The Three Redactional and Theological Layers of the Plagues
The plague story expanded over time in three main stages: The oldest stage (E) has Moses perform 3 plagues on his own; this was revised to create a story of an all-powerful God performing 8 plagues (J), utilizing Moses as a mouthpiece. Finally, the Priestly redactor revised this into our familiar narrative of 10 plagues, in which God uses the miracles to announce himself to Egypt and the world.
Published: January 7, 2016
|
Last Updated: September 7, 2026
The plague narrative continues into chapters 11-12 with the plague of the first-born, but that account really requires a separate treatment.
For more on this see the relevant section in Marc Brettler, “Some Biblical Perspectives on the Haggadah,” TheTorah (2014); Ziony Zevit, “The Ten Plagues and Egyptian Ecology,” TheTorah (2015).
I include statement such as: “Pharaoh hardened his heart as God had spoken” (7:13), as God hardening Pharaoh’s heart. As will be seen, the matter can be traced by distinguishing between two roots, כ-ב-ד vs. ח-ז-ק.
For other examples of my supplementary approach to the Pentateuch’s composition, see my, “Israel's Departure from Egypt: A Liberation or an Escape?” TheTorah (2016); “Speculating about the Original Text of the Decalogue,” TheTorah (2015); “How the Israelite Family Was Put Together: The Twelve Sons of Jacob,” TheTorah (2017); “Jacob Is Renamed Israel (Twice): Why Does the Name Jacob Remain?” TheTorah (2017); “Noah’s Four Sons,” TheTorah (2014); “Moses Wrote Down this Song, Deuteronomy 31:22 - Which Song?” TheTorah (2018); “The Sacrifice of Isaac in Context: Recovering a Lost Ending of the Akedah,” TheTorah (2014).
For more on this, see David Frankel, “When Pharaoh’s Stubbornness Caught God by Surprise,” TheTorah (2015).
This is also true for the plague of darkness, which is not preceded by a warning or by negotiation. But this may be because the effects of this particular plague could be mitigated if the nature of the plague was known in advance (they could light a fire). Instead there is negotiation directly after the plague of Darkness, unlike what we find in the plagues of lice and boils where Pharaoh and Moses do not interact at all.
In the plague of blood, Pharaoh does not speak to Moses but is an active spectator; in the plague of pestilence, he checks to see if any of Israel’s livestock were killed.
The magicians also feature as characters in the plagues of blood and frogs.
This prominence is found in two other plagues. Aaron is partially responsible for the plague of blood and fully responsible for the plague of frogs.
See for example: Tzemah Yoreh, Moses’ Mission, (New York: Modern Scriptures, 2013), p. 38.
For a documentary solution, see Marc Brettler, “Source Criticism: It is in the (Plague of) Blood,” TheTorah (2015).
I skip here the phrase, “and there was blood throughout the land of Egypt (וַיְהִ֥י הַדָּ֖ם בְּכָל־אֶ֥רֶץ מִצְרָֽיִם)” since this may (or may not) be a Priestly gloss, meant to fit this image in with the imagery in 7:19, which is itself a Priestly gloss.
This would depend on whether he counted the serpent wonder and/or the death of the firstborn in the list of ten. If he counted both, then he has eleven. If he counted the drowning at the sea, then 12.
For more on the pre-P notion of Pharaoh hardening his own heart, see David Frankel, “When Pharaoh’s Stubbornness Caught God by Surprise.”
Some would even argue that Aaron is merely a relative of Moses and not his actual brother in the pre-P sources. See Isaac Sassoon, “Moses, Aaron, and Miriam: Were they Siblings?” TheTorah (2015).
Editor’s note: The color and set-up of the divisions follows TABS style. Tzemah Yoreh has a different color and presentation system, which the reader can find on his website: http://www.biblecriticism.com/
See for example John I. Durham, Exodus (Word Biblical Commentary; Waco Texas: Thomas Nelson, 1987.
These latter are not Elohist texts proper, but they are northern and early and come from the same milieu as the Elohist.