An illustration of the Tomb painting from Beni Hasan, Egypt. A figure named Abisha and identified by the title Hyksos leads brightly garbed Semitic clansmen into Egypt to conduct trade. Dating to about 1890 B.C.E. Wikimedia
The Israelites Are Not the Hyksos!
The hidden polemic in the Torah’s note that “Israel did not escape by way of the Philistine coastal route”
Published: April 26, 2016
|
Last Updated: September 7, 2026
See: H.J. Katzenstein, “Philistines, History,” in ABD vol. 5, 326–328.
The way along the Mediterranean Coast was known in the classical world as Via Maris and in the ancient Egyptian literature as “The Ways of Horus.” See: E.D. Oren, “Ancient Military Roads between Egypt and Cana’an’,” Bulletin of the Anglo-Israel Archaeological Society (1982): pp. 20–24; ibid. – “Ways of Horus in North Sinai,” in Egypt, Israel, Sinai: Archaeological and Historical relationships in the Biblical Period (ed. A.F. Rainey; Tel-Aviv : Tel-Aviv University, 1987), 69–119.
See: I. Beit-Arieh, “The Route through Sinai: Why the Israelites Fleeing Egypt Went South,” BAR 14/3 (1988): 28–37.
See: G.E. Mendenhall, “Midian,” ABD vol. 4, pp. 815–818. I am convinced that we have to identify Midian with north-west Hijaz (east of the Gulf of Aqaba).
On this ground, P remains a possible source, but at least for v. 3:12 this is impossible, since the Priestly version of Moses’ appointment only begins in ch. 6. (See David Frankel, “The Priestly Moses.”)
For more on this, see my TABS essay, “Finding the Source of Water in Marah.”
On hidden polemics see: Y. Amit, Hidden Polemics in Biblical Narrative (Leiden: Brill, 2000).
The book was lost but the sections, which are related to the Israelites, are quoted in Josephus Flavius: Against Apion. For more on Manetho, see Gary A. Rendsburg’s TABS essay, “Ancient Egypt: An Overview of Its History.”
Hor is the Egyptian theophoric element for the god Horus. The biblical name Yaaqov is missing a theophoric element, but versions of the name with one, like Yaaqov-El, are attested in epigraphic finds. See discussion in J.C. De Moor, The Rise of Yahwism: The Roots of Israelite Monotheism (2nd ed.; BETL 91; Leuven: Leuven University Press and Uitgeverij Peeters, 1997), 326, and bibliography cited in n. 85.
See: Donald B. Redford, “An Egyptian Perspective on the Exodus Narrative,” in Egypt, Israel, Sinai, (ed. Anson Rainey; Tel Aviv: Tel-Aviv University, 1987), 137–161.
See: Against Apion, 1, 73:1,6. Ramesses II build on the ruins of Avaris his new city Pi-Ramesses, the city that according to the bible was built by the Israelites (Exod 1:11) and it was the starting point of the Exodus (Exod 12:37; Num 33:3).
See: Redford, above, pp. 150–151; Jan Assmann, Moses the Egyptian, The Memory of Egypt in Western Monotheism (Cambridge: Harvard University, 1997), 41.
See: Miriam Lichtheim, “The Autobiography of Ahmose Son of Abana” in Ancient Egyptian Literature 2, (ed. Miriam Lichtheim; Berkeley: University of California Press, 1976), 12–15.
See: J.M. Weinstein, “Hyksos, Archaeology” ABD 3, pp. 344–348, esp. p. 346.
See: Weinstein, above. Another suggested identification for Sharuhen was at Tell Far’ah (south). See: R. Liwak, “Sharuhen,” ABD 5, pp. 1,163–1165. Tell Far’ah is closer to the costal road than to any other road to Egypt.