The Judgement of Solomon (adapted), William Blake, ca. 1799. Wikimedia
Deuteronomy’s Justice System: Real and Ideal
The books of Samuel and Kings portray monarchs—specifically, David, Solomon, and Ahab—as Israel’s chief judicial authority, hearing cases and dispensing justice. Deuteronomy, however, leaves the king out of its justice system, assigning authority instead to local elders and judges, or else to a central court. Does this system reflect how justice actually worked in ancient Israel—or an ideal meant to replace royal justice?
Published: August 17, 2015
|
Last Updated: October 28, 2026
Moshe Weinfeld, “Judge and Officer in Ancient Israel and in the Ancient Near East”, Israel Oriental Studies 7 (1977), p. 83. See also Mark Leuchter’s TABS essay on this subject, http://thetorah.com/judges-who-are-magistrates. Alexander Rofé went even further than Weinfeld, claiming that sofer and shoṭer actually are synonymous, the former being preferred in most of biblical historiography, the latter, derived in his opinion from the Aramaic, used in the Pentateuch and Joshua for its “archaic quality.” Alexander Rofé, “The Organization of the Judiciary in Deuteronomy (Deut. 16.18-20; 17.8-13; 19.15; 21.22-23; 24.16; 25.1-3)”, in P.M. Michele Daviau, John W. Wevers and Michael Weigl (eds.), The World of the AramaeansI, Sheffield: Sheffield Academic Press, 2001, p. 98-99. Only in Chronicles do the two appear together, perhaps because the much later writer of Chronicles thought that they represented two different functions.
Nili Sacher Fox, In the Service of the King: Officialdom in Ancient Israel and Judah, Cincinnati: Hebrew Union College Press, 2000, p.192-196.
- In 1 Chron. 23:4, six thousand “שוטרים and judges” are appointed by David from among the Levites to serve in the Temple.
- In 1 Chron. 26:29, Chenaniah and his sons, of the Izharite Levites, were appointed “for outside duties for Israel” (i.e. outside the Temple), “as שוטרים and judges.”
- In 2 Chron. 19:11, the שוטרים function as judges, are from the Levites, and serve under the priests.
- In 1 Chron. 27:1, the שוטרים are listed in a non-Levitical context, one that seems more military or administrative, similar to how they are presented in Deut. 1:15.
- In 2 Chron. 26:11 the שוטרים also seem to have a military-administrative function: “Uzziah had an army… according to the muster made by the Jeiel the scribe (סופר) and Maaseiah the שוטר, under the direction of Hananiah, of the king’s officers.”
- 2 Chron. 34:13 tells us that “over the burden bearers and directing all who did work in every kind of service; and some of the Levites were scribes, and שוטרים, and gatekeepers.”
Josh. 8:33, for instance, tells how “all Israel and its elders and שוטרים and judges” participated in the ceremony at Mounts Gerizim and Ebal. In 23:2, Joshua calls “all Israel – its elders and chiefs and judges and שוטרים”. The same groups are repeated in 24:1. In Judges and Samuel we find both kind of “elders” – local elders at Succoth in Judges 8:16 and in Gilead in 11:8, as opposed to “the elders of the edah” in 21:16.
The exact meaning of these terms is uncertain. Compare the translation of NRSV, “If a judicial decision is too difficult for you to make between one kind of bloodshed and another, one kind of legal right and another, or one kind of assault and another—any such matters of dispute in your towns”, to that of NJPS, “If a case is too baffling for you to decide, be it a controversy over homicide, civil law, or assault – matters of dispute in your courts”.
This is not the only version of that story. More famous, is the version in Exodus 18, in which Jethro, Moses’ Midianite father-in-law, sees how Moses judges the people “from morning to evening”, and advises Moses to set up a judicial hierarchy, with officers of tens, fifties, hundreds, and thousands judging most matters, and only the most difficult cases being brought before Moses.
For more on which see the TABS essay by A. Avreich, “The Kohanim the Leviim.”
Amnon Shapira, Democratic Values in the Hebrew Bible, Tel-Aviv: Hakibbutz Hameuchad, 2009, p. 324-326 (Hebrew).
They are called Deuteronomistic because of their obvious linguistic, ideological, and theological affinity to Deuteronomy.
The word שפט here probably means “to lead” rather that “to sit in judgment”.