Moses Electing the Seventy Elders (detail), Jacob de Wit, 1695–1754. Rijksmuseum
Eldad and Medad Successfully Challenge Moses’ Control over Prophecy
When Eldad and Medad prophesy in the camp, Joshua zealously presses for their incarceration. Moses, however, exclaims that all the people should ideally be prophets.
Published: June 6, 2014
|
Last Updated: September 7, 2026
I believe that the contradictory evidence concerning the question of whether or not Eldad and Medad belonged to the seventy elders indicates that the entire episode of Eldad and Medad constitutes a secondary expansion. The original continuation of verse 25 is in verse 30. In this form of the text, all seventy elders went out to the tent, prophesied, and returned to the camp as assistants to Moses. Joshua played no role in this form of the story. Note that verse 30 fails to mention the return of the lad to the camp. Only the Eldad and Medad episode sees the speaking in ecstasy as a sign that one is a prophet. The larger story does not express this idea. Verse 30 refers to the seventy who return to the camp simply as ‘the elders of Israel.’
Pertinent here are the bold words of Seder Eliyahu Rabbah (ch. 10):
מעיד אני עלי את השמים ואת הארץ, בין גוי ובין ישראל, בין איש ובין אשה, בין עבד בין שפחה, הכל לפי מעשה שעושה כך רוח הקודש שורה עליו.
“I bring the heavens and the earth as my witness, whether gentile or Jew, man or woman, slave or maidservant, the holy spirit dwells upon each individual in accordance with how they act.”
This Midrash may be said to go even beyond the message of the Eldad and Medad story. In the biblical story, Moses expresses the wish that the divine spirit would be given to all of the “people of the Lord.” The Midrash includes all human beings.