The Flowering Staff: Proof of Aaron’s or the Levites’ Election?

The story of the flowering staff in its current form and context, confirms YHWH’s previous designation of the Aaronides as priests. Originally, however, the story presented YHWH’s selection of the tribe of Levi as his priestly caste.

SBL Style

Click to copy

"The Flowering Staff: Proof of Aaron’s or the Levites’ Election?." TheTorah.com, July 4, 2019. https://www.thetorah.com/article/the-flowering-staff-proof-of-aarons-or-the-levites-election.

APA Style

Click to copy

"The Flowering Staff: Proof of Aaron’s or the Levites’ Election?" (2019, July 4). TheTorah.com. https://www.thetorah.com/article/the-flowering-staff-proof-of-aarons-or-the-levites-election

The Flowering Staff: Proof of Aaron’s or the Levites’ Election?

Aaron holding a flowering staff, by Jacob Matham, after Karel van Mander (I), 1600 – 1604 (adapted). Rijksmuseum.nl

Categories:

Korach

Published: July 4, 2019

|

Last Updated: October 28, 2026

  1. This chapter is comprised of two main sources, with various supplementations. The story about Datan and Abiram is from a non-Priestly source, and I skip over it in this piece. I present here the Priestly story as we have it. Nevertheless, as I have noted elsewhere, the story itself is redacted. The older version makes no mention of Korah or Levites and is only about the chieftains. For a schematic presentation of my reconstruction, see, “Korah, Datan and Abiram: Source and Redaction Approach,” TheTorah.com (2013).

  2. As Korah is a redactional character, the exact manner of his death is kept vague. See discussion in, “How Did Korah Die?” TheTorah.com (2013); Rachel Adelman, “The Mysterious Literary Life and Death of Korah,” TheTorah.com (2014).

  3. For more on the how this story developed, see my, “Why the Fire Pans Were Used to Plate the Altar,” TheTorah.com (2018). For a discussion of how this story reflects an alternative Priestly tradition about the main altar from that which we see in the Tabernacle texts in Exodus, see my, “The Bronze Plating of the Altar: Numbers Versus Exodus,” TheTorah.com (2018).

  4. Rashbam appears to be bothered by the difficulty raised here. He suggests that when Moses saw the staff it only had budded, but when he brought it out to the Israelites it flowered and produced almonds in front of their very eyes! See his commentary at verse 23. There is no textual basis for this reading, but it shows Rashbam’s awareness of the problem.

  5. See Raanan Eichler, “Aaron’s Staff and the Priestly Asherah,” TheTorah.com (2019).

  6. In any event, it is not uncommon for later editors to add etiological motifs to earlier stories. See on this Isaac L. Seeligmann, “יסודות איטיולוגיים בהיסטוריוגראפיה המקראית” [Aetiological Elements in Biblical Historiography], Zion 26 (1961): 141–169; reprinted in Isaac L. Seeligmann, מחקרים בספרות המקרא [Studies in Biblical Literature], ed., Avi Hurvitz, Sara Japhet, and Emanuel Tov (Jerusalem: Magnes, 1996), 11–45. This would be another example of this phenomenon.

  7. In actuality, verse 25 implies that the staff never left Moses’ hand as YHWH tells Moses to return Aaron’s staff to the sanctuary but never tells him to go to Aaron and take it back from him. This discontinuity with verse 24, which states that all the leaders took back their staffs, further betrays the secondary origin of verses 25–26.

  8. The traditional commentaries, however, take verse 18b as an explanation for the fact that only one name, that of Aaron, would appear on the staff of Levi even though this tribe is divided between Aaronides and Levites. It thus clarifies verse 18a. See Rashi, Hizkuni, Ibn Ezra and Ramban. If we follow this interpretation, verse 18b would have to be deemed secondary as well.

  9. Editor’s note: For more on the Korah story as anti-Levite polemic, see, Adele Berlin, “Joining Rebellions: Dathan and Abiram Merge with Korah, Leader of the Levites” TheTorah.com (2013); Ely Levine, “The Historical Circumstances that Inspired the Korah Narrative,” TheTorah.com (2015).

  10. Editor’s note: For more on competition between different priestly houses, see Mark Leuchter, “How All Kohanim Became Sons of Aaron,” TheTorah.com (2019).

  11. The commentators disagreed as to whether the staff vindicated Aaron and his priesthood (Rashi at verse 25) or the Levite tribe in contrast with the firstborn of the tribes (Ramban at verse 25).

  12. For the understanding that Aaron’s staff was one of the twelve, see Ramban at verse 17-18. For other opinions see John Gray, Numbers (ICC), p. 214.

  13. See Ibn Ezra on verse 23, who understands the word מטה as implicitly repeated: מטה אהרן, מטה לבית לוי.

  14. See, e.g., “before the testimony where I appear to you” (לפני העדת אשר אועד לכם שמה) of v. 19, which may originally have simply been “before YHWH” (לפני י־הוה), as in v. 24.

  15. Editor’s note: Many documentary scholars identify this text as E. See Zev Farber, “The Other Ohel Moed,” TheTorah.com (2015).