The Priestly Repudiation of Yibbum

Deuteronomy commands a man to marry the childless widow of his brother (yibbum). And yet, a close look at the Priestly text of the Torah shows that it did not have the option of yibbum.

SBL Style

Click to copy

"The Priestly Repudiation of Yibbum." TheTorah.com, May 11, 2016. https://www.thetorah.com/article/the-priestly-repudiation-of-yibbum.

APA Style

Click to copy

"The Priestly Repudiation of Yibbum" (2016, May 11). TheTorah.com. https://www.thetorah.com/article/the-priestly-repudiation-of-yibbum

The Priestly Repudiation of Yibbum

The ritual of halitza (Deut 25:7-10). Phillip Medhurst Collection of Bible illustrations (colorized). Wikimedia

Published: May 11, 2016

|

Last Updated: October 28, 2026

  1. This is clear both from the extraordinary public humiliation decreed on the recusant levir, which speaks for itself and because “obliterating a name” is a serious affair in Deuteronomy, reserved for villains (Deut 29:19). Yibbum has the effect of sparing a dead brother such a fate.

  2. See similarly Mekhilta Ba-Chodesh 7. For an analysis of a different problematic pair (the two versions of the Shabbat commandment in the Decalogue), see Martin Lockshin’s TABS essay, “The Existence of Two Versions of the Decalogue.”

  3. The fact that the punishment for relations with an uncle’s widow is similar to that of the brother’s widow may imply that this prohibition is also a polemic against a known practice.

  4. There is a firm rabbinic tradition to this effect, see b. Yeb. 24a et al.

  5. The Sages seem aware of this problem. See, for instance, Tosefta Yebamot 6:10 (cf. Yeb. 39b):

    הבא על יבמתו לשם נוי לשם נכסים רואין אותו כאילו פגע בערוה וקרוב הולד להיות ממזר
    A man who goes in unto his childless sister-in-law for the sake of beauty or for the sake of property is to be considered as if he is committing incest and any child born from the union is close to being illegitimate .

    and Bechorot 1:7:

     מצות הייבום קודמת למצות חליצה, בראשונה שהיו מתכוונין לשם מצוה ועכשיו שאין מתכוונין לשם מצוה אמרו מצות חליצה קודמת למצות יבום.
    The mitzvah of yibbum takes precedence over the mitzvah ofhalitza – [this was true] in previous generations, since their intention was only for mitzvah. Nowadays, since people are not only focused on the mitzvah, they (=the sages) said: The mitzvah of halitza takes precedence over the mitzvah of yibbum.
  6. For more on the Priestly ban on polygyny, see my TABS essay, “The Biblical Prohibition of Polygyny?”