Relief from the Central Palace at Nimrud showing Israelites exiled to Assyria, British Museum. Wikimedia
The Ten Lost Tribes: A Myth to Delegitimize the Samarians
The book of Kings recounts how all Ten Tribes were exiled by the Assyrians and replaced by foreigners, and Ezra–Nehemiah rejects them as non-Israelites. Yet other biblical and Second Temple texts, along with the archaeological record, show that northern Israelites continued to live in Samaria well into the Second Temple period. Far from vanishing, the northern tribes maintained a temple and priesthood that cooperated with their southern neighbors and played a role in shaping the Pentateuch.
Published: August 13, 2025
|
Last Updated: September 7, 2026
Pamela Barmash, “At the Nexus of History and Memory: The Ten Lost Tribes.” American Jewish Studies Review 29.2 (2005) 207-236. The Bible refers to “ten tribes” in only one episode, when the prophet Ahijah informs Jeroboam that God will tear “ten tribes” away from Solomon’s kingdom and give them to Jeroboam to rule (1 Kings 11:31, 35).
Zvi Ben-Dor Benite, The Ten Lost Tribes: A World History (Oxford: 2017) provides a comprehensive historical survey. He points out how claims very often reflected contemporary political and religious concerns.
Assyrian King Sargon II boasted "I besieged and conquered the city Samaria. I took as booty 27,290 people who lived there…” See Stephanie S. Dalley, “Foreign Chariotry and Cavalry in the Armies of Tiglath-Pileser III and Sargon II,” Iraq 47 (1985) 31-48.
Sennacherib on the Rassam Cylinder in the British Museum mentions deporting thousands of Judeans to Assyria; see also Ran Zadok, “Israelites and Judaeans in the Neo-Assyrian Documentation (732–602): An Overview of the Sources and a Socio-Historical Assessment,” Bulletin of the American Schools of Oriental Research, 374 (2015) 159–189.
The name “Samaritan” is associated with Christian and Jewish polemics. Greek-speaking Jews and Christians for the most part used “Samaritan (Gk: Σαμαρίτης/Samaritans); the Rabbis tended to refer to Samaritans as Cuthiim (Heb. כותיים) perpetuating the view of 2 Kings 17 which lists Cutheans among the peoples resettled in Samaria by the Assyrians. The community who worship Yahweh on Mt. Gerizim have always called themselves בְּנֵ֣י יִשְׂרָאֵ֑ל, (“Israelites”) or שַמֶרִים (“Observant ones”). Among scholars, “Samarian” is preferred as a neutral term to identify the people of this area, at least before the definitive break in relations between Gerizim and Jerusalem in the late second century B.C.E.
The history of David and Solomon’s monarchy, what its scope was and whether it ruled over the north is a controversial topic. For some recent discussions, see Avraham Faust and Zev I. Farber, The Bible’s First Kings: Uncovering the Story of Saul, David, and Solomon (Cambridge University Press, 2025); Omer Sergi, The Two Houses of Israel: State Formation and the Origins of Pan-Israelite Identity, Archaeology and Biblical Studies 33 (SBL 2023).
The priestly tribe of Levi possessed no territory. The text seems to be treating the Joseph tribes as a single tribe.
The neutral designation “YHWH/Yahweh-worship” rather than “Jewish” avoids anachronism. In the Persian Period, a “Jew” was a citizen of Yehud/Judea. “Yehudians/Judeans” were only one of several YHWH-worshiping communities who self-identified as belonging to the ancient tradition of YHWH worship (again, the neutral description) with its roots in ancient Israel and Judah.
Because this biblical book constitutes the only direct source of information about the experience of the returned Judean exiles, this version of events informed historical reconstructions of the period, not just regarding the Persian province of Yehud (formerly Judah) but also the province of Shomron (Samaria) to the north.
Editor’s note: For some discussion of this separatism in Ezra-Nehemiah, see Atilla Marossy, “Between Holy and Mundane: The Development of the Term Havdalah,” TheTorah (2022).
The northern tribe of Benjamin later allied with Judea. Here is an example of the illogic of the “ten tribes” idea; if Benjamin belonged with Judea then there should have been 9 lost tribes.
King Esarhaddon was the son of Sennacherib and reigned from 681–669 B.C.E., decades after the conquest of Samaria.
Christians also often claim, erroneously, that Samaritans are Gentiles.
This narrative is still repeated in current publications. For instance, the online Jewish Virtual Library entry for “Lost Tribes” cites the Encyclopedia Judaica stating, “In general, it can be said that these tribes disappeared from the stage of history.” (accessed July 9, 2025).
The classic studies are Sara Japhet, The Ideology of the Book of Chronicles and Its Place in Biblical Thought. 2nd ed. (Peter Lang, 1997) and Hugh G. M. Williamson, Israel in the Books of Chronicles (Cambridge University Press, 1977)
1 Chronicles 2:3–8:40, which reflects Second-Temple Judean self-identification.
Gary N. Knoppers, “Social Complexity, and Ethnic Diversity in the Genealogy of Judah,” Journal of Biblical Literature 120. 1 (2001) 15-30.
Barmash, 207. Aristeas is pseudepigraphical apologetic fiction but I cite it to highlight how the Hellenistic Jewish author’s narrative depends on the existence of all twelve tribes.
Editor’s note: For more on this book, see Malka Z. Simkovich, “Sefer Tuviah, the Book of Tobit: An Ancient Jewish Novel for Shavuot,” TheTorah (2014).
Jonathan Bourgel, “The Destruction of the Samaritan Temple by John Hyrcanus: A Reconsideration,” Journal of Biblical Literature 135.3 (2016) 505-523, especially 517 and fn. 64; see also 2 Macc 5:22–23.
For an overview of the results of the late University of Haifa archaeologist A. Zertal’s many surveys as well as full bibliography see Gary N. Knoppers, Jews and Samaritans: The Origin and History of their Early Relations (Oxford University Press: 2013) 103-105; Ido Koch, “Assyrian Deportation and Resettlement: The Story of Samaria,” TheTorah (2019).
Israel Finkelstein and Neil Asher Silberman, “Temple and Dynasty: Hezekiah, the Remaking of Judah and the Rise of the Pan-Israelite Ideology,” Journal for the Study of the Old Testament 30 (2005/2006) 259-285. Notably, Nadav Na’aman, “Dismissing the Myth of a Flood of Israelite Refugees in the Late Eighth Century BCE,” Zeitschrift für die Alttestamentliche Wissenschaft 126.1 (2014): 1–14, calls the “refugee theory” into question.
Knoppers, Jews and Samaritans, 40. Ezra and Nehemiah’s Golah returnees must have been relatively small in number as there is no archaeological evidence of a large population influx into Judah. Oded Lipschits, “Persian-Period Judah: A New Perspective” in Texts, Contexts and Readings in Postexilic Literature, ed. Louis Jonker (Mohr Siebeck, 2011), 187–211 [p. 195].
Benedikt Hensel, “Debating Temple and Torah in the Second Temple Period,” in Torah, Temple, Land. Construction of Judaism in Antiquity, ed., Markus Witte (Mohr Siebeck, 2021), 27-49 (33).
A Bigvai (Bagoas) appears in Ezra 2:2 (also Neh. 7:7) among the exiles returning to Judea with Zerubbabel; his family line is noted in Ezra 8:4.
The Elephantine papyri— photographs, texts, and translations—may be accessed on the website, Texts and Scripts from Elephantine Island in Egypt administered by the Ägyptisches Museum und Papyrussammlung Staatliche Museen zu Berlin, here. Aramaic translations were supervised by Dr. Verena Lepper.
Jedania repeats the community’s request for permission to rebuild their temple, promising that the entire community will pray for Bagoas (Verso 6-9a):
הנ על מראנ טב אתעשת על אגורא זכ למבנה בזי לא שבקנ לנ למבניה חזי בעלי טבתכ ורחמיכ זי תנה במצרינ אגרה מנכ ישתלח עליהומ על אגורא זי יהו אלהא למבניה ביב בירתא לקבל זי בנה הוה קדמינ ומחתא ולבונתא ועלותא יהקרבונ על מדבחא זי יהו אלהא בשמכ ונצלה עליה בכל עדנ אנחנה ונשינ ובנינ ויהודיא.
If it please our lord, take thought of that Temple [אגורא] to (re)build (it) since they do not let us (re)build it. Regard your (community members) and your friends who are here in Egypt. Let a letter be sent from you to them about the Temple of YHW the God to (re)build it in Elephantine the fortress just as it was formerly built. And they will offer the meal-offering and the incense, and the holocaust on the altar of YHW the God in your name and we shall pray for you at all times - we and our wives and our children and the Jews
P. Berlin 13495 [TAD A4.7]; there is also a second draft of this letter: Pap. Cairo EM JdE 43465; cf. Leith, New Perspectives, 158.
Frank Moore Cross, “Personal names in the Samaria Papyri,” Bulletin of the American Schools of Oriental Research 344 (Nov. 2006) 75-90; Jan Dušek, Les manuscript araméens du Wadi Daliyeh et la Samarie vers 450-332 av. J.-C. (Leiden: Brill, 2007).
Mary Joan Winn Leith, “Religious Continuity in Samaria/Israel: Numismatic Evidence,” in A “Religious Revolution” in Yehûd? The Material Culture of the Persian Period as a Test Case, edited by Christian Frevel, Katharina Pyschny, Izak Cornelius (Fribourg: Academic Press; Göttingen: Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht, 2014) 267-304.
Yitzhak Magen, Mount Gerizim Excavations Volume II: A Temple City (Israel Antiquities Authority, 2008).
The meaning of this phrase is unclear.
Yitzhak Magen, Haggai Misgav, and Levana Tsfania, Mount Gerizim Excavations Volume I: The Aramaic, Hebrew and Samaritan Inscriptions (Israel Antiquities Authority, 2004) inscription no. 199; cf. Knoppers, Jews and Samaritans, 128-129.
Knoppers, Jews and Samaritans, 127; all published in Magen, Misgav, and Tsfania, Mount Gerizim Excavations Volume I.
Knoppers, Jews and Samaritans, 190.
Knopppers, Jews and Samaritans, 190-191.
The two stories cannot be referring to the same Sanballat given that they occur a century or so apart. Josephus' story is undermined by the fact that the Gerizim shrine was already a century old.
Samaritan tradition (Samaritan Joshua) makes an analogous claim - that it was the south’s priesthood that was secondarily derived from the northern Aaronide tradition after Eli, a dissident priest, set up a rival shrine at Shiloh (this is the Eli in MT 1 Samuel 1-4); as Knoppers points out, neither Jewish nor Samaritan tradition ever disputed the authentic Aaronide status of the other (Knoppers, Jews and Samaritans 191-192).
Tawny Holm, “The Wandering Arameans in Egypt: Papyrus Amherst 63,” Hebrew Bible and Ancient Israel 12 (2023) 157-179; Karel van der Toorn, “Rosh Hashanah with the Early Israelites,” TheTorah (2020).
Papyrus Amherst 63 is written in Demotic script (late Egyptian cursive) and although published in 1911, its underlying language was not recognized as Aramaic until the 1940s. The text remains a challenge to decipher. There is currently no rendering into Aramaic script. Tawny Holm is preparing an edition with a transliteration and reverse translation into Aramaic script. Karel van der Toorn provides only a transliteration of his reading of the text: Karel van der Toorn, Papyrus Amherst 63 (Ugarit-Verlag, 2018), 3-5, 203.
Holm, “The Wandering Arameans,” 172.
Hensel, “Debating Temple and Torah,” 33.
Matthew Chalmers provides a summary of recent scholarship in “Samaritans, Biblical Studies, and Ancient Judaism: Recent Trends,” Currents in Biblical Research 20.1 (2021) 28–64.
The concept of an authoritative Torah is visible in the Persian Period when Ezra (Nehemiah 8) reads the “book of the Law of Moses”—סֵפֶר תּוֹרַת מֹשֶׁה— to the assembled Golah returnees. Yet the Sukkot celebration in Nehemiah 9 departs in several instances from Leviticus (23:34–44). Lisbeth Fried observes that the author of Ezra seems unaware of Passover or Yom Kippur and that Nehemiah 10:34 mentions a wood offering not found in the received Torah; Lisbeth Fried, Review of Hannah K. Harrington, The Books of Ezra and Nehemiah (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2022), Review of Biblical Literature 02/2023; eadem, “Sukkot in Ezra-Nehemiah and the Date of the Torah,” TheTorah (2015). Ezra’s Torah, furthermore, is not self-explanatory; it has to be interpreted by the attendant Levites (Neh. 8:7-8).
These suggestions go beyond the recognition that the Elohistic (E) Pentateuchal source originated in the Northern Kingdom and that a version of Deuteronomy was possibly introduced into Judean scribal circles by refugees from the north in the eighth century B.C.E. and served as the blueprint for King Josiah’s reform. For the origins of this idea and its development, see Albrecht Alt, “Die Heimat des Deuteronomiums,” Kleine Schriften zur Geschichte des Volkes Israel II (Munich, 1953), 250–275; H. L. Ginsberg, The Israelian Heritage of Judaism (Jewish theological Seminary of America, 1982); Benedikt Hensel, “On the Relationship of Judah and Samaria in Post-Exilic Times: A Farewell to the Conflict Paradigm,” Journal for the Study of the Old Testament 44 (2019), 19–42.
Emanuel Tov, “The Samaritan Pentateuch and the Dead Sea Scrolls: The Proximity of the Pre-Samaritan Qumran Scrolls to the SP,” in Keter Shem Tov: Essays on the Dead Sea Scrolls in Memory of Alan Crown, eds., Shani Tzoref and Ian Young (Gorgias Press, 2013), 59-88.
Emanuel Tov, Textual Criticism of the Hebrew Bible, 4th edition (Fortress Press, 2022), 175. Willingness in Jewish scribal circles to accept as authoritative variant versions of the Torah, and even “rewritten Bible” texts such as Jubilees, was widespread during the Second Temple period. Eva Mroczek (Dalhousie University) states, “It is now par for the course …to state there was not yet a biblical canon in the Second Temple period.” “The Hegemony of the Biblical in the Study of Second Temple Literature,” Journal of Ancient Judaism 6 (2015), 2-35 (p. 33); see also Carol A. Newsom, “There Was Never One Version of the Bible,” TheTorah (2022).
Emanuel Tov, “The Shared Tradition of the Septuagint and the Samaritan Pentateuch, in idem, Textual Developments Collected Essays, Volume 4 (Brill, 2019 [orig. pub. 2016]), 357-372. This takes on added significance when we consider the importance of the Septuagint, as only a Hebrew Torah of impeccable standing could be the basis of the translation that made the Torah accessible to Greek-speaking Diaspora Jews who for centuries thereafter considered it—as the Letter of Aristeas claims—to be endorsed by God.
See Jonathan Ben-Dov, “An Altar on Mt Ebal or Mt Gerizim? – The Torah in the Sectarian Debate,” TheTorah (2016).
The papyrus fragments that made up Papyrus Giessen (destroyed in WWII) were discovered in Antinoopolis (Middle Egypt) and contained a Greek version of Deuteronomy 24-29. Emanuel Tov demonstrated that the wording of Papyrus Giessen reflected the Old Greek (original translation) of the Septuagint; Emanuel Tov, “Pap. Giessen 13, 19, 22, 26: A Revision of the Septuagint?,” in idem., The Greek and Hebrew Bible. Collected Essays on the Septuagint (Brill, 1999 [orig. 1971]), 459–475. Later translations of the Torah into Greek revised the Septuagint to reflect the MT’s “Ebal.”
Gerizim also appears on an ostensible Dead Sea Scroll fragment of this verse. See James H. Charlesworth, “What Is a Variant? Announcing a Dead Sea Scrolls Fragment of Deuteronomy,” Maarav 16 (2009), 201-212, 273-274. Although a number of experts endorse the fragment’s authenticity, its uncertain provenance prevents a secure link to the Qumran community.
Knoppers, Jews and Samaritans, 203. Editor’s note: As for the structure on Mount Ebal, and whether or not it is an ancient altar of some kind, see Zvi Koenigsberg, “Joshua’s Altar on Mount Ebal: Israel’s Holy Site Before Shiloh,” TheTorah (2018).
Knoppers, Jews and Samaritans, 184-186.
Hila Dayfani, “4QpaleoExodm and the Gerizim Composition,” Journal of Biblical Literature 141.4 (2022) 673–698 [p. 693].
Dayfani, “4QpaleoExod,m” 679.
Dayfani, “4QpaleoExod,m” 685
As many scholars have observed, in fact, the centralization formula in Deuteronomy can be interpreted in an entirely neutral key. Where the Deuteronomistic History emphatically identifies the “place” with Jerusalem, from a Samarian point of view, “place” could just as easily refer to Gerizim. Furthermore, within the context of the biblical narrative, placing the altar at Gerizim need not contradict the choice of Jerusalem for God’s temple. From a Judean perspective, Gerizim could be acceptable as the site of a one-time sacrifice to commemorate the crossing into the Promised Land. Jews and Samarians could share a text that “only later became ratcheted to distinctive Samaritan Israelite identity,” which at that point would have triggered the MT’s substitution of Ebal for the original Gerizim. Chalmers, “Samaritans, Biblical Studies, and Ancient Judaism: Recent Trends,” 32, citing S.Schorch ‘The So-Called Gerizim Commandment in the Samaritan Pentateuch’, in M. Langlois (ed.), The Samaritan Pentateuch and the Dead Sea Scrolls (Peeters, 2019), 77-98 and E. Ulrich, ‘Shared Jewish Texts Related to the Samaritan Pentateuch,” Judaïsme ancien 7 (2019), 1-28.
Stefan Schorch, “The Torah as a Closed Cluster Text: Conceptualizing the Transmission of the Pentateuch in the Persian Period,” in Yahwism under the Achaemenid Empire, Edited by Gad Barnea and Reinhard G. Kratz (deGruyter, 2024), 413-432 (418).
Knoppers, Jews and Samaritans, 182.
Christophe Nihan (University of Münster) sees the process of compiling the Torah/Pentateuch as likely a Jerusalem scribal project, but that it was “devised from the beginning so as to be accepted not only by inhabitants of the former kingdom of Samaria, but also by the various diasporas in Egypt, Babylon or Persia, thus accounting for the Pentateuch’s broad-range reception in second temple Judaism.” Christophe Nihan, “The Emergence of the Pentateuch as ‘Torah’”, Religion Compass 4/6 (2010) 353-364 [p. 361].
Mary Joan Winn Leith, “New Perspectives on the Return from Exile and Persian-Period Yehud,” in Brad Kelle and Brent Strawn, eds., The Oxford Handbook of the Historical Books of the Hebrew Bible (Oxford University Press, 2020) 147-269 [pp. 152–155].
For a summary of the issues, see Matthew Chalmers, “Samaritans, Biblical Studies, and Ancient Judaism: Recent Trends,” Currents in Biblical Research 20.1 (2021) 28–64.