Is the Mitzvah to Burn or Nullify Chametz?

The night before Passover, chametz “leaven” is searched for and then burned the next morning—ביעור חמץ biʿur chametz. Afterwards, any remaining unfound chametz is nullified and declared to be “like the dust of the earth,”— ביטול חמץ bittul chametz. Which of these acts fulfills the biblical requirement?

SBL Style

Click to copy

"Is the Mitzvah to Burn or Nullify Chametz?." TheTorah.com, April 16, 2024. https://www.thetorah.com/article/is-the-mitzvah-to-burn-or-nullify-chametz.

APA Style

Click to copy

"Is the Mitzvah to Burn or Nullify Chametz?" (2024, April 16). TheTorah.com. https://www.thetorah.com/article/is-the-mitzvah-to-burn-or-nullify-chametz

Is the Mitzvah to Burn or Nullify Chametz?

Haggadah with German translation, 1829, Braginsky Collection B350, f. 2r (adapted). E-codices

Published: April 16, 2024

|

Last Updated: September 7, 2026

  1. For a deep analysis in Hebrew of these issues see Rav David Bigman, השבתת חמץ—ביטול בלב או ביעור באש [Removal of Chametz: Nullification in the Mind or Burning with Fire?], Maʿagalim 4 (2005), 10–26.

  2. The Torah literally says that this is to occur on the first day of the festival. But the rabbis understand this “first day” to refer to the fourteenth of Nissan. See Mekhilta de-Rabbi Ishmael, Pisḥa 8.

  3. In both places, Targum Onkelos uses root בטל (battel) to translate this word, implying that it can mean more than just “nullify”—it’s contemporary meaning—but “cause to cease to exist.”

  4. Many other Tannaitic sources also state that tashbitu refers to burning. Rabbi Meir and Rabbi Yehudah in Mishnah Pesachim 1:4, of Mishnah Temurah 1:5, of R. Yehudah in Mishnah Pesachim 2:1, and it is the position of Rabbi Akiva in a baraita on Bavli Pesachim 5a. Burning is also probably the original meaning of ביעור חמץ (biur chametz), ubiquitous in rabbinic literature, which should be rendered as “burning leaven” and not “removal of leaven.”

  5. Nullification is also mentioned in Sifre Deuteronomy 131, which quotes this mishnah.

  6. It is possible that this notion is borrowed from the similar concept of nullification of idols. See Mishnah Avodah Zarah 4:4-7. On the nullification of idols see Yair Furstenberg, “The Rabbinic View of Idolatry and the Roman Political Conception of Divinity,” Journal of Religion 2010; Yishay Rosen-Zvi, ״אבד תאבדון את כל המקומות״ הפולמוס על חובת השמדת עבודה זרה בספרות התנאית,” Reshit, 2009.

  7. Shamma Friedman, תוספתא עתיקתא מסכת פסח ראשון: מקבילות המשנה והתוספתא פירוש ומבוא כללי  [Tosefta Atiqta Pesah Rishon: Synoptic Parallels of Mishna and Tosefta Analyzed with a Methodological Introduction] (Ramat-Gan: Bar-llan University Press, 2002).  

  8. The rishonim vigorously debated whether this remained halakhically true. See the Ramban on Exodus 12:19 and the Rosh, Pesahim 1:4.

  9. Eventually the geonim formulate this in Aramaic. See for example Sheiltot 74.

  10. There are other cases where the Talmud does not mandate nullification, for instance the case of a person leaving on a trip by boat or caravan (b. Pesahim 6b) or chametz in the rafters, in holes, or in the mouth of a snake (Pesahim 10b). This leads to debates among the rishonim as to how nullification intersects with these halakhot. In reality, the Talmud is simply uneven in its application of nullification as a solution to certain problems.

  11. While medieval commentaries debate whether the source in the Torah is the verb תשביתו (Rashi) or somewhere else—see Tosafot Pesahim 4b מדאורייתא בביטול בלעמא סגי; Ramban, op. cit.—this line now enshrines mental nullification as a means from the Torah itself to remove chametz and avoid transgression.

  12. It is also reflected in Halakhot Pesukot which explicitly says that nullification is derived from the verb tashbitu.

  13. Pesahim 4b s.v. מדאורייתא.