Tabernacle, Sacrifices, and Judaism: Maimonides vs. Nahmanides

Who needs the Tabernacle? What is the purpose of sacrifices? Maimonides and Nahmanides have radically different answers to these questions, reflecting a core debate about the nature of Judaism and the purpose of its rituals.

SBL Style

Click to copy

"Tabernacle, Sacrifices, and Judaism: Maimonides vs. Nahmanides." TheTorah.com, March 17, 2020. https://www.thetorah.com/article/tabernacle-sacrifices-and-judaism-maimonides-vs-nahmanides.

APA Style

Click to copy

"Tabernacle, Sacrifices, and Judaism: Maimonides vs. Nahmanides" (2020, March 17). TheTorah.com. https://www.thetorah.com/article/tabernacle-sacrifices-and-judaism-maimonides-vs-nahmanides

Tabernacle, Sacrifices, and Judaism: Maimonides vs. Nahmanides

Temple implements, Duke of Sussex's Catalan Bible, 14th c., ff. 3v-4. British Library

Categories:

Pekudei

Published: March 17, 2020

|

Last Updated: September 7, 2026

  1. The details of the mishkan are enumerated in Exodus 25–40, with the exception of the narrative about the golden calf and its aftermath in chapters 32–34.

  2. Some of the ideas in this piece are drawn from a forthcoming article that I wrote with my student Matanel Bareli for the Daniel J. Lasker festschrift (Cultural Encounters in Late Antiquity and the Middle Ages): “Maimonides on the Status of Judaism.”

  3. Guide 3.32; For discussion, see Roy Pinchot, "The Deeper Conflict between Maimonides and Ramban over the Sacrifices," Tradition 33 (1999): 24-33; David Gillis, “On the Problem of Sacrifices: Maimonides’ Ladder of Enlightenment,” TheTorah (2018); Kenneth Seeskin, “The Tabernacle: A Concession to Human Religious Needs,” TheTorah (2020). Commentators on the Guide, in the Middle Ages and since, have indeed balked at this assertion of Maimonides, but so far as I can judge, none has explored the broader implications of Maimonides’ claim that much of the Torah as we have it reflects God’s secondary intention, not God’s original purpose, as it were, for what Judaism was meant to be. How so? A Judaism without sacrifices has no need for a mishkan or temple in which to bring them; has no need for a priestly class or caste to serve in that mishkan or temple; has no need for tithes to support that priestly class or caste; has no need for laws of ritual purity and impurity (designed only to create awe of the mishkan or temple as Maimonides asserts in Guide 3.45; has no need for pilgrim festivals. It turns out that several score of the Torah’s traditionally numbered 613 commandments would not have been given had the Israelites leaving Egypt been able to fulfill the Torah as God originally intended. On this view, Judaism as we have it appears to be a debased, imperfect expression of God’s own vision, of His Torah. These matters are expanded upon, and the conclusion somewhat softened in Bareli and Kellner (forthcoming).

  4. I cite from the Guide in the forthcoming (and elegant) translation of Lenn Evan Goodman and Philip Lieberman. I thank them for sharing their translation before its publication. For those wishing to see the passage in context, it can be found in Shlomo Pines, Guide of the Perplexed (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1963), 2.526

  5. The Sabians were a pre-Islamic sect that played an important role in Maimonides' history of religion. On his account, Abraham's mission was directed against the Sabians, and many mosaic laws were promulgated to uproot Sabian ideas and practices. See Sara Stroumsa, “צאבֵּאִים של חראן וצאבֵּאִים אצל הרמב"ם: על התפתחות הדת לפי הרמב"ם” [The Sabians of Haran and the Sabians According to Maimonides: On the Development of Religion According to Maimonides], Sefunot 7 (1999): 277–295.

  6. =Pines, Guide, 2.581

  7. Charles B. Chavel (trans.), Ramban: Commentary on the Torah – Leviticus (New York: Shilo, 1973), p. 19.

  8. Or, was the ‘Fall’ a reflection, rather than a cause, of a cosmic break? See Bezalel Safran, "Rabbi Azriel and Nahmanides: Two Views on the Fall of Man," Isadore Twersky (ed.), Rabbi Moses Nahmanides (Ramban) : Explorations in His Religious and Literary Virtuosity (Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 1983): 75-106.

  9. The term original sin is ordinarily associated with (Augustinian) Christianity, but it is not unknown in medieval Judaism, especially that strain of Judaism influenced by Nahmanides. For texts see Nahmanides on Lev. 26:6 and (by implication) on Lev. 30:6. See also and his Disputation at Barcelona in Ramban: Writings and Discourses, Translated and Annotated by Charles B. Chavel (New York: Shiloh, 1978), vol. 2, p. 670. A source not translated by Rabbi Chavel, but included in his two-volume edition of Kitvei Ramban (Jerusalem: Mossad ha-Rav Kook, 1982): Torat ha-Adam, Introduction, vol. 2, p. 12. Bahya ben Asher (1255-1340) was strongly influenced by Nahmanides. See his commentary on Lev. 12:7 and his Kad ha-Kemah, on hemdah (beginning). On original sin in Nahmanides’ thought, see further: Moshe Halbertal, “מוות, חטא, חוק וגאולה במשנת הרמב"ן” [Nahmanides' Conception of Death, Sin, Law, and Redemption] Tarbiz 71.1–2 (2002): 133–162. Shlomo Pines detected Christian influence on Nahmanides in connection with the doctrine of original sin: "Truth and Falsehood Versus Good and Evil: A Study in Jewish and General Philosophy in Connection with Guide of the Perplexed I,2," in Studies in Maimonides, ed. Isadore Twersky, (Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1991), pp. 95-157 [155-157] (and his earlier studies cited there). In medieval Jewish philosophy generally, see Daniel J. Lasker, “החטא הקדמון וכפרתו לפי חסדאי קרשקש” [Original Sin and Its Atonement According to Hasdai Crescas], Da'at 20 (1988): 127–135, and Deborah Schechterman, “סוגית החטא הקדמון והפרשנות לדברי הרמב"ם בהגות היהודית במאות השלש-עשרה והארבע-עשרה” [The Doctrine of Original Sin and Commentaries on Maimonides in Jewish Philosophy of the Thirteenth and Fourteenth Centuries], Da'at 20 (1988): 65–90.

  10. See Dov Schwartz’ exposition of Nahmanides on Lev. 1:9: "From Theurgy to Magic: The Evolution of the Magical-Talismanic Justification of Sacrifice in the Circle of Nahmanides and his Interpreters," Aleph 1 (2001): 165–213 [p. 169]. Moshe Idel defines Zoharic sefirot as “manifestations that are either part of the divine structure, or directly related to the divine essence, serving as its vessels or instruments.” See Idel, Kabbalah: New Perspectives (New Haven: Yale University Press, 1988), p. 112.

  11. Compare Rashi on Gen. 1:1; see Menachem Kellner, “Rashi and Maimonides on Torah and the Cosmos,” Between Rashi and Maimonides: Themes in Medieval Jewish Thought, Literature and Exegesis, ed. Ephraim Kanarfogel and Moshe Sokolow (New York: Yeshiva University Press, 2010), 23-58.

  12. Guide, part one, introduction:

    God, you see, chose to improve us and enhance our lives with His practical norms. But these are well anchored only once we’ve embraced certain intellectual convictions – chiefly, an awareness of Him, so far as we are able. That depends on metaphysics, theological knowledge, which is won only after study of natural science. For physics borders on metaphysics and is its prerequisite, as its students clearly comprehend. That is why God opens His book with the Account of Creation, which belongs to physics, as I’ve explained. Given the immensity and sublimity of the subject and our inadequacy in grasping these profundities properly, they were broached to us obliquely and poetically – in words quite baffling. As the Sages say: “To convey to mortal men the power of the Creative Act is impossible, so Scripture baldly tells you, In the beginning God created....” [Midrash Sh’nei Ketuvim, Batei Midrashot 4] – alerting you to the fact that such things are ineffable. You know Solomon’s words: Far off is that which was, and deep, deep – who can plumb it! (Ecclesiastes 7:24). All is expressed in words of more than one meaning. So the masses absorb what their capacity and limited understanding permit, but the enlightened and aware take it otherwise.

    =Pines, Guide, 1.9.

  13. Maimonides teases it out of midrashic comments (thus attributing his view to the Sages):

    The points I’m citing from the Sages’ discussions, you should realize, are consummately perfect and perspicuous, crystal clear to those addressed. So I’ll not expatiate or elaborate in glossing them, so as not to reveal secrets (cf. Proverbs 11:13). If I lightly sketch the outlines, a gentle hint will be enough for someone like you see what they were saying.

    =Pines, Guide, 2.355.

  14. On Rabbi Kafih’s approach to Maimonides, see James Diamond and Menachem Kellner, Reinventing Maimonides in Contemporary Jewish Thought (London: Littman Library of Jewish Civilization, 2019), ch. 7.

  15. Kafih on Maimonides, “Laws of the Sabbath,” v. 3. See his edition of and commentary on the Mishneh Torah. For an academic account of what Maimonides is doing in Guide 2.30, see, for example, Sara Klein-Braslavi, Perush ha-Ramabam le-Sippurim al Adam be-Parashat Bereshit (Jerusalem: Reuven Mass, 1987).

  16. Much of my book, Maimonides’ Confrontation with Mysticism (London: The Littman Library of Jewish Civilization, 2006) is devoted to arguing that Maimonides was aware of what I call “proto-kabbalistic” elements in Judaism and rejected them.

  17. This is wonderfully captured in the title of Kenneth Seeskin’s book, Searching for a Distant God: The Legacy of Maimonides (New York: Oxford University Press, 2000).

  18. One wonders what role non-Jews play in the divine economy according to thinkers like Nahmanides. JBS Haldane is reputed to have said that God seems to be inordinately fond of beetles, having created so many of them; is God also inordinately fond of non-Jews?

  19. Chavel trans., p. 21. Nahmanides likes to introduce hints to Kabbalah in his commentary with the expression “by way of truth” (על דרך האמת). See Oded Yisraeli, “The Kabbalistic Remez and Its Status in Naḥmanides’ Commentary on the Torah,” Journal of Jewish Thought & Philosophy 24 (2016): 1–30.

  20. Elliott Wolfson and Dov Schwartz do go into detail. See Wolfson, “By Way of Truth: Aspects of Nahmanides’ Kabbalistic Hermeneutic,” AJS Review 14 (1989): 103-178 (esp. p. 131) and Schwartz, “From Theurgy to Magic.” David Novak summarizes Nahmanides’ complex and esoteric discussion as follows: “But Nahmanides finds the deepest meaning of the sacrifices in a divine reality. In essence, he holds that they fulfill divine needs. This is the view of Kabbalah, and Nahmanides’ approach here deeply influenced later Kabbalists.” See Novak, The Theology of Nahmanides Systematically Presented (Atlanta: Scholars Press, 1992), 105.

  21. It would appear that this is also the view of the poet who wrote the Yom Kippur poem, Atta Konanta. See discussion in Dalia Marx, “Yom Kippur's Seder Avodah Begins with God's Creation of the World,” TheTorah (2019).

  22. I.e., a human need – which was clearly Maimonides’ position.

  23. Chavel trans., Exodus, pp. 506-507 (emended). See further Nathan Laufer, Rendevous with God: Revealing the Meaning of the Jewish Holidays and Their Mysterious Rituals (Jerusalem: Maggid, 2016), p. 206. Rabbi Laufer’s discussion shows how popular and unexceptional the idea has become. Nahmanides is preceded by Judah Halevi. See Kuzari, i.98, ii.25-26, and iii.23.

  24. This is not how Maimonides understands the verse, naturally. For discussions of Maimonides on the shekhinah, see Menachem Kellner, Maimonides’ Confrontation with Mysticism (London: The Littman Library of Jewish Civilization, 2006), ch. 6, pp. 179-215 and James A. Diamond, Converts, Heretics, and Lepers: Maimonides and the Outsider (Notre Dame: University of Notre Dame Press, 2007), pp. 141-158.

  25. See further the commentaries of Hizkuni (Hezekiah ben Mano’ah, 1250-1310) and Bahya ben Asher. Both follow Nahmanides, seeing the Exodus as taking place so that God could dwell among the Israelites. On this, as well as on many other issues, Nahmanides seems to go out of his way to annoy Maimonides. For important examples in our context, see Dov Schwartz, “From Theurgy…”. For an explicit study of many of these Nahmanidean attempts to annoy Maimonides, see James A. Diamond, Maimonides and the Shaping of the Jewish Canon (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2014), ch. 3. In the first paragraph of that chapter, Diamond writes (p. 69): “Their positions diverged so drastically on notions such as providence, ritual, biblical history, and even the very nature of God–and thus what qualifies as authentic monotheism–that it would be no exaggeration to infer that they adhered to two different faiths.”

  26. See: https://etzion.org.il/en/i-might-dwell-their-midst I found this source thanks to Rabbi Laufer.

  27. See Morris Faierstein, "'God's Need for the Commandments' in Medieval Kabbalah," Conservative Judaism 36 (1982): 45-59. Faierstein finds the first first kabbalistic usage of the expression in the Nahmanides text just cited. Further on the notion of God’s need for Israel, see b. Moed Katan 9a. On theurgy in Kabbalah generally, which Moshe Idel defines as “operations intended to influence the Divinity, mostly in its own inner state or dynamics, but sometimes also in its relationship to man," see Idel, Kabbalah: New Perspectives (New Haven: Yale University Press, 1988), pp. 173-199.

  28. Abraham Joshua Heschel, Heavenly Torah as Refracted through the Generations, trans. and ed. by Gordon Tucker (New York: Bloomsbury, 2007), 71–92; trans. from תורה מן השמים באספקלריה של הדורות, 2 vols. (London: Soncino, 1962).

  29. An expression of the fact that Nahmanides’ views on our subject are unexceptional today may be found in an interesting lecture by R. Baruch Gigi (one of the heads of Yeshivat Har Ezion), posted online under the title “Let Them Make Me a Sanctuary, That I May Dwell in Their Midst”. https://etzion.org.il/en/%E2%80%9Clet-them-make-me-sanctuary-i-may-dwell-their-midst%E2%80%9D

  30. The picture isn’t painted clearly in any one source but when we combine two Maimonidean texts, “Laws of Idolatry” ch. 1 with Guide of the Perplexed 3.32, we arrive at the following picture of the history of the Jewish people and of the religion of Israel.

  31. This supplemented the one commandment already given to the Israelites in Egypt – to count the month we now call Nisan as the first of the months of the year (Exod 12:2).

  32. Nahmanides, (Lev. 1:9) followed by many others (more politely), asked, of course, about the sacrifices offered by Cain and Abel (Gen. 4:3-6), Noah (Gen. 8:20-21), and Abraham (Gen. 22:23). The Talmud (b Shabbat 28b and parallels) also maintains that Adam offered a sacrifice. Maimonides would reply that none of these was commanded.

  33. The two aims of the Torah (Guide 3.27) are the inculcation of ethical and intellectual perfection, with the former preceding and subserving the latter.

  34. Isaac Abravanel interprets Maimonides to be teaching that God's original intention had been to command only the Sabbath and civil laws, but after the sin of the golden calf God realized, as it were, that the Jews were too primitive to manage without a full panoply of sacrifices and was “necessitated” (huzrakh) to command them. See Abravanel's commentary to Jeremiah 7 (p. 328 in the Shotland edition). Seforno (d. 1550), in his introduction to Exodus and in his commentary on Ex. 24:18 follows the chronology of Maimonides and Abravanel: the mishkan follows the sin of the golden calf. In his comment on Exod 31:18 he even adopts Abravanel’s language – huzrakh.

  35. For rabbinic sources supporting the claim that the mishkan was commanded only after and because of the sin of the golden calf, see Exodus Rabbah 33:3 and Tanhuma Terumah 8 (in the Warsaw edition; the Buber edition has a very different text) as presented and interpreted by Nehama Leibowitz, Studies in Shemot (Jerusalem: World Zionist Organization, 1976), pp. 459-460. See also Tanhuma, Pikkudei 2 and Sifri Dt. 1. Maimonides had plenty of rabbinic support for his position.

  36. =Pines, p. 531.

  37. Heb.: bayit le-Hashem. This could be (incorrectly) translated as “a house for the Lord [to dwell in]” as opposed to “a house for the sake of the Lord,” i.e., in which to worship God.

  38. Mendell Lewittes, trans. The Book of Temple Service (New Haven: Yale University Press, 1957), p. 5. It is probably no coincidence that Maimonides fails to cite the continuation of the verse: “that I may dwell among them.”

  39. In the translation of Charles Chavel (London: Soncino, 1967), pp. 27-28.

  40. The Nahmanidean view of the mishkan has become so compelling, that in his notes to his translation of Maimonides’ 20th commandment, Rabbi Chavel writes: “The Commandment which decreed that Israel should build a Sanctuary for the Divine Presence was regarded as a special manifestation of God’s love for His people.” It appears that R. Chavel took the Nahmanidean view as the Jewish perspective; so much so that he was not aware that he was reading Maimonides as if he were Nahmanides! It was Nahmanides, not Maimonides, who taught that the point of the mishkan, and later of the temple, was to build a sanctuary for the divine presence.

  41. For a detailed exposition of Maimonides’ understanding of halakhah as institutional but not ontological, see Kellner, Maimonides’ Confrontation, ch. 2.