Is Holiness Contagious?

Impurity is transferred through physical contact. Theologically speaking, could the same be true for holiness?

SBL Style

Click to copy

"Is Holiness Contagious?." TheTorah.com, March 20, 2015. https://www.thetorah.com/article/is-holiness-contagious.

APA Style

Click to copy

"Is Holiness Contagious?" (2015, March 20). TheTorah.com. https://www.thetorah.com/article/is-holiness-contagious

Is Holiness Contagious?

Aaron in the Tabernacle, engraving by Gérard Jollain, 1670 (colorized). Wikimedia

Categories:

TzavTetzaveh

Published: March 20, 2015

|

Last Updated: September 7, 2026

  1. For a more detailed version of this article, see “Is Holiness Contagious?” in Purity, Holiness and Identity in Judaism and Christianity: Essays in Memory of Susan Haber, ed. C. Ehrlich, A Runesson and E. Schuller [Mohr Siebeck: Tubingen, 2013], 253-262.

  2. Nahum Sarna, The JPS Torah Commentary: Exodus  (Philadelphia, 1991), ad Exod 29:37.

  3. Meyers, C. L. and E. M. Meyers, Haggai, Zechariah 1–8, Anchor Bible 25B (New York, 1987) p. 56.

  4. See Sifra Tzav 1: Rabbi Yose the Galilean says: When the text says “Anything that touches the altar becomes holy,” I might conclude that this refers both to items that belong on the altar and items that do not. For that reason the text says “sheep.” Just as sheep belong on the altar [so also the verse refers to other items that belong on the altar,] but not items that do not belong on the altar…. When the verse says, “Anything that touches the altar becomes holy,” it teaches us that the altar transfers holiness to items that are worthy of becoming holy. And how do we know that [Temple] vessels [that are holy] transfer holiness [only] to those items that are worthy to become holy? In order to teach us that principle, the verse says….” (my translation).

    ר’ יוסי הגלילי אומר: מתוך שנאמר כל הנוגע במזבח יקדש שומע אני דברים הראוים למזבח ודברים שאינן ראוים למזבח תלמוד לומר כבשים מה כבשים המיוחדים שהם ראוים למזבח יצא דבר שאין ראוי למזבח… מתוך שנאמר כל הנוגע במזבח יקדש למדנו שהמזבח מקדש את הראוי לו…. מנין שאף הכלים מקדשים את הראוי להם ת”ל…

  5. Rashi Exod 30:29.

  6. In addition to the text cited above in note 4, see also m. Zev 9:1 and 9:7; b. Zev 83a and 86a.

  7. See especially Sifra Tzav 3: כל אשר יגע בבשרה יקדש, יכול אעפ”י שלא בלע תלמוד לומר בבשרה, עד שיבלע. This midrash halakhah is quoted often in the Talmud; see e.g. b. Pes 45a and b. Nazir 37b.

  8. Shamma Friedman, “The Holy Scriptures Defile the Hands,” in M. Brettler and M. Fishbane eds., Minhah le-Nahum (Shefield, 1993), p. 122 (emphasis in the original).

  9. See my “Tradition or Context: Two Exegetes Struggle with Peshat,” in From Ancient Judaism to Modern Israel, ed. by J. Neusner and E. Frierichs, volume 3 (Atlanta, 1989), pp. 173-186, and more recently the introduction to my Peirush ha-Rashbam al ha-Torah(Jerusalem, 2009), esp. pp. 16-18.

  10. The interpretation can be found even before Rashbam, e.g. in Ps.-Jon. ad loc, and also in the LXX and the Vulgate. Rashbam repeats this explanation four times in his Torah commentary: ad Exod 29:37, 30:29, Lev 6:11 and 11:8. 

  11. Admittedly, Rashbam was willing to interpret verses in ways that directly contradict rabbinic halakha, and he says so explicitly more than once in his commentary. For more on this see Zev Farber’s TABS essay, “Can the Torah Contradict Halacha?”

  12. One of the best left-handed compliments in the history of Jewish Bible commentaries must be Rabbi David Zvi Hoffmann’s commentary on Lev 6:11, where he calls Rashbam’s comment on this verse the best of all the explanations that reject Jewish tradition. “Dies ist noch die vernünftigste aller antitraditionellen Erklärungen,” in Das Buch Leviticus übersetzt und erklärt” (Berlin, 1906), p. 238. Hoffmann does not like Rashbam’s habit of ignoring rabbinic exegesis and going his own way, but he considers Rashbam’s approach preferable to that of the critics who see contagious holiness in the verse.

  13.  The JPS Torah Commentary: Leviticus (Philadelphia, 1989) ad loc. 

  14. Lev. 11:24, 26, 27 and 31; 15:10, 19 and 27.

  15.  Anchor Bible Leviticus, volume 1 (New York, 1991), esp. pp. 444-456.

  16. Longer commentary to Exod 29:37; commentary to Lev 6:11 and 20 and to Hag 2:12. Cf. Friedman, p. 121, note 2, who writes that ibn Ezra “approaches communicable holiness.” On a possible contradiction in ibn Ezra’s commentary to Num 11:8, see Uriel Simon, The Ear Discerns Words: Studies in ibn Ezra’s Exegetical Methodology [Heb.] (Ramat Gan, 2013), p. 95, note 67. On ibn Ezra’s possible dependence here on Menahem ibn Saruq, see Simon,ibid., note 68.

  17. See my “Tradition or Context,” cited above note 9. See also more recently my “Lonely Man of Peshat,” Jewish Quarterly Review 99:2 (Spring, 2009), 291-300.

  18. רק בתורות ובמשפטים ובחקים, אם מצאנו שני טעמים לפסוקים, והטעם האחד כדברי המעתיקים, שהיו כולם צדיקים, נשען על אמתם בלי ספק בידים חזקים. וחלילה חלילה מלהתערב עם הצדוקים, האומרים כי העתקתם מכחשת הכתוב, והדקדוקים. רק קדמונינו הי’ אמת, וכל דבריהם אמת וד’ אלהים אמת ינחה את עבדו בדרך אמת:

  19. Maharshal, in his Yam Shel Shelomo, in the introduction to Tractate Chullin, says that ibn Ezra “did not know Talmud (לא היה בעל תלמוד).” 

  20.  והנה התברר כי אין כח בקודש לקדש מה שלא היה קדש על ידי מגע אמצעי ככח טמא נפש לטמא