Is the Soul Immortal?

Is there a difference between human and animal souls? Is there a hereafter at all, and if so, does righteousness or wickedness affect it? These questions, discussed by Greek philosophers, inspired the Judean discourse of the Hellenistic period. Ecclesiastes on one side, 1 Enoch and the Wisdom of Solomon on the other.

SBL Style

Click to copy

"Is the Soul Immortal?." TheTorah.com, September 29, 2023. https://www.thetorah.com/article/is-the-soul-immortal.

APA Style

Click to copy

"Is the Soul Immortal?" (2023, September 29). TheTorah.com. https://www.thetorah.com/article/is-the-soul-immortal

Is the Soul Immortal?

The Soul Hovering over the Body, by William Blake, 1805-1808, illustration in Robert Blair's The Grave. Wikimedia

Published: September 29, 2023

|

Last Updated: September 7, 2026

  1. The verse itself is very difficult to parse. In his notes, Robert Alter writes “This string of words is not intelligible in the Hebrew and continues the patch of scribal scrambling that spreads over verses 15–18.” See Robert Alter, The Hebrew Bible (New York: Norton, 2019), 3.686–687.

  2. Editor’s note: For a discussion of this term in the Bible, see Meghan Henning, “No Heaven or Hell, Only Sheʾol,” TheTorah (2021).

  3. They are sometimes referred to as rĕp̄āʾı̂m or ʾiṭṭı̂m.

  4. They are depicted as being quiet, unable to praise God like the living do (Ps 6:6, 30:10), and God pays no attention to them and does not work miracles on their behalves (Ps 88:6, 11). While there is no way back from it (Job 7:9), necromancers can bring about conversation with the dead (1 Sam 28).

  5. The system of breath bringing life, and loss of breath ending it, reflects the human (and animal) life cycle throughout time:

    איוב לג:ד רוּחַ אֵל עָשָׂתְנִי וְנִשְׁמַת שַׁדַּי תְּחַיֵּנִי.
    Job 33:4 The spirit of God formed me; the breath of Shaddai sustains me.
    איוב לד:יד אִם יָשִׂים אֵלָיו לִבּוֹ רוּחוֹ וְנִשְׁמָתוֹ אֵלָיו יֶאֱסֹף. לד:טו יִגְוַע כָּל בָּשָׂר יָחַד וְאָדָם עַל עָפָר יָשׁוּב.
    Job 34:14 If He but intends it, He can call back his spirit and breath; 34:15 all flesh would at once expire, and mankind return to dust.
  6. While none of his writings have survived, his view is quoted extensively in many ancient Greek scientific works, especially by Aristotle.

  7. Translation of G.M.A. Grube in John M. Cooper, ed., Plato: Complete Works (Indianapolis, IN: Hackett, 1997), 71.

  8. Although some biblical texts use the terms for “spirit” in derivative meanings, such as “living being” for nĕšāmâ (Deut 20:16, Ps 150:6) or “consciousness/personality” for rûaḥ (Hos 5:4; Ezek 11:19; Ps 51:52), these usages do not express a dichotomy between a soul and a body in the sense that the former can somehow separate and live on independently from the latter, as if it was able to store the person’s life essence on its own. In the Hellenistic period, however, these secondary meanings take on a life of their own. Indeed, a person’s inner, “spiritual” life (rûaḥ) and bodily existence are sometimes described as conflicting, with the spiritual life seen as the more elevated or important aspect, connecting the person to the eternity of the divine world.

  9. Editor’s note: For more on this text, see the section “Enoch and the Separation of Good and Wicked after Death,” in Henning, “No Heaven or Hell, Only Sheʾol.” For more on the Book of Watchers in general, see Miryam T. Brand, “The Benei Elohim, the Watchers, and the Origins of Evil,” TheTorah (2016).

  10. Other texts from the Hellenistic period also demonstrate a belief in the immortality of the soul. Among the Apocrypha and Pseudepigrapha, we see this belief in The Wisdom of Solomon (see below), the Testament of Abraham, and the Testament of Job. In Qumran, this view is found in the Damascus Document and the Thanksgiving Hymns.

  11. We see similar views in Philo, also from this period.

  12. Translation: H St. J. Thackery, Loeb’s Classical Library 210.

  13. Translation: H St. J. Thackery, Loeb’s Classical Library 203.

  14. Editor’s note: For more on Ben Sira and his thinking, see Michael Satlow, “The Wisdom of Ben Sira: How Jewish?” TheTorah (2015).

  15. Translation is that of Michael Knibb as presented by Miryam Brand in Outside the Bible 2:1441–1442.

  16. In contrast, Enoch states, the wicked will receive severe punishment:

    Enoch 103:7 Know that their souls will be made to go down into Sheol, and they will be wretched, and their distress [will be] great; 103:8 and in darkness and in chains and in burning flames your spirits will come to the great judgment, and the great judgment will last for all generations forever. Woe to you, for you will not have peace.

  17. Another example of debates in this period about the afterlife is mentioned in Josephus’ description of the debate between the Sadducees, who did not believe in afterlife, and the Pharisees and the Essenes who did. See Josephus, Judean Wars 2:11 §154; 2:14 §162–165; Judean Antiquities 18 1:3 §14, 1:4 §16. See also Matthew 22:23, Acts of the Apostles 23:6. Editor’s note: See also Devorah Dimant, “The Valley of Dry Bones and the Resurrection of the Dead,” TheTorah (2018).