Why Do Miriam and Aaron Criticize Moses for Marrying a Kushite Woman?

Were they racists?

SBL Style

Click to copy

"Why Do Miriam and Aaron Criticize Moses for Marrying a Kushite Woman?." TheTorah.com, June 17, 2022. https://www.thetorah.com/article/why-do-miriam-and-aaron-criticize-moses-for-marrying-a-kushite-woman.

APA Style

Click to copy

"Why Do Miriam and Aaron Criticize Moses for Marrying a Kushite Woman?" (2022, June 17). TheTorah.com. https://www.thetorah.com/article/why-do-miriam-and-aaron-criticize-moses-for-marrying-a-kushite-woman

Why Do Miriam and Aaron Criticize Moses for Marrying a Kushite Woman?

Moses marries Zipporah, daughter of Jethro, Charles Le Brun 1687. Palazzo dei Musei, Wikimedia

Categories:

Beha’alotcha

Published: June 17, 2022

|

Last Updated: September 7, 2026

  1. See lengthy discussion in David M. Goldenberg, Curse of Ham: Race and Slavery in Early Judaism, Christianity, and Islam (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2003), part 3. Editor’s note: See also, Meylekh Viswanath, “Black People in Jewish Tradition: Eliminating Racism Requires Honesty,” TheTorah (2020).

  2. For the purposes of this article, I am following here the translation suggested by by R. Abraham ibn Ezra that this final phrase is reported speech: זה הדבור שדברה מרים “this is what Miriam said.” See discussion of כי as reported speech in BDB s.v. “כי” 1b. Other commentators, such as R. Joseph Bekhor Shor, see it as a parenthetical, with the narrator affirming that Moses did indeed marry a Kushite woman.

  3. Kush sometimes refers to other regions, and it is unclear that the verse really means to say Nubian. See my discussion in “Moses’ Kushite Wife Was Zipporah the Midianite,” TheTorah (2022), where I argue that the term may be a synonym for Midianite. For the purposes of this piece, however, I will work with the interpretation that the verse means she was Nubian or dark-skinned, since that is the more typical understanding of the Kushite.

  4. Ibn Ezra here cites Habakkuk 3:7, which I argue (in my “Moses’ Kushite Wife Was Zipporah the Midianite”) proves that Midian was also known as Kush, and that Midianite is actually the meaning of the term Kushite here. Nevertheless, Ibn Ezra seems to understand the term Kushan in that verse not as an ethnonym or toponym, but as a nickname for the people, “Nubians,” because of their dark skin.

  5. Rashi (Rabbi Solomon Yitzhaki, ca. 1040–1105), in his commentary ad loc., also believes the woman to be Zipporah the Midianite, and offers more than one reason why she may have been called “the Nubian” even though she was not (see Goldenberg, Curse of Ham, pp. 58-59). Notably, both Rashi and ibn Ezra follow the classical Jewish interpretation that Miriam and Aaron objected to Moses having discontinued marital relations with his wife. For some discussion of this reading, see Elad Filler, “Moses and the Kushite Woman: Classic Interpretations and Philo’s Allegory,” TheTorah (2018).

  6. Edward Ullendorff, Ethiopia and the Bible: The Schweich Lectures 1967 (London: Oxford University Press, 1968), 8.

  7. David Samuel Margoliouth, “Ethiopian Woman” in A Dictionary of the Bible, Dealing with Its Language, Literature and Contents, Including the Biblical Theology, ed. James Hastings (Edinburgh: T&T Clark, 1898), 1:790–791 [p. 791].

  8. Editor’s note: For more on Egyptian slavery, see Mark Janzen, “What We Know About Slavery in Egypt,” TheTorah (2016). For more on the Egyptian attitude towards foreigners, see Flora Brooke Anthony, “Egypt’s Attitude Towards Foreigners,” TheTorah (2016); eadem, “Levantines in 15th and 14th Century Egyptian Art,” TheTorah (2019).

  9. This is certainly the thrust of the biblical story as we have it now. From a source critical perspective, it is possible that this account of the complaint against Moses’ wife derives from a source that saw the Egyptian experience as oppression but not slavery. See Gili Kugler, “Egypt without Slavery—Tracing the Tradition of Israel’s Residence in Egypt,” Scandinavian Journal of the Old Testament 35.1 (2021): 111–125; Tzemah Yoreh, “Behind the Iron Curtain in Egypt: Oppressed but not Enslaved,” TheTorah (2021); David Frankel, “Israelites in Egypt: Slaves or Sojourners?” TheTorah (2022).

  10. An echo of the story is heard in the paraphrase of Targum Pseudo-Jonathan to Numbers 12:1. See further Goldenberg, Curse of Ham, 55–56.

  11. See Goldenberg, Curse of Ham, 29–40, where I survey all biblical references to Kushites.

  12. A different reason for the aptness of whiteness here is suggested in Sifrei Zuṭa 12:10 (p. 276):

    מפני שהיו מלבינים ומאדימים לפי כך נטמאו בבהרת עזה ולבנה.
    Because they were making [Moses] turn white and red (i.e., humiliating him), for this reason, they (=Miriam and Aaron) became impure with a strong and white bright spot.

    Notably, the punishment here is not because they referred to her black skin, but because they whitened Moses’ skin by gossiping about him.

  13. For examples, see Goldenberg, Curse of Ham, 227; and add Sidnie White Crawford, “Moses’ Black-Skinned Wife: What Does the Torah Think of Her?” TheTorah (2021).

  14. For the Qumran fragments, see especially the edition of 4QNumb by Nathan Jastram, The Book of Numbers from Qumrân, Cave IV (4QNumb), Doctoral Dissertation (Harvard University, 1990). Septuagint: Vetus Testamentum Graecum (Göttingen, 1931). Vetus Latina: Pierre Sabatier ed., Bibliorum sacrorum latinae versions antiquae seu vetis italica et ceterae quaecunque in codicibus manuscriptis et antiquorum libris reperiri potuerunt (1739–49), ad loc., 1:288 in the three-volume Turnhout, 1976 reprint.

  15. Jerome (d. 420), the translator of the Vulgate, translated the biblical text directly from Hebrew to Latin. Just as his addition in Numbers 12:10 can be attributed to an attempt at explanatory elaboration, so too is that the case in the Vulgate translation of Ps 68:14/15, where the Hebrew “it snowed in Salmon” became nive dealbatur Selmon (see Goldenberg, “Racism, Color Symbolism, and Color Prejudice,” in The Origins of Racism in the West, ed. Miriam Eliav-Feldon, Benjamin Isaac, and Joseph Ziegler [Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2009], Appendix). Jerome similarly added whiteness in his Contra Ioannem Hierosolymitanum 33 when quoting Exod 4:6, as does Augustine, Sermon 6.6. An interesting modern-day case is the translation of Origen’s Homilies to Numbers in the Sources Chretiennes series. Origen’s text has leprosa sicut nix but the translation reads: “lépreuse, blanche comme neige” (Homélies sur les Nombres; texte Latin de W.A. Baehrens; nouvelle édition par Louis Doutreleau d’aprés l’édition d’Andre Méhat et les notes de Marcel Borret, Paris, 1996, SC 415, pp. 172–173, 176–177 bis, 178–179).

  16. Onkelos translates this way in Exodus 4:6 as well, as does Targum Pseudo-Jonathan מחוורא היא כתלגא “white like snow.”

  17. The Sifrei writes:

    והנה מרים מצרעת כשל[ג]—מלמד שנצטרעה בעזה.
    “And Miriam was afflicted with tzaraʿat like snow”—this teaches that she had bright tzaraʿat.

    For the text of the Sifrei and discussion, see Menachem Kahana, ספרי במדבר: מהדורה מבוארת [Sifre on Numbers: An Annotated Edition] (Jerusalem: Magnes, 2011), 1.259. As Kahana explains in his commentary (ibid., 3.679), this opaque gloss is based on how the Rabbis categorized forms of tzaraʿat (m. Negaim 1:1):

    מַרְאוֹת נְגָעִים שְׁנַיִם שֶׁהֵן אַרְבָּעָה. בַּהֶרֶת עַזָּה כַשֶּׁלֶג, שְׁנִיָּה לָהּ כְּסִיד הַהֵיכָל. וְהַשְּׂאֵת כִּקְרוּם בֵּיצָה, שְׁנִיָּה לָהּ כְּצֶמֶר לָבָן, דִּבְרֵי רַבִּי מֵאִיר. וַחֲכָמִים אוֹמְרִים, הַשְּׂאֵת כְּצֶמֶר לָבָן, שְׁנִיָּה לָהּ כִּקְרוּם בֵּיצָה.
    The appearances of diseased skin are two which are four: Baheret is bright like snow, its subsidiary is like the lime of the Temple. Se'et is like the membrane of an egg, its subsidiary is like white wool; the words of Rabbi Meir. The Sages say, Se'et is like white wool, its subsidiary is like the membrane of an egg.

    This understanding of baheret as bright white is supported in the rabbinic reading of the laws of tzaraʿat in Leviticus 13:4 found in Sifra (Tazria, Negaim 2:2):

    בהרת לבנה אין לי אלא בהרת לבנה, מנין לרבות את השאת תלמוד לומר למטן שאת לבנה, ומנין לרבות שאר המראות תלמוד לומר ואם בהרת. יכול כשם שהוא שלישי לכתוב כך תהא שלישי למראות תלמוד לומר לבנה לבנה היא לבנה (היא) ואין למעלה הימינה, וכמה תהא לבנוניתה כשלג שנאמר והנה מרים מצורעת כשלג.
    “White baheret”—I only know that baheret is white, whence do we know this of seʾet? The text teaches below (v. 10) “white seʾet.” Whence do we know this about other appearances? The text teaches “and if baheret.” Perhaps just as it is the third to be listed in the Torah it is also the third level of appearance? The text teaches “white” it is white and there is no [appearance] higher than it. How white must it be? Like snow, for it says (Num 12:10): “And Miriam was afflicted with tzaraʿat like snow.”

    As for the Sifrei Zuta, see the text and my discussion in n. 12 above.

  18. Editor’s note: For some discussion of what this may be, see Yitzhaq Feder, “Tzaraat in Light of Its Mesopotamian Parallels,” TheTorah (2017); Chaim Trachtman, “Tzaraat as Cancer,” TheTorah (2016).

  19. “Scales” in NJPS (revised ed., 1992), the New American Bible (revised ed., 2010), and “diseased” in the NRSVue. For “disease” I count 16 different English translations listed on biblegateway.com.

  20. This description of tzaraʿat, its relationship to leprosy, and the position of biblical scholars on the issue is taken from David P. Wright and Richard N. Jones, Anchor Bible Dictionary, ed. David Noel Freedman et al., (New York, 1992), 4:277–280, s.v. “Leprosy.” See also Elinor Lieber, “Old Testament ‘Leprosy,’ Contagion and Sin,” Contagion: Perspectives from Pre-Modern Societies, ed. Lawrence Conrad and Dominik Wujastyk (Aldershot: Taylor & Francis, 2000), 99–136. On “like snow” being a reference not to color but to the flaky texture of the snow, see also Athalya Brenner, Colour Terms in the Old Testament (Sheffield UK: Bloomsbury, 1982), 82. Further on the color of tzaraʿat (green, red, or reddish-white as well as white) see Leviticus 13:13, 42, 49.

  21. Bekhor Shor continues by explaining that they were not bothered by the marriage to Zipporah, a Midianite, since Moses was in exile at the time and had no other choice.

  22. Several biblical texts seem to argue for or against the acceptability of intermarriage. In early texts, only certain local enemies were forbidden (e.g., Moabites Ammonites in Deuteronomy 23:4, and Canaanites in Deuteronomy 7:3), but the issue became especially acute in Second Temple period polemics, where we begin to see blanket prohibitions against exogamy. For some discussion, see David Glatt-Gilad, “The Prohibition of Joining the Assembly of the Lord,” TheTorah (2015); Jacob L. Wright and Tamara Cohn Eskanazi, “Contrasting Pictures of Intermarriage in Ruth and Nehemiah,” TheTorah (2015); Naomi Graetz, “The Dinah Story: A Missed Opportunity for Intermarriage and Conversion,” TheTorah (2014).

  23. [23] For bibliography on this point, see Goldenberg, Curse of Ham, 229–230, n. 17; and Karen Strand Winslow, “Framing Zipporah: Early Jewish and Christian Memories of Moses’ Wife” (PhD diss. Univ of Washington, 2003), 104–105. Colin Kidd, The Forging of Races: Race and Scripture in the Protestant Atlantic World, 1600–2000 (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2006), 41, mentions two early works, one of which dates from 1694, that objected to the notion that it was the Kushite’s blackness, not her foreignness, that was disturbing to Miriam and Aaron. Another author who made the argument was the Karaite, Aaron ben Joseph (d. ca. 1320) in his Sefer ha-Mivḥar we-Ṭuv ha-Misḥar (Gozlow, 1835), ad loc., Numbers, p. 11a.