The Oral and the Textual in Jewish Tradition and Jewish Education, ed. J. Cohen, M. Goldish and B. Holtz (Jerusalem: Magnes Press, 2019), 54–89. See also, Robert A. Harris, “Concepts of Scripture in the School of Rashi,” in Jewish Concepts of Scripture: A Comparative Introduction (Benjamin D. Sommer, ed.; New York and London: New York University Press, 2012), 102–122. For my earliest attempt to call attention to this factor, see my dissertation, The Literary Hermeneutic of Rabbi Eliezer of Beaugency, Ph.D. diss. (New York: Jewish Theological Seminary, 1997), especially 280–300.
The latter provides one of the earliest definitions of “the four-fold method of exegesis (quadruplex sensus) in his work, Conlationes Patrum (14:8), a pithy presentation of which appears in a poem attributed to Augustine of Dacia (13th century):
1. Plain Sense
littera gesta docet;
The letter, events, (does) teach;
2. Allegorical
quid credas allegoria;
That which you should believe, allegory;
3. Moral
moralis quid agas;
Morals (or tropology), what you should do;
4. Mystical
quid speras anagogia,
that which you should hope for, anagogy.
This poem is cited widely; I first read it in Beryl Smalley, The Study of the Bible in the Middle Ages (Oxford: Basil Blackwell, 1982), xiii.
A popular account of Christian biblical exegesis may be found in Henning Graf Reventlow, History of Biblical Interpretation, trans. James O. Duke (Atlanta: Society of Biblical Literature, 2009); for John Cassian, see Volume 2, 73: “Following Origen’s model, Cassian knows here two sorts of interpretation, ‘historical interpretation and spiritual understanding.’ He distinguishes three types of spiritual understanding: Tropology (moral meaning), allegory (figurative) meaning, and analogy (relating to ‘the more spiritual mysteries…”
Excerpt from Hugh’s “On Sacred Scripture and Its Authors,” chapter 3; see Franklin T. Harkins and Frans van Liere, Victorine Texts in Translation: Exegesis, Theology and Spirituality From the Abbey of St. Victor: Interpretations of Scripture: Theory (Turnhout: Brepols, 2012), 214–215.
Elsewhere I have dubbed this “religious truth-seeking.” See Harris, “Concepts of Scripture,” 104. Among relevant usages of the root ד-ר-שׁ in Biblical Hebrew we note occurrences of “to seek after sheep” (e.g., Deuteronomy 22:2) or “to seek a Divine oracle” (e.g., Genesis 25:22). Late Biblical Hebrew provides the even more pertinent usage “to expound” (i.e., “seek/demand out of”) the Torah book (Ezra 7:10). The root also yields the noun “midrash” (2 Chronicles 13:22; 24:27), though the precise meaning of this term there is uncertain; see Sara Japhet, I & II Chronicles: A Commentary (Louisville: Westminster/John Knox Press, 1993), 700. This latter meaning, of both noun and verb, denotes the standard exegesis of the Bible throughout rabbinic literature; this leads to an additional definition of midrash in rabbinic Hebrew is “that which is sought (and found) in the Bible.”
The question of why and how the root פ-שׁ-ט developed out of its various ancient uses into the catchword of a far-ranging medieval exegetical enterprise has never fully been fleshed out. It is found in the Bible, most often in the context of “stripping off clothing” (e.g., Genesis 37:23; Leviticus 6:4; 16:23; Isaiah 32:11; see also Leviticus 1:6, in the context of removing the hide before butchering a slaughtered animal). The root also occurs in military contexts (e.g., Judges 9:33; 20:37); unless one wishes to consider the possibility of “attacking” or “assaying” a text, however, it seems the first types of usages are more relevant. For the use of the root in ancient rabbinic literature (פשטיה דקרא and the like), see Sarah Kamin, רש"י: פשוטו של מקרא ומדרשו של מקרא [Rashi’s Exegetical Categorization in Respect to the Distinction Between Peshat and Derash] (Jerusalem: The Magnes Press, 1986), 25–57. I agree with Kamin that the root means something entirely different in medieval rabbinic Hebrew than it did in the Talmuds and ancient rabbinic midrashic sources, and in this essay, I primarily address the former.
Both of the premier 12th century peshat exegetes, Rashbam and Ibn Ezra, provided a core statement that described their overall methodology. Rashbam’s briefest statement on the subject is found in his introduction to the Covenant Collection at Exodus 21:1 and Ibn Ezra’s is found in part five of his introduction to the Torah. For a brief discussion of each of these passages, see Robert A. Harris, “Jewish Biblical Exegesis in the Middle Ages: From Its Beginnings Through the Twelfth Century,” in The New Cambridge History of the Bible (Richard Marsden and Ann Matter, ed. Cambridge University Press, 2012), 596–615 [608–613].
Kamin, Rashi, 14. The Hebrew original reads:
ביאור הכתוב על־פי לשונו, מבנהו התחבירי, הקשרו הענייני, סוגו הספרותי ומבנהו הספרותי, תוך יחסי גומלין בין מרכיבים אלה. לשון אחר: פירוש על דרך פשט הוא פירוש המתחשב בכל היסודות הלשוניים בהתרכבותם ומקנה לכל אחד מהם מובן על־פי השלימות.
The translation is my own.
See R. Joseph Kara’s diatribe (at 1 Samuel 1:20) against בעלי אגדה, i.e., masters of expounding Scripture only according to midrash and who (to whatever extent they were aware of it) eschew the developing rabbinic sense of peshat:
ויודע אני שיליזו על פתרון זה כל בעלי אגדה ותלמוד, שלא יניחו מה שפתרו רבותינו... וילכו אחרי פתרונם. אך המשכילים ישכילו לנתיבות הקרייה, להעמיד דבר על האמת.
I know well that all of those ‘masters of Aggadah and Talmud’ will laugh at (my) explanation, since they never abandon what our Sages have interpreted… and always run after their interpretations. But illuminati will become enlightened through the pathways of reading, and will stand matters upon the truth.
In general, the ancient Jewish world, including the rabbis, approached Scriptures with a completely different set of assumptions from ours. James L. Kugel insightfully calls these “the four assumptions” shared by all ancient interpreters of the Bible. See James L. Kugel, The Bible as it Was (Cambridge, Mass: Belknap Press of Harvard University Press, 1997), 17–23.
Northern French pashtanim held a multivalent approach to “meaning,” and therefore could sustain support for both derash and peshat at one and the same time, whereas Sephardic exegetes held a fundamentally univocal understand — and therefore expressed a great deal of tension particularly when dealing with the conflict between peshat and halacha. Various exegetes from the Judeo-Islamic world (from Saadia to Abraham Ibn Ezra and beyond) developed a concept of peshat that, although it shares certain basic assumptions about grammar and context with the northern French rabbinic exegetes, was remarkably different in certain elements of theory and practice. Describing the circumstances in which it originated (in interplay with both Islam and Karaism) and developed, requires its own treatment, and I do not address it in this essay.
On the origins of midrash as oral discourse, see, e.g., Jonah Fraenkel, דרכי המדרש והאגדה [The Ways of Aggadah and Midrash] (Jerusalem: Massada, 1991), 1.16–43.
On the corresponding transition from oral to literary culture in Latin literature, see Brian Stock, The Implications of Literacy: Written Language and Models of Interpretation in the Eleventh and Twelfth Centuries (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1983), 3–87.
Karaite commentary, in the Arabic milieu, began earlier. Daniel Frank, Search Scripture Well: Karaite Exegetes and the Origins of the Jewish Bible Commentary in the Islamic East (Leiden, Boston: Brill, 2004); Meira Polliack, Karaite Judaism: A Guide to Its History and Literary Sources (Leiden; Boston: Brill, 2003). But as the vast preponderance of this literature was composed in Arabic, and that language was not known in 11th–12th century Europe, its influence in the origins of northern French peshat may be discounted. Karaite influence only truly began to influence European exegetes with the arrival of Abraham Ibn Ezra, and even then, only through his citations of it (and polemic with it) in Hebrew translation.
See David A. Salomon, An Introduction to the Glossa Ordinaria as Medieval Hypertext (Cardiff: University of Wales Press, 2012). While the present paper is concerned with northern French cultural and intellectual developments, analogous observations may be made concerning developments in the Mediterranean and Byzantine worlds, as well with respect to Karaite commentaries and their Rabbinite respondents.
See Nikolaus M. Haring, “Commentary and Hermeneutics,” In Renaissance and Renewal in the Twelfth Century, ed., Robert L. Benson, Giles Constable, and Carol D. Lanham (Toronto: University of Toronto Press, in association with the Medieval Academy of America, 1991), 173–200.
For a fine collection of essays on the subject, see Celia Martin Chazelle and Burton Van Name Edwards, The Study of the Bible in the Carolingian Era (Turnhout, Belgium: Brepols, 2003).
We see evidence of this interest as early as 786, in Charlemagne’s “Letter to the Lectors,” issued some years before his more famous Admonitio Generalis:
…Since it is our concern that the condition of our churches should always advance towards better things, we strive with vigilant zeal to repair the manufactory of learning, almost destroyed by the sloth of our forefathers, and summon whom we can, even by our own example, to master the studies of the liberal arts.
Translation from P. D.King, Charlemagne: Translated Sources (Lambrigg, Kendal, Cumbria: P.D. King, 1987), 208.
Thus, the Admonitio Generalis (paragraph 72) states:
And let schools for teaching boys the psalms, musical notation, singing, computation and grammar be created in every monastery and episcopal residence. And correct catholic books properly, for often, while people want to pray to God in the proper fashion, they yet pray improperly because of uncorrected books. And do not allow your boys to corrupt them, either in reading or in copying….
King, Charlemagne, 217.
Irvine, The Making of Textual Culture, 305. On the increased production of manuscripts, Mary J. Carruthers observes, “There is no questioning the fact that written material came increasingly into use from the eleventh century on; the reason that more manuscripts survive from the later Middle Ages is because more were made.” Carruthers, Mary J. The Book of Memory: A Study of Memory in Medieval Culture. Cambridge, UK; New York: Cambridge University Press, 2008, 195. Irvine further notes:
…The Carolingian codification of grammatica established the foundations for subsequent textual culture: most of the corpus of classical grammatical treatises and classical literary works is preserved in manuscripts copied in the Carolingian era. Grammatica supplied special technologies of authority — literacy, normative latinity, knowledge of a literary canon, the scribal arts, book production — which became part of a larger ideology. Without grammatica laws and charters could not be written, the Scriptures could not be read, copied, or interpreted…
Irvine, The Making of Textual Culture, 305–306; see also 521, n. 112.
To get a feel for the approach, here are some excerpts (translated from the Latin):
…we, along with our faithful advisors, have deemed it useful that the bishoprics and monasteries… should… devote their efforts to the study of literature and to the teaching of it, each according to his ability, to those on whom God has bestowed the capacity to learn; that, just as the observance of a rule gives soundness to their conduct, so also an attention to teaching and learning may give order and adornment to their words, and that those who seek to please God by living aright may not fail to please him also by rightness in their speaking… For although it is better to do what is right than to know it, yet knowledge comes before action… They should give special service to truth. Letters have often been sent to us… we found that in most of these writings their sentiments were sound but their speech uncouth… because of their neglect of learning their unskilled tongues could not express it without fault. And so it came about that we began to fear that their lack of knowledge of writing might be matched by a more serious lack of wisdom in the understanding of holy scripture… Wherefore we urge you, not merely to avoid the neglect of the study of literature, but with a devotion that is humble and pleasing to God to strive to learn it, so that you may be able more easily and more rightly to penetrate the mysteries of the holy scriptures. For since there are figures of speech, metaphors and the like to be found on the sacred pages, there can be no doubt. that each man who reads them will understand their spiritual meaning more quickly if he is first of all given full instruction in the study of literature.
Cited from H. R. Loyn and John Percival, The Reign of Charlemagne: Documents on Carolingian Government and Administration (New York: St. Martin’s Press, 1975), 63–64. For a different translation, see King, Charlemagne, 232–233.
As Richard Matthew Pollard has written,
Whether or not we can really call this period a ‘renaissance’ is still much debated by scholars, but there can be no question that these centuries saw a great upswing in cultural and intellectual productivity. This can be illustrated most simply in terms of book production, that is, by the number of manuscript books that were copied in the Carolingian period. The total number of surviving Latin manuscript books that were produced in Europe before the year 800 is less than two thousand, whereas for the period c. 800-900 we have more than four times as many, perhaps nine thousand.
Richard Matthew Pollard, “Carolingian Literature at Reichenau and St. Gall.”
As Beryl Smalley already noted in an early publication, Andrew of St. Victor habitually referred to “Hebraeus meus” to describe his Jewish interlocutor. See Beryl Smalley, “Andrew of St. Victor, Abbot of Wigmore: A Twelfth Century Hebraist.” Recherches de théologie ancienne et médiévale 10 (1938), 358–73 (362–363).
Indeed, if one looks for a “smoking gun” of the type in which some rabbi would write “on such and such a day, I sat down with my good friend at the Cathedral School of St. Victor and, in studying Scripture together, I learned…” one surely looks in vain. While the occasional (and exceptional) Christian scholars could write such a thing, no Jewish exegete, given the degree of animus and constructions of power exercised by a dominant Christian majority over northern Europe’s tiny Jewish community, could possibly have been expected to express positive acknowledgment of Christian influence on Jewish exegesis. For discussions of Jewish-Christian relations in the 12th Century, see, e.g., Anna Sapir, Abulafia, Christians and Jews in the Twelfth-Century Renaissance (London and New York: Routledge, 1995); Robert Chazan, Reassessing Jewish Life in Medieval Europe (New York: Cambridge University Press, 2010); and Israel Jacob. Yuval, Two Nations in Your Womb : Perceptions of Jews and Christians in Late Antiquity and the Middle Ages (Berkeley: University of California Press, 2006).
For the 11th Century, see Mordechai Z. Cohen, “A New Perspective of Rashi of Troyes in Light of Bruno the Carthusian: Exploring Jewish and Christian Bible Interpretation in Eleventh Century Northern France,” Viator 48:1 (2017), 39–86. For the 12th Century the evidence is much greater. See, e.g., John Van Engen, “Ralph of Flaix: The Book of Leviticus Interpreted as Christian Community,” in Jews and Christians in Twelfth-Century Europe (Michael A Signer and John Van Engen ed. Notre Dame, Indiana: University of Notre Dame Press, 2001), 150–70 (indeed most any article in this fine volume might be consulted); and my own article, written in respectful response, Robert A. Harris, “The Book of Leviticus Interpreted as Jewish Community,” Studies in Christian-Jewish Relations 6 (2011): 1–15.
For the moment, I do not address the question of whether the pitronot of R. Menahem bar Helbo represent true commentaries, or whether there were other (anonymous or otherwise) precedents to Rashi’s oeuvre. Analogously, Rashi’s commentary on the Babylonian Talmud (quite probably begun earlier) represents the first primary line-by-line guide for reading that work.
For an extended study of Rashi’s commentary in its essence as a midrashic anthology, see Yedida C. Eisenstat, “Rashi’s Midrashic Anthology: The Torah Commentary Re-Examined,” diss., Jewish Theological Seminary, 2014.
For a discussion of the development of the Gloss, see Lesley Smith, The Glossa Ordinaria : The Making of a Medieval Bible Commentary (Leiden: Brill, 2009). See also Margaret T. Gibson, “The Place of the Glossa Ordinaria in Medieval Exegesis,” in Ad Litteram: Authoritative Texts and Their Medieval Readers (ed. Mark D. Jordan and Kent Emery. Notre Dame, Ind.: University of Notre Dame Press, 1992), 5–27.
Devorah Schoenfeld authored a comparative study of Rashi and the Glossa, in which she clearly concludes that they share a similar approach to the exegesis of Scripture. See Devorah Schoenfeld, Isaac on Jewish and Christian Altars: Polemic and Exegesis in Rashi and the Glossa Ordinaria (New York: Fordham University Press, 2013), 9. Schoenfeld does not particularly develop the hermeneutic insight, and instead concentrates on presenting the interpretations of both on the narrative of Genesis 22, especially with the intention of highlighting the polemical overtones of the two exegetical texts. Editor’s note: For an accessible look at the Glossa Ordinaria interpreting a text, see Wendy Love Anderson, “Parents Eating their Children – The Torah's Curse and Its Undertones in Medieval Interpretation,” TheTorah (2018); Devorah Schoenfeld, “Akedah: How Jews and Christians Explained Abraham’s Faith,” TheTorah (2017).
See Robert A. Harris, “Twelfth-Century Biblical Exegetes and the Invention of Literature,” in The Multiple Meaning of Scripture: The Role of Exegesis in Early-Christian and Medieval Culture (Ienje van ‘t Spijker, ed. Leiden; Boston: Brill, 2009), 311–329, in which I present and explain northern French rabbinic awareness of a wide variety of literary devices, and detail the terminology they developed to call attention to them in biblical literature. For extended examples with one rabbinic exegete, see Robert A. Harris, Rabbi Eliezer of Beaugency: Commentaries on Amos and Jonah (With Selections from Isaiah and Ezekiel) (Kalamazoo: TEAMS: Medieval Institute Publications and Western Michigan University, 2018). For extended examples with Christian exegetes, see Frans van Liere and Franklin T. Harkins, Interpretation of Scripture: Practice: A Selection of Works of Hugh, Andrew, Richard of St Victor, Peter Comestor, Robert of Melun, Maurice of Sully and Leonius of Paris (Turnhout, Belgium: Brepols Publishers, 2015).
Robert A. Harris, “The Reception of Ezekiel Among Twelfth-Century Northern French Rabbinic Exegetes,” in After Ezekiel: Essays on the Reception of a Difficult Prophet (Andrew Mein and Paul M. Joyce, ed. New York, London: T&T Clark International, 2011), 71–88 (87–88).
Hermeneutics and exegesis have both been thoroughly bound up in biblical studies from the Middle Ages into modernity. For a basic overview, see Anthony C. Thiselton, Hermeneutics: An Introduction (Grand Rapids, MI: W.B. Eerdmans Pub. Co., 2009). Medieval and pre-modern Bible study fed directly into theoretical discussions of literature in the emergent modern university. The contemporary idea of “literature” as a distinct academic pursuit is primarily the result of changes taking place in the 19th century university. See James Turner, Philology: The Forgotten Origins of the Modern Humanities (Princeton and Oxford: Princeton University Press, 2014), 254–273.
[32] See Brian Stock, Listening for the Text: On the Uses of the Past (Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 1996), 102–103.