Silhouette image of a woman raising hands towards heaven in sun set time. 123rf
Bringing It All Together: The Interactive Paradigm of Divine-Human Relations & Conclusion
Published: March 25, 2014
|
Last Updated: September 7, 2026
This method of depicting the difference between R. Shneur Zalman of Lyadi’s view of reality as opposed to that of R. Hayim’s has been suggested by Shalom Rosenberg – see his essay, “Kabbalistic Doctrine in ‘Nefesh Ha-Hayim'” (Hebrew), Shana B’Shana (Jerusalem: Dept. of Torah Education of the Ministry of Education, 1998), pp. 357-370. Rosenberg applies the comparison in precisely the opposite manner, relating the theater image to the Hassidic view and that of the cinema to the Mitnaggedim. Despite appearances to the contrary, I do not believe that this reflects a basic disagreement between us regarding the nature of the two systems, but rather a difference as to where the definitive point of “hiding” in each of them lies.
A.I. Kook, Orot ha-Emunah, 25
For a slightly different interpretation, suggesting that the superiority of the heretic’s relationship to the Torah lies in his ability to appreciate the sublime value of its contents, rather than focusing upon the external circumstances of its transmission, see Amit Kula, Existential or Non-Essential, p. 134.
See in this connection R. Kook’s equation of exile and estrangement from God with estrangement from a sense of our authentic selves, in a passage entitled: “The Search for the Essential Self” (Heb.), Orot ha-Kodesh III (Jerusalem: Mosad harav Kook, 1985), p. 140, The ending of this passage with the verse “I am the Lord, thy God, who delivers you from Egypt in order to be your God, I am the Lord”, referring to this delivery in present tense, suggests an audacious interpretation of the last four words. For expression of similar ideas in a postmodern vein that challenge the focusing of religion on cognitive claims rather than on the way that God (as symbol) is integrally connected with our experience of ourselves and the way we engage with the world, see Jan-Olav Henriksen, Relating God and the Self: Dynamic Interplay (Surrey: Ashgate, 2013).