The Rev. M.J. Raphall, D.D, 1850 Library of Congress
Noah’s Curse: On the Eve of the Civil War, a Rabbi Declares Black Slavery Biblical
In 1861, Rabbi Morris Raphall of New York attempted to save the Union by declaring from his pulpit that slavery was the will of God, as per the Torah’s story of the curse of Ham. Some rabbis and Jewish scholars approved of the message, but others, such as Michael Heilprin and David Einhorn, pushed back with biting criticism.
Published: October 28, 2022
|
Last Updated: September 7, 2026
See discussion in, Emerson Powery, “The Bible and Slavery in American Life,” in The Oxford Handbook of the Bible in America, ed. Paul C. Gutjahr (New York: Oxford University Press, 2017), 304–318.
For an overview of the New York City scene before and during the Civil War and the reaction of Jews to the crisis, see Howard B. Rock, Haven of Liberty: New York Jews in the New World, 1654–1865 (New York: NYU Press, 2012) ch. 11.
Raphall, whose father was banker to the King of Sweden, was educated in Copenhagen. In Britain he became honorary secretary to the chief rabbi and translated Maimonides, Joseph Albo, and Herz Wessley. Though there is no evidence of formal ordination, he was rabbi of the Birmingham synagogue for eight years.
Raphall also delivered his sermon at a gathering at the New-York Historical Society chaired by the artist and inventor Samuel F. Morse. Morris. U. Schappes, ed., A Documentary History of the Jews in the United States, 1654–1875 (New York, 1950, 1971) p. 683, n.7.
Morris Raphall, ‘Bible View of Slavery’, a Discourse by Rabbi Morris Jacob Raphall before Congregation B'nai Jeshurun, New York, on the National Fast Day, January 4, 1861, in Schappes, Documentary History, pp. 405–418.
David Frankel, “Noah, Ham and the Curse of Canaan: Who Did What to Whom in the Tent?” TheTorah (2017), argues that the curse was originally directed by Ham against his son Canaan for incest. In this reading, the origin and purpose of the story was to justify the Israelite domination of the Canaanites rather than of the Egyptians. See also Tzemah Yoreh, “Noah’s Four Sons” TheTorah (2014) and Zev Farber, “Noah’s Nakedness: How the Canaan – Ham Curse Conundrum Came to Be,” TheTorah (2015), both of whom argue that the early story is about the sin of Canaan and not Ham, thus fitting the curse. Either way, whether or not Ham was the sinner or Canaan, there is not biblical curse of Ham, only a curse of Canaan.
See the genealogy in Genesis 10. Editor’s note: For more on this chapter, see David Ben-Gad HaCohen, “Decoding the Table of Nations: Reading it as a Map,” TheTorah (2015).
Raphall, Bible View of Slavery, pp. 410-412. The misnamed curse of Ham, the source of numerous defenses of black slavery and racism, has produced a voluminous literature both scholarly, political, and religious. The fullest analysis of the literature surrounding the Curse of Ham is David M. Goldenberg, The Curse of Ham: Race and Slavery in Early Judaism, Christianity, and Islam (Princeton, 2005). Among his conclusions are that there was no prejudice against skin color in the biblical era. Dark skinned peoples included not only Africans but many Semites and Egyptians. Unlike the Talmudic and Medieval eras, Judaism’s earliest literature did not reflect attitudes of disdain against black Africans. Goldenberg explores the etymology of the name Ham, finding that assertions that the name meant black were erroneous. Moreover, the biblical Hebrew image of the lands of Cush was of powerful kingdoms with strong militaries. Cushite skin color had no negative valence. The story was reinterpreted in the Roman era when Blacks became increasingly identified and denigrated as slaves. See Goldenberg, The Curse of Ham, pp.43–50, 75, 126–128, 135-140, 162-3, 183. See also idem, “Why Do Miriam and Aaron Criticize Moses for Marrying a Kushite Woman?” TheTorah (2022); Abraham Melamed, The Image of the Black in Jewish Culture: A History of the Other, trans. Betty Sigler Rozen (London: Routledge-Courzon, 2003); Meylech Viswanth, “Black People in Jewish Tradition: Eliminating Racism Requires Honesty” TheTorah (2020).
Abraham (Gen 24:5, 35), Isaac (Gen 24:66), Jacob (Gen 30:43, 32:6), Job 1:3. While Raphall attributes this passage to Exodus it is actually from Deuteronomy.
Raphall, Bible View of Slavery, 412-415.
Ibid., 415-417. How much this distinction between Hebrew and non-Hebrew slaves was actually observed in rabbinic times is an open question. While the Mishnah and Talmud certainly include legal distinctions, Catherine Hezser argues that during the Greco-Roman era “whether someone was a slave or free person was important to them [Jewish slaveowners], rather than whether the slave was of Jewish origin.” Catherine Hezser, Jewish Slavery in Antiquity (Oxford, 2005), pp. 20-23, 114-120.
Raphall’s assertion here contradicts Deuteronomy 23:16, which forbids returning a slave, as David Einhorn will note (see below).
Mishneh Torah, Sefer Kinyan, “Laws of Slaves” 9:8. See discussion in James A. Diamond, “The Treatment of Non– Israelite Slaves: From Moses to Moses,” TheTorah (2015).
Raphall is playing off Jonah 3:10 here, in which the city of Nineveh repents.
Raphall, Bible View of Slavery, 417-418. The contradiction or difficulty of claiming that slaves are both human and property has been a constant problem for defenders of slavery. Hezser contends that the rabbis of the Mishnah and Talmud, who accepted slavery and included slave owners, never solved this conundrum. Hezser, Jewish Slavery, pp. 57-60, 175.
Schappes, Documentary History, pp. 406, 683 [n.9].
Samuel Strickberger, Covenant in Crisis: Orthodox Reactions to Slavery in Antebellum America, 1848 – 1861, Honors Thesis (University of Pennsylvania, 2022). Strickberger persuasively argues that both American Orthodox clergy as well as their congregations were proslavery, fearing the progressivism of the reform movement that supported abolitionism, their fear of what would happen to the Jewish population in America if the union sundered, and their unwavering commitment to a literalist interpretation of the Bible. See also Schappes, Documentary History, n.4, p. 686. Aside from Illowy, who strongly supported the South, the other rabbis expressed some misgivings, especially over Raphall’s interpretation of the Curse of Ham.
See the excellent entry, HEILPRIN, MICHAEL in The Jewish Encyclopedia (1906), 6.326.
He refers here to the killing of Jesus.
Michael Heilprin, "Michael Heilprin Replies to Dr. Raphall, The New–York Daily Tribune, 15 January 1861, in Schappes, Documentary History, 422-423.
Ibid.,423-424. David Einhorn (see below) contended that sub-Saharan African descended from Semites through Japheth. Ham’s descendants were the Egyptians. Goldenberg’s assessment is that the biblical Kingdom of Cush included not just sub-Saharan Africa but also much of Arabia and the land of the Israelites, and that the Cushites held power in Egypt for 700 years. See further, Goldenberg, The Curse of Ham, pp. 13–21. It is not clear why Heilprin restricts the Cushites to Syria and Palestine.
In reality, the term can mean either, depending on context.
This is again an apologetic claim based on his interpretation of eved as a hired servant. Certainly, the Bible claims that all these men had avadim (plural of eved)—Abraham (Gen 24:5, 35), Isaac (Gen 24:66), Jacob (Gen 30:43, 32:6), Job 1:3—which, in context, does appear to mean “slaves.”
Heilprin, Replies to Dr. Raphall, pp. 421–427; Heilprin likely reasoned that since all Hebrews were slaves and Moses was a Hebrew, beneath his princely garments he was still a slave. Heilprin also maintained that the word l’olam referred only to the lifetime of the bondsmen and did not imply perpetual servitude. His refusal to agree, contrary to the consensus of scholars, that one of the definitions of eved was a slave, was central to his interpretation.
His response was translated from the German by Mrs. Kaufmann Kohler.
Howard B. Rock, “New York's Pro–Slavery Rabbi,” Tablet (September 9, 2012); Adam Goodheart, “The Rabbi and the Rebellion,” New York Times (March 7, 2011); Schappes, Documentary History, pp. 418–419, 444–445. Robert F. Southard, “The Debate on Slavery: David Einhorn and the Jewish Political Turn,” American Jewish Archives Journal V. 65.1–2 (2012): 137–155.
This is even clearer in Exodus, which places the wife together with the other “objects” in the man’s household. Einhorn, unlike Raphall, notes the textual differences between the Exodus and Deuteronomy versions of the Decalogue. Perhaps as a Reform rabbi, he felt freer to do so than the Orthodox Raphall?
Editor’s note: For some discussion of this, see Isaac Sassoon, “Did Israel Celebrate Their Freedom While Owning Slaves?” TheTorah (2015).
Einhorn, Response to a Biblical View, 6-8.
Editor’s note: For more on blood vengeance, see Yigal Bloch, “Blood Vengeance in Ancient Near Eastern Context,” TheTorah (2022); Itamar Kislev, “Revising the Laws of Murder to Accommodate Blood Vengeance,” TheTorah (2022). For more on marrying a captive woman, see Shaye J.D. Cohen and Zev Farber, “Marrying a Beautiful Captive Woman,” TheTorah (2020); David Resnick, “The Captive Woman at the Intersection of War and Family Laws,” TheTorah (2021).
Ibid., p. 8. Editors’ note: This is reminiscent of Maimonides view of sacrifices as a concession to ancient people and their familiar form of worship. See discussion in, Menachem Kellner, “Tabernacle, Sacrifices, and Judaism: Maimonides vs. Nahmanides,” TheTorah (2020); Kenneth Seeskin, “The Tabernacle: A Concession to Human Religious Needs?” TheTorah (2020); David Gillis, “On the Problem of Sacrifices: Maimonides’ Ladder of Enlightenment,” TheTorah (2018).
Editor’s note: For a discussion of whether the Torah uniformly approves this practice or not, see Isaac S.D. Sassoon, “The Biblical Prohibition of Polygyny?” TheTorah (2016).
Ibid., pp. 8-9; Heilprin, Replies to Dr. Raphall, pp. 426 -427.
The phrase “disposing of himself” in this period and context, unlike current usage, means controlling one’s own fate, being one’s own master.
Einhorn, Response to a Biblical View, 11-13.
Einhorn, Response to a Biblical View, 18-19.
For further details on Raphall’s relationship with Lincoln, and his son’s experience in the army, see Jonathan D. Sarna and Benjamin Shapell, Lincoln and the Jews: A History (St. Martin's Publishing Group, 2015), 150-151, 158-159, 211-214, 258.
[New York] Jewish Messenger, 26 April 1861, 24 May 1861; New York Times, 1 May 1863, 27 November 1864. Goodheart, “Rabbi and the Rebellion,” New York Times, 7 March 2001.
See Rock, Haven of Liberty, pp. 236-240, 249 –251.