Mozes by Theo van Doesburg (adapted), 1906. Kröller-Müller Museum
The Priestly Moses
Is Moses raised by an Egyptian princess? Does he kill an Egyptian man? Does he run away to Midian and marry the daughter of a Midianite priest? Not according to P, which cleanses Moses of these problematic elements.
Published: January 15, 2015
|
Last Updated: September 7, 2026
In this essay, I will be following the basic contours of the analysis of Moshe Greenberg, one of the most important Jewish Bible scholars of the past generation. See Moshe Greenberg, Understanding Exodus: Second Edition. A Holistic Commentary on Exodus 1–11 (Cascade Books, 2013 [1st ed., 1969]).
The latter reflects the text as presented in the Septuagint: καὶ ἐγνώσθη αὐτοῖς.
Just to complete the picture, and without going into the reasoning behind it, scholars basically agree that the original flow of the narrative that is picked up in 6:2–7:13 was as follows: Exodus 1:(1–)7, 13–14; 2:23b–25. Everything else is part of the narrative thread that continues in Exodus 3:1–6:1.
According to the theory, this source was written by the priests of Jerusalem, and they were out to promote a priestly agenda. P is found in parts of Genesis and Exodus, all of Leviticus, parts of Numbers, and the very end of Deuteronomy.
Thus, Aaron the priest is a central character in P, and a major concern of P is the priestly line’s authority and prerogatives. P is interested in rejecting any competing claims to the priesthood, so it tells the story of Korah the Levite who sought the priesthood and ended up six feet under (see the story in Num 16).
This may also explain why Moses is 80 in this source: P has Moses die at 120 (see end of Deuteronomy), and it also has the account of the 40 years of wandering in the wilderness. Thus, Moses had to be 80 at the time of the exodus event.
“…P was composed later than JE… by someone who was familiar with J and E in their combined form… as an alternative to that JE version of Israel’s story. It was a retelling of the story in terms that were more suitable to the Aaronid priesthood.” Richard Elliott Friedman,The Bible with Sources Revealed (Harper Collins, 2003), 27. For the alternative view, that P did not know the Non-P sources, see: Joel Baden, The Composition of the Pentateuch (Yale University Press, 2012). The above scholars are meant as representative examples of each school of thought among the documentarians; this is not the place for an exhaustive bibliography on the subject.
Though Joseph similarly marries the daughter of an Egyptian Priest (Gen 41:45), intermarriage with non-Israelites is often (though not always!) frowned upon in the Bible.
This would probably be particularly odious to an Israelite priestly caste.
This mitzvah is central for P, for it is specifically P that relates in Genesis 17 how God (as El Shaddai; compare Gen 17:1 with Exod 6:3) made a covenant of circumcision with Abraham’s seed to be their deity and to give them the land. This is thus probably another story that P could happily do without.
Is he missing his suffering brethren or his good life as the son of the princess? In spite of his sense that he is living in a foreign land, he doesn’t seem to feel any urgent need to go back “home” and leave his new Midianite life to help his suffering brethren—until God adamantly insists!
Note that in Exodus 2, the father and mother of Moses are unnamed Levites. There is also an unnamed older sister here, but no hint of an older brother. Moses seems from verse 1 to be the first son! For more on this, see Isaac S. D. Sassoon, “Moses, Aaron, and Miriam: Were They Siblings?,” TheTorah (2015); and Mark Leuchter and Zev Farber, “Pre-Biblical Aaron, Miriam, and Moses,” TheTorah (2020).