Abraham Passes the Test of the Akedah But Fails as a Father

The story of the Akedah appears to present Abraham’s actions in a uniformly positive light. However, Isaac’s absence at the end of the story, and Sarah’s death immediately afterwards, suggested to some traditional and modern commentators a criticism of Abraham.

SBL Style

Click to copy

"Abraham Passes the Test of the Akedah But Fails as a Father." TheTorah.com, September 26, 2019. https://www.thetorah.com/article/abraham-passes-the-test-of-the-akedah-but-fails-as-a-father.

APA Style

Click to copy

"Abraham Passes the Test of the Akedah But Fails as a Father" (2019, September 26). TheTorah.com. https://www.thetorah.com/article/abraham-passes-the-test-of-the-akedah-but-fails-as-a-father

Abraham Passes the Test of the Akedah But Fails as a Father

The Sacrifice of Isaac, Adi Holzer, 1997. Wikimedia

Published: September 26, 2019

|

Last Updated: September 7, 2026

  1. Editor’s note: The contrast between these stories is discussed in Reuven Kimelman, "Testing Abraham: Justice in Sodom before Loyalty in the Akedah," TheTorah (2014).

  2. See discussion in David Blumenthal, “Akedah and Rosh Hashanah: Invoking the Original Oath God Was Forced to Make," TheTorah (2014).

  3. Editor’s note: See discussion in, Devorah Schoenfeld, "Akedah: How Jews and Christians Explained Abraham's Faith," TheTorah (2017); Isaac Kalimi, "Mitigating the Akedah," TheTorah (2015); Judy Klitsner, "The Book of Job and Its Paradoxical Relationship with the Akedah," TheTorah (2015); Chaim Trachtman, "The Maimonidean Akedah," TheTorah (2014).

  4. The other thrice-repeated phrase is הנני (verses 1, 7, and 11).

  5. Editor’s note: The glaring absence of Isaac has led some critical scholars to suggest that the verse is evidence of an older layer of the story in which Abraham did sacrifice Isaac and then continues home without him. See Tzemah Yoreh, "The Sacrifice of Isaac in Context," TheTorah (2014).

  6. On these parallels, with further insights into their significance, see especially Jon D. Levenson, The Death and Resurrection of the Beloved Son: The Transformation of Child Sacrifice in Judaism and Christianity (New Haven: Yale University Press, 1993), 104–110; Uriel Simon, “על גירוש ישמעאל, העקדה שקדמה לעקדת יצחק” [The Banishment of Ishmael: The Akedah Preceding the Akedah of Isaac] in עקדת יצחק לזרעו: מבט בעין ישראלית (The Binding of Isaac for His Descendants: The Akedah from an Israeli Viewpoint), ed. Israel Rozenson and Binyamin Lau (Jerusalem: ha-Ḳeren le-hanṣaḥat Yiṣḥaḳ Hirshberg, 2003), 377–380.

  7. Levenson, Death and Resurrection, 104.

  8. See Shalom Carmy, “Paradox, Paradigm, and the Birth of Inwardness: On R. Kook and the Akeda,” in Hazon Nahum: Studies in Jewish Law, Thought, and History Presented to Dr. Norman Lamm, ed. Yaakov Elman and Jeffrey S. Gurock (New York and Hoboken: Michael Scharf Publication Trust of the Yeshiva University Press, and Ktav, 1997), 459-478 at 466 [n14], noting that this understanding of the mishnah is reflected in the Jerusalem Talmud as well.

  9. This is one of a group of Shavuot piyyuṭim that deal with the giving of the Torah, the theme of the day.

  10. The relevant text was published by Shulamit Elitzur, רבי אלעזר בירבי קליר - קדושתאות ליום מתן תורה [Rabbi El’azar be-Rabbi Qillir: The Qedushta’ot for the Day of the Giving of the Torah] (Jerusalem: Meḳiṣe Nirdamim, 2000), 184–185. Elitzur discussed this motif in the corpus of classical piyyuṭ in her introduction to the volume, pp. 67–73, and in expanded form in, Shulamit Elitzur, “החטא אברהם אבינו בעקדו את יצחק?” [Did Abraham Sin by Binding Isaac?] in עקדת יצחק לזרעו: מבט בעין ישראלית (The Binding of Isaac for His Descendants: The Akedah from an Israeli Viewpoint), ed. Israel Rozenson and Binyamin Lau (Jerusalem: ha-Ḳeren le-hanṣaḥat Yiṣḥaḳ Hirshberg, 2003), 215–224.

  11. The text, found in the Cairo Geniza, was published by Joseph Yahalom and Michael Sokoloff, Shirat Bene Ma’arava: Aramaic Poems of the Jews of the Land of Israel in the Byzantine Period (Jerusalem: Israel Academy of Sciences, 1999) [Hebrew], poem #14.

  12. The text is from Jerrold C. Frakes, Early Yiddish Texts 1100-1750 : With Introduction and Commentary (Oxford; Oxford University Press, 2008), 316-328; translation (with slight adjustments) from Jerrold C. Frakes, Early Yiddish Epic (Syracuse: Syracuse University Press, 2014), 149–155.