The central wall of the northern stairs of Apadana palace, which shows Xerxes enthroned, with crown prince Darius behind the ruler. Wikimedia.
Persia’s Achaemenid Dynasty—If You Read the Bible Without History
Ezra-Nehemiah mentions only four of the twelve kings who ruled the Persian empire: Cyrus, Darius, Xerxes, and Artaxerxes. The book of Daniel also speaks of four Persian kings, and adds a fictional Darius the Mede as their precursor. Historically, the Achaemenid period lasted 220 years, but using only the kings mentioned in the Bible, rabbinic texts reconstruct a 52-year Persian period.
Published: March 22, 2024
|
Last Updated: September 7, 2026
The term Achaemenid comes from a supposed ancestor of both Darius and Cyrus, Achaemenis. For an overview of this period, see Zev Farber, “The 220-Year History of the Achaemenid Persian Empire,” TheTorah (2017); Matt Waters, A Concise History of the Achaemenid Empire 550-330 BCE (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2014). For fuller presentations, see Pierre Briant, From Cyrus to Alexander: A History of the Persian Empire (trans. Peter T. Daniels; Winona Lake: Eisenbrauns, 2002 [orig. French, 1996]); A. T. Olmstead, History of the Persian Empire (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1948). For a detailed presentation of the ancient sources, see Amélie Kuhrt, The Persian Empire: A Corpus of Sources from the Achaemenid Period (London: Routledge Press, 2007).
For a discussion of how the name Xerxes becomes Ahasuerus in Hebrew, see Mitchel First, “If Achashverosh Is Xerxes, Is Esther His Wife Amestris?” TheTorah (2016).
Historically, Cyrus ruled for twenty years, and was killed in 530 B.C.E. on campaign against the Massagetae (modern day Uzbekistan). He was succeeded by his son Cambyses, who ruled for eight years (d. 522 B.C.E.), after which another son, Bardiya ruled shortly, but was deposed by Darius, a general not part of the royal family. Thus, if read against the backdrop of Persian history, the halt in Temple construction actually lasts approximately 25 years, from year 2 of Cyrus though the reigns of Cambyses and Bardiya, up to the accession of Darius.
See Seder Olam Rabbah, ch. 29. As Abraham ibn Ezra notes, the problem with this is that year 12 is not the beginning of Ahasuerus’ rule. A critical perspective might suggest that each offers a different tradition or memory based on the same historical events, but this is not an approach attractive to traditional scholars.
In fact, putting aside the absence of Cambyses, one thing that works nicely with this reconstruction is the order of the first Persian kings, since Xerxes was the son of Darius and ruled after him, and Artaxerxes ruled after that.
This verse, and the section it is part of, is in Aramaic. The book of Ezra, like the book of Daniel, switches between Aramaic and Hebrew.
Lisbeth S. Fried, Ezra: A Commentary (Sheffield: Sheffield Phoenix Press, 2017 [orig. 2015]), 200. Scholars debate why it was inserted here. Fried (ibid) suggests was to add drama, Tamara Eskanazi suggests it was to connect the building of the wall with the building of the Temple, without paying attention to chronology, while Hugh Williamson suggests it was to soften the harsh response of the Judeans to the Samarians by showing that the Samarians were really enemies after all. See Tamara C. Eskanazi, In an Age of Prose (Atlanta, GA: Scholars Press, 1988), 84, 188–189; Hugh G. M. Williamson, Ezra-Nehemiah, Word Biblical Commentary (1985) 56–57. See also discussion in Sara Japhet, עזרא-נחמיה [Ezra-Nehemia], מקרא לישראל [A Bible Commentary for Israel] (Tel Aviv: Am Oved, 2019), 137–139. Other solutions once preferred by scholars, such as changing the names of the two kings to Cambyses and Bardiya, or assuming the Darius mentioned in the later verses is Darius II, are no longer supported, says Williamson, by virtually any scholars.
In this account, while the Jews rebuild the Temple, a governor named Tattenai asks them what authority they have to do this, and they respond on that of the previous king, Cyrus. Tattenai then writes to Darius to learn whether this is in fact true, and Darius checks the records and confirms it. He thus commands Tattenai to assist.
Placing Ahasuerus/Xerxes in the period before the reconstruction of the Temple connects to the many rabbinic midrashim that see him as a force for not rebuilding the Temple. For more on this see, Malka Z. Simkovich, Zev Farber, and David Steinberg, “Ahasuerus and Vashti: The Story Megillat Esther Does Not Tell You,” TheTorah (2018).
His work is lost, but is quoted by Abraham ibn Ezra in his gloss to Daniel 11:2.
The reason he rejects ibn Gikatilla’s reading is because, based on the 70-year count between the destruction of the Temple and its rebuilding according to Daniel (see discussion later), there would have been no time for both Ahasuerus (ruled 14 years) and another king to have ruled between Cyrus and Darius.
Artaxerxes is the king during the time of Ezra and Nehemiah, and thus dominates the rest of the book, but his appearance in chs. 1–6 is artificial.
Many articles have been written trying to make sense of the rabbinic reconstruction of the Persian Period. Here I follow the contours of the analysis laid out in Chaim Milikowsky, סדר עולם: מהדורה מדעית, פירוש ומבוא [Seder Olam: Critical Edition, Commentary and Introduction] (Jerusalem: Yad Ben Zvi, 2013), 2.462–475.
See also Yalqut Shimoni, Ezra, 1068. Although Ibn Ezra does not believe that the Darius, under whose auspices the Temple was completed, is the same as the Artaxerxes of Ezra and Nehemiah, he uses the name equivalence claim to solve a different problem. Ibn Ezra was apparently aware, from access to history books, that the name of the king who was defeated by Alexander was Darius (which is correct). He thus suggests that the real name of the Artaxerxes of Ezra and Nehemiah was Darius. (Historically speaking this is not correct; Darius III and Artaxerxes I were two different people separated by about a century.)
As already noted by R. Zerahiah HaLevi (1115–1186), the derasha here is likely based on the use of the term “king” in the singular, in reference to all three individuals (see his Meor commentary on the Talmud ad loc.):
כיון שכתוב מלך פרס ולא נאמר מלכי פרס נראה לנו מזה כי שלשה שמות היו לו.
Since it says “king of Persia” and it doesn’t say “kings of Persia,” we can see from this that he had three names.
See discussion in Milikowsky, Seder Olam, 2.505. R. Zerahiah himself is so bothered by this that he suggests that the gemara is merely claiming that the last king of Persia had three names, not that this shrinks the number of kings from three to two:
ואין זה כורש המלך שהיתה הפקידה בתחלת מלכותו שהוא היה הראשון ממלכי פרס שמלך בבל אחר דריוש המדי, וזה המלך האחרון שהרגו אלכסנדרוס, והוא היה בן אסתר כדברי רבותינו.
This is not the King Cyrus who gave the order [to allow Jews to return to Judea] in the beginning of his reign, who was the first king of Persia, who ruled Babylon after Darius the Mede. This was [instead] the final king of Persia, who was killed by Alexander, and he was the son of Esther, as our rabbis have said.
Artaxerxes I in fact ruled for more than 40 years (465–424 B.C.E.).
The verse states:
נחמיה יג:ו וּבְכָל זֶה לֹא הָיִיתִי בִּירוּשָׁלִָם כִּי בִּשְׁנַת שְׁלֹשִׁים וּשְׁתַּיִם לְאַרְתַּחְשַׁסְתְּא מֶלֶךְ בָּבֶל בָּאתִי אֶל הַמֶּלֶךְ וּלְקֵץ יָמִים נִשְׁאַלְתִּי מִן הַמֶּלֶךְ. יג:ז וָאָבוֹא לִירוּשָׁלִָם...
Neh 13:6 During all this time, I was not in Jerusalem, for in the thirty-second year of King Artaxerxes of Babylon, I went to the king, and only after a while did I ask leave of the king to return. 13:7 When I arrived in Jerusalem…
This too is historically inaccurate. After Amel-Marduk (2 years), the king was Nergal-Sharezer (Neriglissar, 4 years), followed by Labashi-Marduk (only for a month), and finally Nabonidus (17 years), who was not part of the royal family. Belshazzar was never the king but the crown-prince (Nabonidus’ son). Nevertheless, it is much closer to the historical reality than the description of the Persian period.
Calling the Persian empire “Media,” as if they were one entity, fits with the language of the book of Esther, which refers to “Persia and Media” (Esth 1:3, 14, 18, 19) or “Media and Persia” (Esth 10:2), a phrase that also appears in the book of Daniel (Dan 5:28; 6:9, 13, 16; 8:20)
The order of the three kings in Genesis Rabbah is different than in most rabbinic reconstructions. Whether it had a different understanding of the period is unclear, but the later midrash collection, Sefer Aggadah, was sufficiently bothered by this that it changes the text (Lech Lecha 15:11):
שלשה מלכים על ישראל כורש ואחשורוש ודריוש בן אחשורוש
Three [Persian] kings ruled over Israel: Cyrus, Ahasuerus, and Darius the son of Ahasuerus.
Rabbinic interpretation sees significance in the number 62 here (Seder Olam ch. 28):
מה ת]למוד[ ל]ומר[ כבר שנין שתין ותרתין? אלא מלמד שביום שניכנס בו נבוכדנצר להיכל בימי יהויכין נולד סטנו דריוש,
What does the phrase “being already 62 years old” teach (i.e., what is the point of including this detail)? Rather it teaches that the day Nebuchadnezzar entered the Temple in time of Jehoiachin, Darius, his persecutor, was born.
The calculation—which is based on the rabbinic reconstruction of Babylonian history and not on actual historical information—goes as follows: Nebuchadnezzar reigned 45 years (historically 43), followed by his son Evil-Marodak/Amel-Marduk for 23 years (historically 2), followed by his son Belshazzar who ruled for 3 years (historically not a king). The total for the Babylonian dynasty then is 70 years. As Nebuchadnezzar conquered Jerusalem and took Jehoiachin into exile during his 8th regnal year (2 Kgs 24:12), when we subtract 8 from 70—the total length of the Babylonian Empire—we get 62, the age of Darius the Mede. If the book of Daniel—which was written in the Greek period—is working with a historical rubric similar to that of the rabbis, it is possible that this interpretation reflects the intention of the original author in making Darius the Mede that age.
It is hard to believe that the fact that the rabbis understand Darius the Persian to be the son of Ahasuerus of the Esther story, and the fact that Darius the Mede is described here as the son of Ahasuerus (the Mede) is a coincidence. Nevertheless, I do not have a suggestion at this point for how the two things are connected.
Since Nabonidus was often far from the capital, including the night it fell, Belshazzar was de facto in charge, which probably explains the confusion.
The specific calculation here is idiosyncratic to Seder Olam: Darius the Mede is not counted, Cyrus is given only two years (the third is described as having been partial), Ahasuerus is given 14, and Darius/Artaxerxes 36. In contrast, R. Abraham ibn Daud (ca.1110–ca.1180) counts Darius the Mede’s 1 year, gives Cyrus 3, Ahasuerus 16, and Darius/Artaxerxes 32, in his succinct and clear presentation of how rabbinic historiography understood the history of the Achaemenid Persian Empire from the fall of the Babylonian Kingdom to the conquest of Alexander the Great:
ספר הקבלה וכן היתה גאולתם של ישראל. נהרג בלשצר והמלך על מלכות כשדים דריוש בן אחשורוש מזרע מדי ומלך שנה אחת ומת. ומלך כורש ג' שנים. ובשנת אחת למלכו העיר יי את רוחו לבנות בית המקדש ואחר כך בטלו. ומלך הוא ג' שנים והרגתהו מלכת שטים מפני שהרג הוא את שני בניה, ומלכים גדולים היו. ומלך אחריו אחשורוש י"ו שנה ומת. ומלך בנו אשר ילדה לו אסתר הוא דריוש הוא ארתחשסתא. ובשנת שתים למלכו נבנה הבית. בן ז' היה במלכו ול"ב שנה מלך. ועלה עליו אלסכנדרוס מוקדון ויכהו וימיתהו בשנת ג' לבנין הבית. והכרת מלכות פרס והתחילה מלכות יון.
Book of Tradition Now the redemption of Israel came as follows: Belshazzar was killed, and Darius the son of Ahasuerus, of the seed of the Medes, was made king over the kingdom of the Chaldeans; and he reigned one year and died. Cyrus reigned after him for 3 years. In the first year of his reign, the Lord stirred up his spirit to build the Temple, and after that he ordered the construction halted. He reigned 3 years, when the queen of the Scythians killed him, for he had killed her two sons, both of whom were emperors. After him Ahasuerus reigned 16 years and died. He was succeeded by his son to whom Esther had given birth, namely Darius, who is the very same as Artaxerxes. In the second year of his reign, the Temple was built. He was seven years old when he began to reign, and he reigned 32 years. Alexander of Macedon went up against him and smote him and killed him. This was in the thirtieth year after the rebuilding of the Temple. Thus, the Persian Empire was cut off, and the empire of Greece began.
Text and English from, Gershon D. Cohen, The Book of Tradition (Sefer HaQabbalah) by Abraham ibn Daud: A Critical Edition with Translation and Notes, Judaica: Texts and Translations, 1st ser., 3 (Philadelphia: JPS, 1967), 9–10 [Heb.] 14–15 [Engl.].
For a discussion of how the rabbis interpret these verses, see Eyal Ben-Eliyahu, “Walled Cities ‘from the Time of Joshua’ Celebrate Shushan Purim – Why?” TheTorah (2020). Ibn Daud, in contrast, Xerxes/Ahasuerus rule for 16 years, perhaps because he sticks with 32 for Artaxerxes and wants to make up the two years elsewhere.
According to the rabbis, the Seleucid Greek period lasted 180 years, the Hasmonaean period 103 years, and the Herodian period 103 years.
Since this would make the Persian period 53 years—the 1 year of Darius the Mede is not part of the Persian Period but the Chaldean Period in Seder Olam’s thinking—instead of 52 (which is Seder Olam’s total based on yet another set of calculations), he solves this by saying that Cyrus’s 3rd year was only partial (מקוטע). For a detailed argument explaining all this, plus a host of other related pointes, see Milikowsky, Seder Olam, 2.469–475.
For an example of such a work, see Alexander Hool, The Challenge of Jewish History: The Bible, the Greeks and the Missing 168 Years, 2nd ed. (White Plains, NY: Mosaica Press, 2015). For a summary of the Jewish responses to this problem over the ages, see Mitchell First, Jewish History in Conflict: A Study of the Major Discrepancy between Rabbinic and Conventional Chronology (New York, NY: Jason Aaronson, 1997).
For a discussion of the difference between traditional study and contemporary academic study, see Zev Farber, “Traditional Torah Study Versus Scientific Analysis,” TheTorah (2018).
The line appears in his poem, “The Balad of East and West,” and refers to the differences between the British Empire and the natives of India.
The corrections in brackets, based on the text in the Yalkut Shimoni, were suggested by R. Ze’ev Wolf Einhorn of Horodna [Maharzu, d. 1862] in his commentary (ad loc.), and is based on the internal logic of the response, which must have been spoken to Darius the Mede and not by him.